Arunachal caught in catch-22

Executive Vs Judiciary

 

All-party decisions on Chakma-Hajong refugee issue on Monday are wise and reflected wisdom as the refugees, displaced by Patkai dam in the then East Pakistan and hit by social conflict, were rehabilitated in North Eastern Frontier Agency (NEFA, now Arunachal Pradesh) by PM Indira Gandhi in 1964 without consent of any Arunachalee leader.

Was then PM not aware that this land was constitutionally protected by Article 371H, Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873 and Chin Hill Regulations, 1896 that provides special protection and safeguard for the peaceful existence of indigenous tribal people? Then union home minister P Chidambam , well aware of Constitution being a lawyer, at Itanagar on 12.0512 had avoided the question:  Was granting citizenship with Arunachal residentship not violation of the Constitution?

Indira Gandhi had explained the situation in Parliament in 1971 saying: “About three-and-half million people have come into from Bangladesh during the last eight weeks…. . They are not refugees in the sense we have understood this word since partition. They are victims of war who have sought refuge from the military terror across our frontiers.”

On India’s financial burden by massive influx of refugees, she had said: “on the present estimate, cost to the central exchequer on relief alone may exceed Rs. 180 corer for a period of six months. All this has imposed an unexpected burden on us.”

The influx continued during 1964-69 posing a herculean problem for India even before rehabilitating 1947 partition refugees. Carving out pieces of land for the refugees was difficult as it had later evoked reactions from Arunachalees. But, in 1966, the Centre had set up a resettlement scheme to  rehabilitated them but several complaints about Chakmas encroaching land, reserve forest and indulging in illegal collection of arms and ammunition in contact with militant groups surfaced steadily.

When the GoAP ordered Chakmas to vacate encroached reserve forest and move back to their designated camps, they challenged the order in Supreme Court, which had held that the Chakmas had a right to rehabilitation under Article 21 of Constitution, but had said that it could not scrutinize the Govt policy providing procedure for their rehabilitation.  Rehabilitation is an intricate socio-economic issue that invariably assumes political overtones.

In another case ‘Nation Human Rights Commission-Vs Arunachal Pradesh’, the SC had sternly dealt with the ultimatum given by All Arunachal Pradesh Students Union to the Chakmas to either flee the state. The SC had  warned against any threat to life of Chakmas and directed the GoAP that it was its duty and obligation to protect “life and liberty” of every human being, be a citizen or otherwise, and it cannot permit anybody or group of persons to threaten Chakmas to leave the state.

First, the central Govt takes decision in violation of the Constitution and second, the apex court directs to protect the refugees. Such directives put the GoAP in a ‘what to do, what not to?’ situation. Should the GoAP also violate the Constitution? – is a million dollar question.

Any Indian from rest of India is not allowed to settle down in Arunachal Pradesh by Constitutional protections. But, the  injustice imposed on Arunachal Pradesh by Statehood Act, 1986 is a glittering example of how the Centre enacted different laws for different NE states.

While Article 371 (A) is applicable to Nagaland, and Article 371 (G), under which Mizoram is placed, ensure that no act passed by Parliament can ordinarily interfere with the religious, social and customary practices of the states. Both Arunachal and Mizoram attained statehood on 20.02.87. However, while Mizoram was placed under Article 371 (G) of Constitution (53rd Amendment) Act, 1986, Arunachal was not granted the same protection.

The Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873 and the Chin Hill Regulations, 1896 provide special protection and safeguard for the peaceful existence of the indigenous tribal people by prohibiting entry of outsiders in the tribal area without “Inner Line Permit”. Article 243D of Constitution (83rd Amendment) Act, 2000 provides for reservation for ST in every PRI as only indigenous tribal people are allowed to take part in democratic process. The tribal society  with social equality among  men and women prevailing for ages, the Article 243D will provide a legal and constitutional basis for PRI in tune with state’s socio-political ethos.

All Arunachalees are under an impression that they all are owners of land but constitutionally they are owners of visible surface land  only while the resources hidden below belong to the GoI as Article 371H takes away their rights of ownership and transfer of land and its resources. Unlike Nagaland, Meghalaya and Mizoram, why Arunachal was made an exception by Arunachal Pradesh Statehood Act, 1987 that imposes constitutional bar?  Does it not mean that the Statehood had  had turned into Statehoot?

That is why the PPA is making efforts to meet BJP chief Amit Saha to get the Statehood Act amended to rectify the blunder. If lotus instead of pond cloud bloom in hills, why Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who has been advocating cooperative federalism for India with the intention of making every state self-dependant, could  amend the Constitution to give Arunachal its due rights with khul ja sim sim mantra?

All said and done, involvement of the refugee problem creator  (the Centre)is essential for which revival of high powered committee involving a MoHA representative is vital to find an acceptable lasting solution to this contentious issue.

Related posts