By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR | Jul 05 | The IAF HAL Dhhruv chopper getting crashed in Sagalee area of Paum Pare district of Arunachal Pradesh on Wednesday and simultaneously Union MoS (Home Affairs) had a narrow escape at the same time when an IAF Mi-172 helicopter carrying him and six others forced landed at Itanagar.
Of the three on board, two were reportedly dead and the other untraced.
The crash history of the state raises a simple question: Is Arunachal Pradesh a Devil’s Triangle for flying machines?
Crash history:
May 31, 2017: Two pilots of the Sukhoi jet that had crashed after taking off from Tezpur in Assam suffered fatal injuries, the Indian Air Force on Wednesday said five days after the wreckage of the plane was found.
Squadron Leader D.Pankaj and Flight Lt S Achudev could not initiate ejection before the crash that occurred 60 kms from Tezpur Airbase on 23 May, the IAF said. The wreckage of the Sukhoi-30 MKI jet was found on 26 May in a dense forest area in Arunachal Pradesh after a three- day search operation.
July 14, 2015: Pawan Hans chopper with 17 passengers makes an emergency landing on NH-52A at Gohpur in Sonitpur district near Assam-Arunachal Pradesh border.
Aug 05, 2015: A Pawan Hans helicopter went missing near Khonsa, HQs of Tirap district with Tirap Deputy Commissioner Kamlesh Kumar Joshi and pilots M S Brar and Rajeev Hoskote. Their bodies were recovered on 12.08.15 by commandos of the High Altitude Warfare School.
Nov 19, 2011: AIF’s MI-17, a multi-utility helicopter, blasted into flames midair 5 minutes after take-off from Tawang helipad, killing 12 defence personnel, including 3 pilots.
Apr 30, 2011: The then Arunachal Pradesh chief minister Dorjee Khandu and four others died after their Pawan Hans chopper crashed in Luguthang, near the China border.
Aug 6, 2010: Pawan Hans helicopter (24-seater MI-172) cabin crew Dhananjoy Roy fell to his death while trying to shut the unfastened chopper door that had flung open midair when on its way from Namsai to Tezu.
Nov 19, 2010: IAF’s MI-17, a multi-utility helicopter, blasted into flames midair 5 minutes after take-off from Tawang helipad, killing 12 defence personnel, including 3 pilots.
Aug 6, 2010: Pawan Hans helicopter (24-seater MI-172) cabin crew Dhananjoy Roy fell to his death while trying to shut the unfastened chopper door that had flung open midair when on its way from Namsai to Tezu.
June 9, 2009: Russian-made AN-32 aircraft while returning from Mechuka after an Army ration sortie crashed over Tato, killing all 13 defence personnel on board.
May 8, 2001: A Pawan Hans chopper piloted by DGM Capt VK Dhir and carrying state Education Minister Dera Natung, education secretary Sange Lhaden, union HRD ministry’s Dy secretary SK Jain and two others crashed into a high hill near Sessa in West Kameng district due to poor visibility, killing all on board.
Feb 26, 2001: IAF’s MI-8 chopper while returning from Tali after a ration sortie crashed near Ziro, killing all 6 crew members including two pilots.
Nov 14, 1997: Union MoS for defence NVN Somu and three top officials, including Maj Gen Ramesh Nagpal died when their four-seater Cheetah hit a 1300 ft peak 40 km from Tawang.
Jun 06, 1995: IAF’s MI-8 chopper on ration sortie crashed near Bello village under Yomcha subdivision in West Siang district killing all seven crew members including pilots.
Mar 25, 1992: An Antonov AN-32, the workhorse of IAF, on a ration sortie from Rowriah had reportedly crashed Along China without any trace of the four crew members, including two senior pilots and its wreckage. The defence ministry had ordered a court of inquiry. (The detailed story was filed by me in The Arunachal Times, quoting Anindo Majumdar, a very upright IAS officer of the 1985 batch, who was DST director then(04-06-89 to 27-05-92) and present joint secretary in the union agriculture ministry).
In 1989: An Antonov AN-32 on a ration sortie from Rowriah had reportedly crashed into China side without any trace of the crew members at its wreckage. The defence ministry had ordered a court of inquiry. (The detailed story was filed by me in The Arunachal Times quoting then DST director A Majumdar).
After the Nov 19 crash, Lok Sabha member Takam Sanjoy in an interview to this daily had blamed the defence ministry for not giving due importance to this Himalayan state despite its strategic location. He had demanded an IAF training centre considering the number of air crashes, particularly in Arunachal, saying after the humiliating defeat in the 1962 Chinese aggression it is time to learn the lesson.
