Indian myth: Declining tax payers Vs rising dependants?

 

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR | Aug 05 | A government is a perpetual body unlike an Assembly and Lok Sabha which are not permanent but have a fixed life for which they are prorogued after expiry of their lives. That is the reason why a chief minister or even the prime minister on completion of the term resigns to be appointed as care taker till the newly elected leader is sworn in to take over the reign.

If “Government of the people, by the people and for the people, shall not perish from the Earth” as defined by former USA president Abraham Lincoln is right, its solely responsible is for all round development and welfare of its people whom it represents.

While the GoI has extended the last date of August 5 next for filing tax returns,  a WhatSaap message doing rounds read: My IT return was rejected for a wrong entry about dependant. On my number of dependants, I wrote: 65% non-tax paying Indians, 21 million illegal migrants, 9 lakh criminals in over 1382 prisons, 544+ MPs and over 4,000 MLAs of states. I was sure the information was not right. Thus, I worked to ascertain  the total number of tax payers and dependants:

Dependants: There were 1387 functioning jails in India with a total 356,561 prisoners’ capacity as per official data as on 31.12.14 and there were 418,536 inmates in jails..

Interestingly, population of depending on India grew after  Bangladesh Liberation War in 1971. The government, citing inputs available with it, told the Rajya Sabha on Wednesday that there were around 2 crore Bangladeshi immigrants staying illegally in India. The rise in the number of illegal Bangaldeshi immigrants, which almost equals the size of the entire population of Australia, shows a rise of around 67% over the 1.2 crore estimate given out by the UPA Govt in 2004 but withdrawn soon after.

“There are reports of Bangladeshi nationals having entered the country without valid travel documents. Since entry of such Bangladeshi nationals into the country is clandestine and surreptitious, it is not possible to have accurate data of such Bangladeshi nationals living in the various parts of the country. As per available inputs, there are around 20 million (2 crore) illegal Bangladeshi migrants staying in India,” Union MoS (Home) Kiren Rijiju said in written reply to a question posed by Rajya Sabha MP Jharna Das Baidya.

The 20 million estimate far surpasses the figure of 12 million cited by then minister of state for home Sriprakash Jaiswal in 2004 in the same House. Jaiswal had, in reply to a question 0n 15.07.04, said that 1,20,53,950 illegal Bangladeshi migrants were residing in 17 states and Union territories as on 31.12.01. He also said Assam alone accounted for 50 lakh Bangladeshi squatters, while their number in West Bengal was estimated to be the highest at 57 lakh.

The BJP, which was then the main opposition party, demanded that the 12 lakh illegal Bangladeshi immigrants   be identified and deported. As a political storm brewed in states like Assam, Jaiswal withdrew his reply, dismissing the 12 million figure as one based on “unreliable reports” and “hearsay”.

However, a Union minister on Wednesday said it was a conscious decision by Modi Govt to highlight the 20 million estimate of illegal Bangladeshi migrants residing in India. “Unlike UPA, we won’t be cowed down by pressure to deny the figure as ‘hearsay’,” said the minister.

Why income tax payers in India are a small and shrinking breed, ToI reported on 02.02.17: Out of 125 crore Indians only 1.5% (1.9 crore) pay income tax.  Even among the few who do pay income tax, the disparities are huge.

In fact, the number of income taxpayers has fallen, even though tax revenue has risen. There is no solution to shrinking tax base as long as 98.5% Indians don’t pay income tax.

Related posts