Food for thought
Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
Tomato, onion and potato are essentials for the masses. But onion prices have been skyrocketing since the last week of August, touching Rs 80 per kg in many cities and nearly Rs 100/kg in Mumbai. This is contrary to what Prime Minister Narendra Modi in 2018 had dubbed that tomato-onion-potato as top priority for his government.
Price hike of these commodities led to food inflation, which invariably became a key issue in elections. Possibly with the Bihar elections in mind, the government had acted twice to control onion prices.

Onion 2020
Harvesting seasons: There are three main harvesting seasons of onions in India, namely Kharif (sowed in June-July and harvested after October), late Kharif (sowed in September and harvested after December) and Rabi (sowed in December-January and harvested after March). However, India’s annual consumption is 160 lakh tones.
Why price hike? Heavy rains in Karnataka hit state’s Kharif harvest, due in the market after September. It was to last till Maharashtra’s Kharif harvest arrived by October end. Maharashtra is the only state with marketable produce. But rain has cost 50 to 60% of its 28 lakh tones of opinions in storage. The rain also affected the onion storage Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and other states driving up wholesale prices.
On Sept 14, the central Govt announced a ban on export of onions while import norms were relaxed to facilitate procurement from Turkey, Iran and other onion-producing nations. However, on October 23, the central Govt reintroduced stock limits on onions. Some traders said that the GoI’s move to relax phytosanitary norms will help bring supplies from Dubai. About 300 containers, or 12,000 tonnes of onion, are likely to reach the Mumbai port in next 10 days, said leading onion exporter Danish Shah, adding “As the landed cost of imported onion is Rs 40 to Rs 52/kg, the wholesale prices should range between Rs 50 and Rs70/kg.”
There was a fear that the onion prices will hit Rs 100/kg. However, the NAFED will soon begin importing onions in a bid to tame soaring prices, Food and Consumer Affairs Minister Piyush Goyal had said on Oct 30.
While the imports meet demands of hospitality industry, but the lag remains for household consumptions. Notably, rains in Maharashtra had affected seeds and saplings for later crops. The shortage could affect Rabi crop production too. The prevailing rate may continue till new crops enter the market after November.
Onion, a politically-sensitive commodity, remained costliest in the retail markets of Bengaluru at Rs 100 per kg on November 2 despite Karnataka being the third-largest producer of the kitchen staple in the country, according to GoI data. The lowest price quoted was Rs 35/kg in only two cities of Udaipur in Rajasthan and Rampurhat in Birbhum district of West Bengal, out of 114 cities where price trends are monitored on a daily basis by the GoI.
The average all-India daily price of onion was ruling as high as Rs 70/kg on Nov 2. Despite Maharashtra being the top onion producing state in India, retail price of the commodity in Mumbai was a hefty Rs 77/kg. A similar situation prevailed in Delhi, one of the major consuming markets, where retail prices were firm at Rs 65 per kg, in Kolkata at Rs 70 per kg and Chennai at Rs 72 per kg that day, the GoI data said.
Onion prices have soared for the last few weeks due to tight supplies following damage to this year’s kharif crop in the wake of heavy rainfall in the key growing states of Maharashtra and Karnataka.
However, the GoI took several measures, including banning exports and imposition of stock limits on traders, to boost the domestic supply and keep the prices under check till the arrival of fresh crop by October end. It also released buffer stock of onion as well as relaxing norms for imports via private trade to ease domestic availability till December. Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka are the top three onion growing states in India.
The Economics Times on October 22 had reported: Onion prices had doubled in major wholesale markets to Rs 80 per kg in last part of October despite the ban on exports and the government’s decision to ease norms on imports.
In some markets, like Kalvanand Dindori Vani in Nashik district, known for top quality onion purchased by seed manufacturing companies, prices have touched Rs 90/kg.
In India’s largest wholesale market for onions, Lasalgaon, the average price was Rs 62/kg, while the highest was Rs 70/kg on Thursday. At Pimpalgaon APMC, the next largest onion market after Lasalgaon, the price was Rs 68/kg, while the highest was Rs 81/kg. At both the markets, the average prices have doubled in the past 10-12 days. However, at other markets like Kalvan and Dindori Vani, the highest prices have crossed Rs 90/kg.
“The onion that is grown in the hinterland of our markets is known for its best quality and all the leading seed companies purchase our onion for the purpose of seed production,” said Ravindra Hire, secretary, Kalvan APMC, where top quality onion has been selling above Rs 80/kg. The highest price of Rs 92/kg was recorded on October 21 at Kalvan.
The price of onions, a staple food of all classes, castes and religions, has an almost mystical political significance in India. (To be continued)
