Kakoi Nyokum festival structures dismantled by Assam forest official with JCB on 17.03.20
Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
High level teams headed by chief secretary and director general of police of Assam and Arunachal Pradesh held a threadbare meeting on inter-state boundary row and unanimously decided to maintain peace and status quo along the inter-state boundary.
It would be worth mentioning here that much higher level meetings were conducted in the past – chief ministers of both states agreed to honour the status quo on 10-07-87, 12-08-95 and 20-07-99. Further, they held a joint meeting on 31-08-91 and a joint ministerial meet on 27/28-05-98. The Assam government moved the Supreme Court in September 1989, which constituted the Local Boundary Committee in Sept 2004 to identify the boundaries of Assam, Arunachal and Nagaland.
“The Supreme Court-constituted one-man Local Boundary Commission, headed by justice Tarun Kumar Chatterjee, who replaced justice Variabha recently, is looking into the pros and cons of the boundary issue and is expected to send a report to the home ministry soon”, was the statement of then union home minister P Chidambaram given at Itanagar on 02.04.10. But the issue is gathering dust and amicable is still a mirage and inter-state boundary disputes continue to occur off and on.
An 18-member team of Assamese newsmen led by the state’s deputy IPR director Hiranya Kumar Bhuyan on a four-day goodwill mission in Sept 2009 was shocked when Tarasso village gaon buri Tana Joy, who lost her everything, including traditional ornaments in the April 22 eviction drive conducted by the Sonitour DC, narrated in detail (in chaste Assamese) how she suffered, and questioned – “Is this eviction? Are we not Indians? Why should we be looted, tormented and left homeless for no fault of ours?” “We are going back to Dispur as your ambassadors,” was the assurance of Dainik Purboday executive editor Ravi Sankar Ravi, while Assam Tribune EE Prasanta Jyoti Baruah had opined: “The media of both states should mobilize people’s opinion and pressurize both state governments to settle the boundary dispute once and for all when the same party is ruling in both the states and at the Centre.”
After independence, a sub-committee headed by Indian independence activist Gopinath Bordoloi was appointed by the Constituent Assembly of India to recommend the future pattern of administration of North Eastern Frontier Areas. The Bordoloi Committee recommended that since the administration has been satisfactorily established over a sufficiently wide area, the Assam Govt should take over that area by the strength of a notification.
However, for various considerations, particularly problem of communication and defiance, GoI decided to administer North East Frontier Tracts as “Excluded Area” through Assam Governor as an agent to the President of India. In 1950, the plain portions of these tracts namely, Balipara Frontier Tract, Tirap Frontier Tract, Abor Hill District and Mishimi Hills Districts were transferred to Assam Govt. In 1951, the units of the tracts were reconstituted again and Tuensang Frontier Division was created which later merged with Nagaland. The remaining portion of Tracts after introduction of the North East Frontier (Administration) Regulation, 1954 was designated as North East Frontier Agency (NEFA). Thereafter, the administration was brought under the Ministry of External Affairs and in August 1965, it was brought under the supervision and control of the MoHA, which remained so till attainment of Union Territory status as Arunachal Pradesh in 1972.
But, Bordoloi, first Assam CM, being member of Constitution drafting committee and heading lone man Bordoloi Committee had notified the boundary between Assam and Arunachal Pradesh in 1951 which was abinitio rejected by the later being “arbitrary, ex-parte”.
As the boundary issue has been agitating the minds of people of both states despite their age-old cultural relations, both the state Govts had moved the Supreme Court which had constituted boundary commission to work out modalities for an amiable solution and on 25.09.06 had appointed justice (retd) SN Vairava to be assisted by two other members with specific direction that the panel shall identify the boundaries between Nagaland, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh.
But, how and why the top political leaders and bureaucrats are forgetting that Bordoloi, being member of Constitution Drafting Committee, had issued the notification before the Constitution was brought into effect for which none can deny the legal strength of the notification, which is the bone of contention. This was brought to mu notice first by present Siang deputy commissioner Rajiv Takuk as border affairs director.
The only way is to nullify the notification and replace it by another notification of land could be as under occupation by respective states. When the Bharatiya Janata Party is ruling now in the Centre as well as in Assam and Arunachal Pradesh it would not be difficult proposition. Or else the inter-state boundary tangle, I fear, would continue to remain a bone in the throat of Arunachal Pradesh!
