Are Arunachalees ready for Festival of ballots?

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, Mar 10: Arunachal Pradesh, which boasts of numerous sobriquets, is also known as ‘Land of Festivals’ as 26 major tribes and 105 sub-tribes celebrate their unique festival reflecting their age-old unique cultures.

But ‘Festival of ballots’ or ‘Battle of ballots’ could considered the greatest festival of state’s predominantly tribal population, which represents a highly participatory society because of the inbuilt democratic setup. They are still governed by their traditional local councils or Gaon Burah Institutions (GBIs), known in different names by different tribes.

Their democratic spirit has been proved in election conducted since in 1978 as below records of state Nirvachan Bhawan clearly give conclusive proof:

Year      Voters         Votes polled      %         Uncontested seats

1978       2, 32, 711    1, 64, 600        70.73     Dirang-Kalaktang, Niausa-Kanubari 

1980    2, 58, 197      1, 80,045          69.73     Niausa-Kanubari

1984    3, 11, 219       2, 37, 584       76.34      Koloriang 

1990    4, 89, 299       3, 56, 286       72.82      Tawang, Mukto, Koloriang

1995    5, 34, 001       4, 33, 657       81.20      Tawang, Mukto, Koloriang

1999    5, 81, 663      4, 24, 337        72.95      Tawang, Anini, Roing, Khonsa East

2004    6, 55, 984      4, 50, 452        68.77      Mukto, Dirang, Sagalee 

2009    7, 25, 984      5, 75, 645        79.38      Lumla, Mukto

2014    6, 33, 205      5, 11, 510        80.78      Sagalee, Mukto, Nacho, Pakke-Kessang,

                                                                             Mebo, Seppa West, Dirang, Doimukh,

                                                                             Palin, Nyapin & Taliha

These GBIs have legal sanctity to settle petty to murder cases, and enjoy the confidence of the people in the absence of an independent judiciary.  The deputy commissioner-cum-district magistrates refer many cases to the councils or GBIs justifying its relevance while high court judges have lauded the system for its effective trial at low cost to grant speedy and honourable justice to victims.

While lauding the relevance of time-tested GBIs set up under Assam Frontier (Administration of Justice) Regulation 1945, while inaugurating legal aid centre at Papu village here on 05-04-12, Supreme Court of India’s judge justice Altamus Kabir, also the executive chairman of National Legal Services Authority had, commented: “No judge could claim to have known all the laws. The 1945 archaic customary law was enacted then to solve social problems. Though the GBs dispose of many complicated cases with highest 10 sittings at a stretch, but it needs mechanism to make them available for the seekers as the GBs complaint of lack of guidance for them.

“Aap hazzar sallo se judge ho, hum bhi judge hai’, we have to learn from each other. We do not want to break the GB system. There could be some defect in either system which should be removed to grant justice,” was the opinion of then Gauhati HC judge justice IA Ansari.

Then Chief Minister Nabam Take had termed the GBI a highly respected unique institution of the tribal society known for speedy and cost effective grant of justice.

The formation of Agency Council as the apex of a four-tier Panchayati Raj system on 03.12.69 after implementation of NEFA Panchayati Raj Regulation Act, 1967, re-designation of the council as Pradesh Council after the state (North Eastern Frontier Agency) attained Union Territory status on 20.-01.72, and conversion of the Agency Council to provisional Legislative Assembly on 15.08.78 strengthened the democratic spirit of the state people. The union territory graduated to parliamentary democracy only in 1978 with the conduct of first general election to 30-member house on 25.02.78 and installation of PK Thungon-led Janata Party (JP) Govt on 14.03.78.

However, launching campaign for free and fair elections by Arunachal Pradesh Catholic Association (APCA) on 12.08.18 by releasing a pamphlet of “Make Arunachal corruption-free state” is the most important aspect of the process since 1978 when this state had graduated to parliamentary democracy and earned the obnoxious distinction of practicing turncoat politics.

The state’s  future looks bleak due to rampant corruption, former chief minister Nabam Tuki had said, while APCC president-cum-APCA adviser Takam Sanjoy had exhorted the younger generation to listen to their inner voice as corruption beyond exchange of money encompasses morality and spirituality.  Referring to arrest of senior politicians, he had said that the bribe giver and taker are equally corrupt as no religion advocates corruption.

It is worth mentioning here that Young Mizo Association with support of powerful missionary groups had made election free from money and muscle power by launching reforms in 2008, which had succeeded with willing support of the people.

The APCA pamphlet quoted Lord Jesus: 1) “Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe make people blind to what is right and ruins the cause of those who are innocent”; 2) “When the king is concerned with justice, the nation will be strong, but when he is only concerned with money, he will ruin his country”; 3) “Show me a righteous ruler and I will show you a happy people. Show me a wicked ruler and I will show you a miserable people” & 4) “You are doomed, you sinful nation, you corrupt and evil people! Your sins drag you down!” Lord Buddha: “Power does not corrupt people, people corrupt power”; Bhagavad Gita: “Perform all works carefully guided by compassion” and Quran: 1) “The curse of Allah is upon the one who offers a bribe and the one who takes it” & “Do not eat each other’s wealth unjustly and do not bribe the judges”. With large section of Arunachalees being Christians, success of the campaign seems to be a foregone conclusion, a campaigner had said.

Interestingly, CM Khandu has been repeatedly making fervent appeals in his public addresses to make elections free from money. “Corruption in election is the curtain raiser to push corruption to entire system. If the election is won with money power “we won’t find good leaders”, he had said to a huge audience of annual Hornbill Festival on 08.01.18. This had moved me to write on 22.10.18- Will 2019 battle of ballots be free from money culture?

Whether the next election will be free from money culture and which party will capture how many seats would be known only after results of the hasting are announced. Till then wait and watch is the only reply to such questions, political pundits say.

Related posts