Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
The number of tourists Arunachal Pradesh, including capital city Itanagar is on the rise with the state government attaching priority to boost revenue of fund poor.
Though census 2011 quotes only 59,490 population, but, if it’s ever rising migration from other parts of the state and floating number is considered, it could reach about two lakhs, the main factor behind rising number of crimes as per police records.Year-wise cases registered were:2010- 447, 2011- 560, 2012-520, 2013-613, 2014-709, 2015-759, 2016-791, 2017-769. 2018-811, 2019-802, 2020-680 and 2021-1143.
Policing was attested first in English language in 15th century, originally in a range of senses encompassing “(public) policy; state; public order”, the word police comes from middle French police (public order, administration, government), in turn from Latin politia, which is romamization of ancient Greek term politeia, means “citizenship, administration, civil polity”, which is derived from Polis (city).
However, to make Itanagar a safe city, the state government could give a serious thought to introduce police commissionerate system of policing, like Guwahati and Dimpaur.
Assam was the first among eight North East states to introduce police commissionerate system for capital city Guwahati on 1st January 2015 having a population of 9,57,352 (2011) while Nagaland followed suit for its commercial hub Dimapur with a population of 1,22,834 (2011) on 15th April 2015.
Dimapur, which occupies less than 10% geographical area of Nagaland, accounts for almost 43% of state crimes, including rape, murders, robbery, burglaries, dacoities, trafficking in drugs, arms and humans, cyber-crimes, economic offences etc.
While policing is based on Police Act, 1861, 61 cities in 15 states had this system in place by January 2018, according to a BPRD report.
“Dual command” system of policing: Under the dual command system, the District Magistrate and the Superintendent of Police (SP) share powers and responsibilities in a district. Under this structure, the DM is entrusted with issuing arrest warrants, licenses while the SP has powers and responsibilities to investigate crime and make arrests. The system is designed to ensure a lower concentration of power and making the police more accountable to the DM at the district level.
However, under the police commissionerate system, the powers of both policing and magistracy are concentrated with the commissioner, who is directly accountable to the state government and the state police chief.
Empowerment of police: The commissioner of police under the commissionerate system exercises the powers and duties of a DM. These powers are also available to any officer under the commissioner who is not below the rank of an Assistant Commissioner of Police.
This essentially means that such police officers now have powers of preventive arrest, imposing Section 144 of the CrPC Act. Also to initiate chapter proceedings which include issuing show cause notices to persons asking them to execute a bond with or without sureties for good behaviour in interest of the public.
The police are a constituted body of persons empowered by a state to enforce the law to ensure safety, health and possessions of citizens, and to prevent crime and civil disorder. Law enforcement is only part of policing activity. Policing has included an array of activities in different situations, but the predominant ones are concerned with the preservation of order. Police forces are usually public sector services, funded through taxes.
India is a police state unlike many nations in the world, like Singapore as despite having security agencies, paramilitary and police forces proliferate, 2021 witnessed the quiet birth of new ones with new powers, like:
— Jammu and Kashmir’s new Special Investigation Agency can prosecute crimes of “false narrative” and “spreading disaffection”.
— Uttar Pradesh’s new Special Security Force is protected from civil or criminal action and can search or arrest anyone on “reasonable suspicion” alone, with no warrant or magistrate’s order.
— Bihar’s new Special Armed Police can make arrests “on reasonable suspicion” without a warrant or order from a magistrate.
— The NATGRID is a surveillance system with unfettered access to 21 databases, including real-time information from agencies like the income tax department, banks, insurance companies, Indian railways, among others.
Powers granted to these agencies do not have any backing in India’s criminal law or the Constitution, others, while technically legal, are unjustifiable. Yet, these agencies have been brought into force without due legislative process in a union territory controlled directly by the central government.
“Considered together with new jurisdiction for a central paramilitary agency, the Border Security Force, in Punjab, West Bengal & Assam, the establishment of these new agencies heralds a new chapter in what critics have already warned as the emergence of ‘police states’ in H&K, UP and Bihar,” Mani Chander wrote on 07.12.21 in “The Rise Of India’s Police State: Shadowy New Agencies With Shadowy Powers” in https://article-14.com.
Interestingly, to my query as to why not a single cop is visible in Singapore during my visit to the island nation in 2006, the local tour had quipped: We are not a police state. Commit any crime, you will see the police. She was right as after one member of our group was trying to escape from a shopping mall without paying, police surfaced from nowhere to arrest her.”
Thus, the police commissionerate system if set up would undoubtedly create fear psychosis to check crimes to make Itanagar safer.
