Will BJP solve NE inter-state boundary imbroglio?

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, Jan 05: The division of Assam and creation of the predominantly tribal states of Mizoram, Meghalaya, Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh which shares boundary with the former has left a residue of boundary problems, which continue to bedevil relations between the neighbouring states. Each of Assam’s border disputes has its own legacy of claims and counter-claims:

People of Arunachal Pradesh, particularly those living along the inter-state boundary, have been victims of atrocities committed by Assam Govt officers under the pretext of 1952 Bordoloi Commission report, which was ab initio rejected by Arunachal people. Eviction drives of Assam officers, snatching away their ripen paddy from fields, domestic animals are common incidents,

Why because of visionless act of Assam Prime Minister Gopinath Bordoloi, a member of Constitution drafting committee. The Constitution of India was ready by 26.11.1949; India formally became a sovereign republic only on 26.01.1950. All official formalities for brining North East Frontier Tracts (NEFT) under the 6th Schedule of the Constitution was complete by November 1949.

After completing his report, he was waiting for India to attain its full-fledged sovereign status to move the report for assent of President of India. He did it when none in the NEFT (present Arunachal Pradesh) was aware of either the move or the impact it would have on this Himalayan state and its populace.

Once the presidential assent was obtained, Bordoloi having the authority formally notified the report on 23.02.1951 to demarcate the boundary between then NEFT and Assam. It has legal status to become a bone in Arunachal throat, but could be nullified only through an act in the Parliament.

“An 18-member team of Assamese newsmen led by the state’s deputy IPR director Hiranya Kumar Bhuyan on a four-day goodwill mission in September 2008 was shocked when Tana Joy, gaon buri of Taraso village, who had lost her everything, including traditional ornaments, on 22.04.2008 eviction drive conducted by Armed police personnel led by Sonitour DC, narrated in detail (in chaste Assamese) how she suffered, and questioned – “Is this eviction? Are we not Indians? Why should we be looted, tormented and left homeless for no fault of ours?” The team had gone back with the assurance to pursue Assam Govt not to repeat it.

Alas…another boundary dispute had cropped up at Shimhokho location of Kamkuh Rusa village under Kanubari sub-division of Tirap district bordering Sibsagar district of Assam in August 2010, where an Arunachalee sustained grievous injuries in indiscriminate firing by Assam police.

CMs of both states had agreed on 10.07.87, 12.08.95 and 20.07.99 to honour the status quo followed by holding a joint meeting on 31-08-91 and a joint ministerial meet on 27/28.05.98. The Assam Govt had moved the Supreme Court in September 1989, which constituted the Local Boundary Committee in September 2004 to identify the boundaries of Assam, Arunachal and Nagaland.

Despite all this, the Assam police and forest officials evicted 200 villagers of Dolung village under Papum Pare district on 20-12-04 and burnt down 9 houses and a granary in Dipik village on 05-02-05.

Things hardly have changed. Though Union Home Minister Amit Shah in his 69th plenary session of North Eastern Council address at Shillong on 23.01.21 had urged all CMs to solve the dispute amicably at state level by August 15.08.22, at least six Assam Police personnel were killed, more than 60 officials and civilians received bullet injuries on being fired upon from Mizoram at inter-state boundary in Cachar district’s Lailapur on 30.07.21. Chief Ministers Himanta Biswa Sarma (Assam) & Zoramthanga (Mizoram) had sought central intervention then.

On 15.07.21, Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Pema Khandu had said that Assam and Arunachal have in principle agreed to sort out the inter-state boundary issue out-of-court and formed a formed a high power committee headed by Home Minister Bamang Felix for the purpose.

Though Congress ruled most of the NE states for long but never took any pragmatic step to solve boundary dispute except decorating it in election manifesto and speeches. Appreciably, Shah had a meeting with Assam CM Sarma and his Arunachal counterpart Pema Khandu in New Delhi on 22.12.21 to push for a permanent solution to the vexed issue and had asked both to hammer out a permanent solution.

Several efforts have been made to arrive at some kind of resolution to boundary dispute. In 1979, both Govts agreed to set up a high-powered committee to discuss the disagreements, but nothing came of it. In 1983, Arunachal Govt sent a proposal to Assam asking it to return 956 sqkm of land, but Assam Govt did not respond. In 1989, Arunachal again renewed its claim and argued that it has been magnanimous and asking only a small portion of the plain land transferred to Assam.

In response, Assam Govt filed a civil suit in the Supreme Court requesting it to ascertain Assam–Arunachal boundary. Incidentally, in 2007, Arunachal presented its proposal in front of Tarun Chatterjee Commission in which it increased its request of return of territory from 956 sqkm to 1,119.2 sqkm. Assam rejected it in 2009 and argued that the boundary should be settled in the spirit of give and take. It is reported that the Commission upheld 70–80% Arunachal Pradesh’s claim.

Raising encroachment issue in 2020, Assam has claimed that Arunachal has encroached upon 6,375 hectares of its forest land. It important to note that Assam Govt has been periodically launching eviction drives in encroached lands leading to violence on the ground and tensions, like in 2005 and 2014. The present situation on the border is calm but could flare up at any moment given that rapid encroachment from both sides, which is politicised by vested interest groups.

In August 2021, Assam CM Sarma and his Meghalaya counterpart Conrad K Sangma had agreed to set up regional committees to resolve the inter-state border disputes while both states had exchanged reports submitted to their regional panels on 04.01.22.

On 04.01.22, Assam CM Sarma, also chairman of North East Democratic Alliance (NEDA), addressing a press conference at Dibrugarh, expressed his hope of some resolution to long-pending boundary dispute with Meghalaya and Arunachal Pradesh this year but take more time to resolve the border dispute with Nagaland and Mizoram.

“Barring a few areas, the disputes with Meghalaya are very minor. The disputes are mostly on paper and there is no question of forcing the border residents to choose different sides of their own free will. He also dismissed allegations that criminal elements in Meghalaya were trying to force the residents of Assam to choose the neighboring state,” Sarma said, adding “three ministers in charge of regional committees constituted to settle six types of disputes have assured that the matter will be resolved expeditiously in first phase.”

“Mizoram has been insisting that inter-state boundary should be demarcated on the basis of 1875 notification, an outcome of Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation (BEFR) Act 1873. However, Assam wants to implement 1933 notification. Assam’s border dispute with Nagaland began after the creation of the state in 1963,” he added.

Lotus never blooms in hills, but it has made its presence felt in all these hilly states except Assam (partially hilly). The BJP ruling in the Centre is also ruling in Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya (NPP with BJP support), Nagaland (Democratic Alliance of Nagaland with BJP support) but and regional party in Mizoram.

This is the most conducive situation to find a lasting and amicable solution to this decades-long imbroglio. Let’s hold our betted breath for a positive outcome!

Related posts