Depositors still in demonitisation trap

*Will remonitisation recoup Rs 1.28 lakh cr loss

Why ATMs going dry?

And ATMs in Capital Complex going dry has become the order of the day as was reported by this daily quoting Arunachal Chamber of Commerce & Industry general secretary Tarh Nachung. The SBI being state’s lead bank with 57 branches total state’s 180 bank branches should facilitate flow of currency notes from the RBI. The SBI branches suffered for six months for no currency notes after demonitisation, indicating that move was totally unplanned.

In such situation, whom should the people approach is a million dollar question?

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR | Apr 11| Caught in the trap of demonitisatgion effected on 08.11.16 midnight as well as remonitisation, the national economy is visibly doomed as the ground realities smack policy objectives.

Arunachal Pradesh, remotest state of India far away from New Delhi, is the best example as was experienced in a SBI branch today. A local gentleman walked into a senior officer’s chamber to charge him for making mockery of bank depositors as all bank ATMs were empty. As he threatened to demolish all ATMs, the officer quipped:  “Behave like a gentleman as you are and stop such threatening without knowing the facts and figures”.

Responding to the man’s question as to why the bank is offering only Rs 10,000 against a need of Rs 1,00,000, the officer asked if he had deposited Rs one lakh in cash which silenced him. “When public don’t deposit cash and the RBI has stopped supplying currency notes since February last, where from the bank would meet currency demands of all public except transferring from account to account” he reasoned, adding “watch which investor is getting more than Rs 10,000 and report back”.

The SBI despite being state’s lead bank with 57 branches of state’s total 180 bank branches is mandated to meet supply of currency notes, but with the RBI failing to facilitate such flow the SBI has become hapless. In such a situation, whom should the people approach is a million dollar question?

Note ban objective?: Prime Minister Narendra Modi referred to “black money” 18 times in his maiden speech on demonetisation on 08.11.016. But, how many times did he refer to digitization, cashless economy or integration of economy? Not even once. (The Quint)

The narrative of note ban has slowly changed over months. From a war on black money, the GoI gradually described this as a righteous war of the honest against the dishonest. Digitisation and a move towards a cashless economy were also introduced as intended objectives of demonetisation. Why the narrative continued to shift is a million dollar question?

Firstly, digital money transfer still remains a distant dream with internet playing hide & seeks in Capital Complex bank branches while GoI’s Digidham only a lip-service. Secondly, banks usually don’t divulge the amount of currency notes received from the RBI, though much less than needed as the senior officer mentioned during his argument.

Eight months after demonetization, the GST was rolled out as a one-two punch to growth, though intended to formalise Indian economy. The Indian economy had started decelerating even before demonetisation. After hitting 9.1% in March 2016 quarter, GDP growth had been on a gradual decline. Thus, the twin (demonetisation & GST) shocks hit the weakening economy hard. Both were hardest on job creating sectors, like manufacturing, which also have a large informal segment.

Demonitisation and its impacts?: The cost of withdrawing high-denomination currency notes to wipe out black money from the country will be about Rs 1.28 lakh crore during 50-day window till 30.12.16, the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) had said, adding the overall cost could be much higher leading to long-term impact on economy, as Economic Times had reported.

The demonitisation had invalidated 86% of Rs 17.8 lakh crore of currency in circulation on 28.10.16, the CMIE had estimated. “A steady stream of news reports of empty mandis, low footfalls at malls and drop in business in restaurants, stressed factories paint a grim picture of effects of a sudden withdrawal of liquidity from markets,” CMIE report said on Thursday.

Emphasizing that all estimates are conservative and limited to the 50-day window, CMIE had said the GoI and the RBI are estimated to bear a cost of Rs 16,800 crore, largely on account of printing new currency notes and transporting them to banks, ATMs and post offices.

The question of how effective demonetisation would be against tax evasion and black money was hotly debated. “By making an unexpected announcement that high-value currency would not be valid, the GoI thought that [cash] hoarders would be caught off guard,” How India Lives founder John Raja, a firm that analyses public data, told The National.

“Black money held in cash is a very small proportion of total illegal wealth,” economist C Rammanohar Reddy said. “Those who do hold stocks of cash are powerful enough to launder it and recycle it in different ways into the banking system.”

Even as early as January – three months after demonetisation kicked in – a Bloomberg report revealed that 97% of all invalided notes had already been returned to the RBI. That report was based on anonymous GoI source in the know of the process. However, the RBI then denied that figure as correct.

Demonetisation complete failure? Modi Govt had defended its move saying the benefits of demonetisation will create an impact on the country’s economy in the long run, Indian Express reported on 05.01.17.As much as 97% of currency notes, outlawed by the GoI on 08.11.16, have reportedly returned to banks, posing a huge question mark on PM Modi’s demonetisation move. Politically, too, Modi Govt had faced immense criticism from the Opposition as well as from within ruling National Democratic Alliance with ally Shiv Sena saying: Demonitisation had created a sense of fear that was witnessed during British Rule.

Opposition parties led by Congress had called for a probe into PM’s move to demonetise note asking that a committee be setup and a white paper be presented in Parliament.

Interestingly, Union Finance Ministry had topped the list of ministries to receive maximum number of RTI applications in 2016-17. It also happened to be the one to reject the maximum number of requests under the RTI Act for disclosure of information. It had received 1,51,186 RTI applications and rejected 18.41%  amounting to 27,833, CNN-News18 had reported on March 16 last quoting  Central Information Commission’s 2016-17 annual report.

Demonitisation was withdrawing high value currency notes from circulation while remonetization, just the reverse, aimed at restoring status of legal tender. Demonetization is followed by remonetization to replace old discontinued currency with new currency in the economy. Whether the demonitisation or remonitisation yielded any result or not, but people the hardest way learnt the meaning of both new words unheard so far.

Remonetization is an uphill task, if the facts and figures are any indication. According to 2016 RBI data, ‘taking into account the current capacity of printing presses for printing currency notes, PM Modi’s deadline cannot be met, come what may! Another major question is – how much currency does the Modi Govt want to put back into circulation? What forms the crux of the problem is that India’s printing presses don’t have the capacity to print 500 rupee notes in sufficient numbers.

RBI has four printing presses at Dewas (MP), Nasik (Maharashtra), Salboni (West Bengal) and Mysuru (Karnataka), Ikshit had reported on 15.12.16 in Remonetization after demonetization will take at least 4 more months – the math explained!

* According to RBI’s 2016 annual report, the combined capacity of these four presses is of printing around 2,670 crore notes a year, or around 7.4 crore notes a day.

* If these presses are made to run three shifts a day instead of two, the printing capacity can be pushed up to 11.1 crore notes a day.

* However, less than half of the machines at these presses are equipped to print the security features on higher denomination notes of Rs 500 and above.

* This means that if all four printing presses print 500 rupee denomination notes for 24 hours a day, they would be at best able to churn out 5.56 crore of 500 rupee notes a day. This means that our presses can only print Rs 2,778 crore of Rs 500 notes in value every day.

The Modi Govt had made an arrangement for printing 200 crore (roughly Rs 4 lakh crore in value) Rs 2,000 notes even before the announcement of demonetization. So, they became the first new currency notes to be dispensed by ATMs and that’s why there are so many Rs 2,000 notes in circulation, while Rs 500 denomination notes are hardly seen.

Thus, The key to the problem lies in the smaller denomination notes of Rs 100, Rs 50, Rs 20 and Rs 10, which according to RBI’s annual report, value Rs 2.19 lakh crore.

Related posts