Arunachalee tribes call tigers as their brothers

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

The Idu Mishmi sub-tribe Dibang Valley of Arunachal Pradesh believes that tigers are their elder brothers and killing tigers is a taboo for them. While their beliefs support wildlife conservation, they also offer a critique of the dominant mode of nature protection, IIT-Gandhinagar assistant Prof (humanities and social science) Ambika Aiyadurai writes in her book: “Tigers Are Our Brothers”.

The book is an outcome of her PhD thesis in anthropology from National University of Singapore and based on long-term ethnographic fieldwork in various  parts of Arunachal Pradesh, mainly in Dibang Valley. Her research critically leads to debates of wildlife conservation and its impact on the lives of Idu Mishmi.

The book, a timely reminder on World Wildlife Conservation Day (December 4), argues for an inclusive, culturally informed, and people-centric approach to wildlife conservation. Based on in-depth interviews, archival research and living with an Idu Mishmi family, it presents rare insights into how local communities negotiate their lives, as their landscape is fast-changing, and forcing them to take part and also question the nature of development.

“I had initially avoided focusing on tigers as part of my research; I did not want my research to centre on a high profile animal or a site. However, during my exploratory visit to Koronu village (Lower Dibang Valley district) adjacent to Mehao Wildlife Sanctuary, in 2012, I heard stories about the rescue of tiger cubs in Dibang Valley. I was shown a letter from the forest department had sought  help from villagers to give information about a tiger-killing incident.

“The letter was some sort of a joke, the villagers ridiculed and questioned the naivete of the forest department expecting the villagers to identify the tiger’s killer. People told me about the visits made by scientists and NGOs to Dibang Valley. As I began to assess the situation, I felt that Dibang Valley had all the features that I intended to research: the interest of NGOs and wildlife biologists, scientists, imposition of state authority, human-wildlife conflict and very vocal Idu Mishmi community,” Aiyadurai told in an interview.

The book begins with the rescue of tiger cubs by a Dibang Valley-based NGO engaged in conservation, after which the district witnessed a series of conservation interventions and research projects by state and NGOs “and this remote corner of India transformed itself into a site of high profile visits of wildlife researchers and conservation NGOs”, she said.

“They mapped the tiger habitat, assessed the tiger and its prey population and this information led to the proposal of a tiger reserve. While the researchers and NGOs were busy studying the wildlife, Idu Mishmis were anxious with the several actors visiting the district to study tigers and their habitat. They were particularly curious about the ‘new’ found interest in tigers,” she said.

Dibang Valley residents often said that they do not harm tigers and in fact their kinship relations with tigers are helping tiger population. “The fear of getting intertwined with the state’s ‘ever-reaching hands’ and losing their lands for tiger conservation was the chief reason behind their anxieties,” she explained.

“While some welcome the idea of a tiger reserve with the hope of employment, others worried that the ownership of their lands, forests and mountains will be compromised. This is one of the many issues that brought researchers, scientists and the state in direct confrontation with Dibang Valley people. A common grievance of the residents was the non-consultative approach of the state and the non-participatory nature of researchers.

“Idu Mishmi felt a sense of mistrust towards the forest department and the research team members. This has resulted in mild intimidation and resistance, as well as hesitation or even refusal in participating in research activities. Moreover, there was a difference in the perception and understanding of nature as well as its protection and conservation that the book examines,” Aiyadurai reasoned.

Wildlife Institute of India scientist GV Gopi, who along with research scholar Aisho Sharma Adhikarimayum, had conducted a study had found 11 tigers caught on through camera traps during 2015 to 2017.

The paper titled “First Photographic Record of Tiger Presence at Higher Elevations of the Mishmi hills in the Eastern Himalayan Biodiversity Hotspot, Arunachal Pradesh, India” was published in the journal “Threatened Taxa” in November and documents presence of tigers at an altitude of 3,630 metres. “Considering we could cover only 336 sqkm of 4,149 sqkm of Dibang Wildlife Sanctuary (DWS) even 11 tigers indicate a high density. We are certain that the actual population will be much higher, cover the entire area in the next phase of our study,” Gopi said.

Interestingly, Arunachal Pradesh had scripted a success story in tiger conservation as from nothing in 2010, 29 tigers were spotted in Dibang-Kamlang-Namdapha block in 2018, as per National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) survey.

The Apatani also respect the cats as one Apatani had told National Geographic, “The tiger is the brother of the human being. To kill a tiger is equal to murder…to kill any cats is a serious offense. The Apatani always cut the head off a snake they kill and bury it. If they don’t they believe the snake will come back and get them.”

Apatani Cultural Landscape was nominated to be a UNESCO World Heritage site in 2014. According to a report submitted to UNESCO:“The Apatanis, one of the major ethnic groups of eastern Himalayas, have a distinct civilization with systematic land use practices and rich traditional ecological knowledge of natural resources management and conservation, acquired over the centuries through informal experimentation. The tribe is known for their colorful culture with various festivals, intricate handloom designs, skills in cane and bamboo crafts, and vibrant traditional village councils called bulyañ. This has made Ziro Valley a good example of a living cultural landscape where man and environment have harmoniously existed together in a state of interdependence even through changing times, such co-existence being nurtured by the traditional customs and spiritual belief systems, as per Permanent Delegation of India to UNESCO.

Related posts