The Tawang–Guwahati daily subsidized helicopter service, a part of PM’s massive package, was announced for Arunachal on January 30, 2008.
The Bermuda Triangle or the Devil’s Triangle, is a loosely-defined region in the western part of the North Atlantic Ocean, where a number of aircrafts and ships are said to have disappeared under mysterious circumstances.
Any answers for repeated crashes? – was a question I had raised on 20.04.vvv after the 24-seater MI 172 Pawan Hans chopper crash in Tawang on Tuesday. Numerous questions mostly remain always unanswered after any such mishap.
The pilot had announced ‘May Day’ prior to the crash, getting the emergency doors open and asking the passengers to jump. A pilot, a crew member and four civilians had jumped to save their lives, according to a survivor’s account.
Khana purti (eyewash): The director general of civil aviation probe will presumably zero down either on technical snag or human error and the file get closed for ever. Of course, the condolences and compensation payment are part of the khana purti while the bereaved families would be grieving for their life.
The five-member Asif family was wiped out, Karishma became a widow, two doctors’ families were orphaned and the Army lost a colonel. What a tragedy!
Invariably, there will be neither any remedial measures nor lessons from the past mistakes to plug the loopholes to improve upon the airworthiness of choppers, safety of the passengers, maintenance procedures and reliability of air journey in hilly terrains.
How long would the people of landlocked Arunachal Pradesh fly in such unsafe copters in the name of majboori ka naam Jagannath (God is the saviour for the helpless)?
The facts: The 1996-97 manufactured chopper’s scheduled passenger flight to Seppa was cancelled on Monday due to technical problem, and its maintenance taken up with reportedly change of some spare parts before it flew to Jorhat on a test flight and for refueling. On its return it took off for Guwahati with 13 passengers and 5 crew members at 12.30 pm, 30 minutes late.
The next day, it left Guwahati with 18 passengers (2 minors) and five crew members for Tawang, and was scheduled to halt there for the night and fly back to Guwahati Wednesday morning with VIPs attending the NE RD Ministers’ conference being chaired by Union RD Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh. But it crashed, killing 17 while 6 were pulled out of the burning chopper by onlookers.
The questions:
1) Why and how did the chopper catch fire midair over Tawang?
2) What message had the pilots radioed to air traffic control at Guwahati and Tawang heliports?
3) Why was a fire brigade not stationed before landing as mandatory? Why have most of the landing grounds in the state no fire tenders in violation of DGCA guideline? Had the fire brigade been on duty, who knows, possibly all or few more lives could have been saved.
4) Did Pawan Hans stick to the mandatory maintenance schedule of the chopper?
5) Were the pilots flying beyond the prescribed monthly flying hours limit?
6) Why did the passengers’ list prepared by the Guwahati office carry incomplete and misspelled names, reflecting callousness?
Chopper service is essential in this hilly landlocked state for carrying essentials, men and machines and patients. It was famous federal pilot Biju Pattanaik’s Kalinga Airlines had maintained lifeline of NEFA during 1956 to 1957 by flying from DST Rowriah (Jorhat) to drop rations throughout NEFA and at times landing at Anini and Ziro.
Though the invaluable service of the crew members, at times at life’s risk, is highly praiseworthy, choppers are proving to be the proverbial ‘flying coffins’ in this Himalayan state, particularly in Tawang sector, with numerous air pockets and treacherous terrain dotted with high hills and very unpredictable weather conditions.
The ‘air-maintenance’ sortie from Tawang, located about 9,000 feet above the ground, is helicopter-aided support for forward army posts on the China frontier, at altitudes of 8,000 ft to 14,000 ft where winds are high and oxygen density almost 30% lower, and where supplies are either para-dropped or the helicopters make touch-and-go landings. The IAF service is essential for national security.
From ‘Yamdoot’ to ‘flying coffins’: The Vayudoot operating in the state (Along, Daporijo, Pasighat, Tezu, Ziro and also Lilabari) during the 80’s had earned an obnoxious name, ‘Yamdoot’, after the door of one of the aircrafts (a Dornier aircraft)collapsed after it took off from Ziro airfield. In a bizarre turnaround, a Pawan Hans chopper’s door went ajar midair over Namsai while it was on a routine passenger sortie, resulting in the fall to death of flight attendant Dhananjoy Roy on 06.08.10.
Commercial choppers Pawan Hans Helicopters Limited (PHHL) had become more like Mrityuhans, if its records are any indication, I had written in Killer Pawan Hans’ truth out on 16.5.12.
