Will GoAP shed adhocsim for good governance?

Fruits after applying Win (Shree) crop

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

Adhocism has been thumb rule of consecutive Arunachal Pradesh governments since the state graduated to parliamentary form of democracy, instead of discarding it.

The last BJP government was no exception either despite maintaining law and order and good governance its top priority policy. Or else why unsanctioned police stations have been created at Nafra, Pangin, Oyan, Mebo, Nirjuli, Sunpura, Wakro, Chowkham and Hawai? Available strength is divided to run those nine PSs which neither allow the sanctioned PSs nor the unsanctioned ones to function effectively.

Who should be blamed? Not the police department, but adhocism of policy makers for which there are numerous glittering examples.

First, Chief Minister Pema Khandu impressed with ‘save life mission’ of Arunachal Vivekananda Vivekananda Yuva Shakti had marked its application to then chief secretary Shakuntala Gamlin for grant which went untraced despite repeated follow ups.

Second, global organic scientist Dr Nilmadhab Nanda, whose product Win (Shree) crop has been doing miracle in 40 nations by doubling crop production and tripling pulse production and helped Sikkim to go organic first in NE India, was urged by Prime Minister Narendra Modi at New York during top American CEOs’ meeting in September 2016 to return to India soon to popularise organic cultivation.

Dr Nanda during his repeated visit to Itanagar had highlighted his product to lawmakers, including CM Khandu & DyCM Chowna Mein at the initiative of Speaker Tenzing Norbu Thongdok in old assembly premises on 10.03.16 after presentation of budget.

His organic manure is produced by taking enzyme extracts from 101 different sea weed collected about 25-30 km sea bed from across the globe. This product has been certified by the US department of agriculture (USDA) and other reputed global organizations including Assam Agricultural University after conducting tests to prove its worth.

—————————————————————————————————————

Indian food demand and supply projections by 2030 – Indian Food Security Portal

Food demand in India is expected to increase significantly in the coming decades thanks to large population and income increases, expanding urbanization, and dietary changes. Simultaneously, India’s food self-sufficiency is expected to face significant challenges due to decreasing rates of agricultural productivity growth, scarce natural resources, and climate change. A recent chapter in International Trade and Food Security: The Future of Indian Agriculture estimates food demand and supply projections for India for 2020 and 2030. The supply-demand deficit or surplus expected for each commodity in 2020 and 2030. For various studied food products, estimates see a significant supply-demand deficit for fruits, a marginal deficit for meat, a moderate surplus for fish and sugar, and a large surplus for milk.

————————————————————————————————————-

Interestingly, Dr Nanda invited by Assam Chief Minister Sarbananda Sonowal on 18.03.17 was requested to supply the manure and also on request submitted a proposal to develop a biotechnology park by California-based Shree Biotech on PPP mode in identified location near Guwahati.  .

Dr Nanda accompanied with his wife Pushpalata Nanda-cum-marketing in-charge, on an invitation had met Meghalaya Chief Minister Conard Sangma at Shillong on 29.03.18 and was requested to facilitate agri-horticulture development of his sate by supplying his product. Moreover, Nilapuspa Energy Pvt. Ltd would set up to set up a 50-MW solar energy project at Garo hilltop proposed with Rs 500–700 crore investment. Thus, Meghalaya Govt has set organic farming target in 2, 40, 000 hectre by 2021-22.

Arunachal Opposition bench members led by leader Takam Pario on the floor of Assembly on 13.03.18 while recalling Dr Nanda’s presentation had questioned that when the GoAP had launched organic mission in 2017 to go organic but why no action was visible. However, it was then APAMB chairman Ngurang Pinch who had ordered products worth Rs 2 lakh after meeting Dr Nanda who had explained his dream to benefit the farming communities from his innovation.

Interestingly, Itanagar lawmaker Techi Kaso along with entrepreneur Tarh Nachung with a written request to procure the manure had approached CM Khandu, who had marked it to horticulture director to process. The file moved only after repeated follow ups but went missing in official channel never to be traced. Is this good governance?

Third, fund-crunched Arunachal Pradesh always craves for more central funds, but regrettably a huge chunk of which gets surrendered or lapsed for inability to spend it timely hurdled by state’s chronicle problem – lackadaisical babudom.

Rs 9 crore sanctioned by the GoI (Rs 8 crore for a full-fledged regional forensic science laboratory (FSL) at Pasighat and a Rs 1 crore-mobile lab) during 2010-11 plan period only Rs 3.5 crore was received but could not be spent for indecisiveness while rest Rs 5.5 crore was lapsed for reasons best known to those responsible for implementing the scheme, which is why Arunachal Pradesh Police (APP) would continue to depend on outside FSLs and fail to deliver justice to the aggrieved.

The GoAP had moved the MoHA for permission to utilize the fund to upgrade the existing Banderdewa FSL.

Thanks to the initiative of noted forensic scientist Dr Hemanta Pratihari, who had joined Banderdewa FSL after I pursued him at the request of then PTC principal Cukhu Apa in early 2010. Dr Pratihari, with about 40 year experience including founder directors of Manipur FSL (1971-97) and Tripura FSL (1998-2013) and as director in-charge of Arunachal FSL (Feb 2010 to April 2011), had prepared a blueprint to develop forensic science to facilitate scientific investigation. As things hardly moved in GoAP channel, he left disheartened.

Dr Pratihari after few months had returned to Agartala on personal request of Tripura Chief Minister Manik Sarkar under whom he has been working.

Crimes, a gift of development, cannot be totally wiped out. In case of any murder, the APP shuttles down from various FSLs to cause inordinate delay and deny justice. But who cares?

Fourth, well aware of ‘single window clearance’ benefits, Lohit DC PS Lokhande was first to introduce it in 2007. I had constantly persuaded political bosses to adopt it in the police department as a panacea to remove official hurdles to prevent fund surrender.

Interestingly, GoAP had created longest channel on the earth as a file used to move 38 tables in six months. It was admitted by then Parliamentary Home Secretary Gadam Ete, saying “If a file on recruitment of constables is delayed for six months, it has a cascading effect as the recruitment takes six months and their training 18 months…..”

Interestingly, then Chief Minister Nabam Tuki had consented to sit along with and finance commissioner in the CM’s official conference hall on 18.02.12 to clear files of various sections of police department at one go to fast track under single window.

Ete was very happy: “fast tracking of files ‘for which you were after me and the CM umpteen times’ would help us to get the much desired speed on all sensitive security matters, including recruitment and police modernization”.

Regrettably, the CMO had cancelled the event citing busy schedule for Statehood Day preparation as vested interest had turned the apple-cart turtle. The ‘single window clearance’ remained a mirage and officialdom continued to rule supreme with files moving through 38 tables for clearance even on state security matters, contrary to four tables in GoI and one hour in case of national emergency.

The outcome of single clearing process claimed to be adopted by last Govt was not visible. As the lawmakers have changed former American President Abraham Lincoln’s definition of democracy “Of the people, for the people and by the people” to “Off the people, buy the people and far the people” to suit their political interest?

Related posts