Remedies to remove ‘fault lines’ in PSCs-II

  • Analysis and suggestions

By Robin Hibu

Recruitment strategies:

1) Conducting compulsory rigorous induction training, followed by examination (where they have to qualify) for all state PSC members and staff.

2) Seeking guidance from the UPSC for all operational procedures. Many illustrious officers who have served in Arunachal are members of the UPSC. Even, why not bring on deputation those officers who have had successful stints in the UPSC. Even an Arunachalee officer with a five-year successful stint can be requested to join as APPSC secretary.

3) Adopting time-tested practices in conducting foolproof PSC exams.

4) Need for critical analysis and feedback for improvement from every exam conducted by the respective state PSC.

5) Using the latest IT for upgrading databanks for retrieval and improvisation of arsenal for robust leak-proof conduct of examinations.

6) Preventing unfair means, like impersonation and copying through Bluetooth or Blu-ray with impregnable requisite data on admit cards, like identification mark on the face, Aadhaar card number etc; jamming internet/mobile connection, use of latest jammer; selecting proven high-integrity subject specialists as examiners, both for exam days and for paper evaluation by two experts secretly; enhancing honorarium per answer sheet for quality and timely checking of essay type answers; having tamper-proof assigning numbers for original roll numbers; ensuring fair play for both arts and science subjects as arts subjects are very difficult to score marks, unlike science and maths subjects.

7) Impact analysis and all-round stock-taking by state PSC, keeping in view the recent controversy leading to arrests and cancellation of the exams, followed by court cases in many states, including in NE.

8) The marks awarding system during viva voce needs rethinking. There is no justification column in the viva voce format for giving very high marks to a candidate. This offers ample scope to favour a candidate by viva voce board members. Such members should be kept secret but rotation through a roster in last minutes should be adopted to avoid prior lobbying or any external pressure for giving more marks.

Permanent marker pens should be used for awarding marks during viva voce, with full signature of the board members and the average of board members should be calculated immediately by board chairman in the presence of other members. The marks awarded should also be written in words, duly signed on mark sheet of viva voce by all members.

No pencil or ink pen should be allowed to prevent any tampering or manipulation of mark sheets. Only permanent markers should be used for marking. Any viva voce member awarding high marks to any candidate must justify the reason for that.

9) Only persons with proven integrity and having some exposure to recent trends in administration (civil, military, security, management or judiciary) should be appointed to PSC, august cradle of breeding public servants to serve the people for life.

10) No videography during recruitment.

Recruitment innovative adopted by me:

1) All members of recruitment team are kept under surveillance to prevent human error and deter infiltration, leakage, etc.

2) Using different teams for different jobs, without knowledge of other branches.

3) Detailed arrangement, like sitting plan, supervisors, nearby toilet facilities, police arrangement, drinking water; elaborate plan for searching & frisking, jammer for mobile or internet signal, food packets for staff, medical team with doctor, arrest party and mounted CCTV cameras in exam centre.

4) Introduction of biometric fingerprints equipment for candidates. (12 impersonators were detected and arrested.

5) Establishing a 24×7 ‘war room’ for any exam a month ahead. It should be manned by an officer who has all information on FAQs, coordinates and branches on action taken before the exam.

6) Repeated rehearsals on ground with all stakeholders including non-commissioned units, like police, centre in-charge, jammer and keeping enough space between the candidates.

7) Selection of only those staff as team whose integrity is beyond doubt.

8) Debriefing, followed by immediate clearance of all honorariums, and offering appreciation to excellent performers immediately.

Conclusion: The present perception of the state PSC is a wake-up call for serious introspection, pulling up socks, and taking all steps by all the stakeholders to allay any misgiving over the constitutional trust bestowed upon this supposedly hallowed PSC.

After all, this PSC is dealing to give birth to the cardinal governance structure involving the best and the brightest youths who want to serve the society in their careers for more than 30 years.

The sooner the better, lest the PSC goes beyond control. (The views of the writer, an IPS officer, are his own)

Related posts