Root causes behind Sino-India border disputes

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, Jan 03: Indian and Chinese troops often face off while patrolling along 3,488-km undefined Line of Actual Control of Sino-India border as seen on 09.12.22 in Yagtse area of Tawang sector in Arunachal Pradesh when 20 Indian Army personnel and reportedly many more Chinese PLA jawans had sustained minor injuries.

This was fist incident of its kind after 25.06.30 incident when 20 Indian soldiers were killed and several were injured in a violent clashesthe in Ladakh’s Galwan Valley. A similar incident had taken place in October 2021, when some Chinese soldiers of a large patrol team were detained for a few hours by Indian Army as they engaged in a minor face-off near Yangtse. Thus, commanders of both sides had flag meeting to discuss the issue and restore tranquility

In the last few years, the Army has significantly upgraded firepower and infrastructure along the LAC in the Tawang sector and a similar effort is under way in the rest of Arunachal Pradesh (RALP). The road built by the BRO that linked Maza, the last border post in Upper Subansiri district, on Dec 28 is a glittering proof.

Root cause of repeated disputes are due to ill-defined, 3,448-km-long border that both countries dispute. Four states – Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand (erstwhile part of UP), Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh and Union Territories of Ladakh (erstwhile state of Jammu & Kashmir) share border with China.

The Sino-Indian border is generally divided into three sectors namely: Western sector, Middle sector, and Eastern sector.

Western sector: In western sector, India shares about 2152-km border with China – between UT of Ladakh and Xinjiang province of China. The dispute is over Aksai Chin, which India claims as part of erstwhile Kashmir, while China claims it is part of Xinjiang. The dispute is reportedly due to failure of the British empire to demarcate a legal border between both countries. During the British rule in India two borderlines were proposed – Johnson’s line and McDonald line in 1865 and 1893 respectively.

The Johnson’s line shows Aksai Chin in Ladakh, i.e., under India’s control whereas McDonald Line places it under China’s control. India considers Johnson Line as a rightful national border with China, while China considers McDonald Line as the correct border with India. The different claims and perceptions of LAC have lead to overlapping area within that area, including a small zone which both sides patrol causing clashes of armies of nations.

At present, Line of Actual Control (LAC) is the line separating Indian areas of Ladakh from Aksai Chin. It is concurrent with the Chinese Aksai Chin claim line.

In Middle sector, India shares about 625-km of Sino-Indian border. Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand touch the border with Tibet. The border runs from Ladakh to Nepal and only sector where both countries have less disagreement.

In Eastern sector, India share 1140-km border with China, called the McMahon Line that runs from eastern limit of Bhutan to a point near Talu Pass at Tibet-India-Myanmar tri-junction. China considers McMahon line illegal. Sir Arthur Henry McMahon, a British Indian Army officer and diplomat, had proposed the line in tune with Simla Accord in 1914 to settle boundary between Tibet and India, and Tibet and China. Though the Chinese representatives attending the meeting had signed the agreement, but Beijing subsequently refused to accept it. Thus, major territory of Arunachal Pradesh is claimed by China as a part of Southern Tibet.

Sino-Indian disputed areas: China claims about 90,000 sqkm of India’s territory in the NE, including Arunachal, while India says 38,000 sqkm of land in China-occupied Aksai Chin is part of Ladakh. There are several disputed areas along the LAC, including in Himachal, Uttarakhand and Sikkim.

India witnesses around 300 transgressions by the PLA troops ever year while it was record 426 in 2017, the year of Doklan face-off.

State/UT-wise disputed areas are:  Ladakh – Pangong Tso lake; Galwan Valley where Shyok and Galwan rivers meet; Daulat Beg Oldi (DBO), a key northern region close to Karakoram Pass; Hot Springs-Gogra area of the LAC; Demchok close to southernmost part of LAC in Ladakh; Chushul, located on southern bank of Pangong Tso Lake, having an airstrip near Rezang La pass on the LAC; Spanggur Gap along  LAC having roads giving access to either side; India’s Chushul-Demchok road, like Samar Lungpa, Trig Heights, Chumar, Dumchele & Kongka La.

Himachal Pradesh – Kaurik & Shipki La, an ancient trade routem, Uttarakhand – Pulam Sumda & Barahoti Plains; Sikkim -: North Sikkim, a high-altitude snowbound plain area  & Chumbi Valley,  India–China–Bhutan tri-junction where Doklam is located and  Arunachal Pradesh – Namkha Chu, Sumdorong Chu, Asaphila, Longju, Dichu, Yangtse, Fish Tail-1 & 2 in Dibang Valley and Lamang.

Related posts