Why ‘No’ to Tibetan Rehabilitation Policy, 2014?

By Mina Toko

Tibetan Rehabilitation Policy, 2014 (TRP) refugees in Arunachal Pradesh can be fairly termed as  ‘queue jumpers’ if they are made exclusive beneficiaries by extending all Central and State govt. schemes, employment opportunity in Govt. sector and land occupation on lease which they are already enjoying when indigenous population of the state is surviving on hand to mouth.

Tibetan refugees are the only refugee in India properly settled and liberally run a parallel Govt in exile with cabinet minister and independent commission. Many studies reflect that Tibetan refugees have crossed the transition from those typical least developed countries to middle income and more affluent societies in these 50 years of exile.  They are receiving Govt recognition and patronage along with assistance from different UN agencies. Its principal donors include Swiss aid, Norwegian Refugee Council, Indo- German Social Service Society, Christian Aid (UK), American Emergency Committee for Tibetan Refugees, Tibetan Refugee Aid Society (Canada), Oxfam (UK), Arbeiter-Whohlfahrt (West Germany) and Deutsche Welhungerhilfe (West Germany) which clearly shows how economically privileged, socially established and  politically empowered they are than the indigenous state people, who still lack assistance and support  from GoAP and GoI.

As reasoned by state BJP president to implement TRP, 2014 because India is signatory of Geneva Convention for which obligation falls on Arunachal Pradesh to act accordingly is imprecise.  India only has a partial commitment to international community by being UNHCR executive member and acceding few of international covenant which  do not mandatorily directs the GoAP to rehabilitate refugees by depriving indigenous people. Rather, it says extension of ‘basic facilities’ on the basis of consultation and discussion between the GoI and the state concerned which never took place in case of Arunachal Pradesh as it is stated in the official message of MoS in TRP 2014.

Hence, it proves that the current Govt has strong imprint of political undertone with Tibetan Govt.  in exile  to heighten the economic hardship, social trouble and  political oppression of state’s indigenous population. Otherwise, Tibetan refugees are being used as ping-pong ball or safety card for Sino-Indian relation by Indian Govt without sorting fundamental issues of peace and security when India has several political issues to settle with China.

Arunachal Pradesh needs to pass a regional mechanism and legal framework that will assure strict regulation of all refugees living in state.  Continuous Influx of Tibetan refugee into the state is of great concern as there are more than 70 scatted communities and total settlement areas which have increased from 38 in 2002 to 45 in 2017 followed by rise in population approximately accounting to 1, 10,095.  In such situation granting domicile certificates to  Tibetan refugee poses an apprehension that the Tibetan refugees may not go back and demand for separate homeland as Chakmas are doing now, which may deteriorate the situation further. Tibetan Bazaar and land for economic trade are already there in Arunachal Pradesh curtailing the economic opportunity of locals and posing economic conflict.

Further, it is also to mention that benefits and facilities are always extended to refugees living in camps. Tibetans are probably the only refugee community who do not live in refugee camps, but in prospered settlements with all privileges with higher literacy rate of 88.7% for males and 74.4% for females which state’s indigenous population never dreamt of.

Hence, the TRP,2014 is a disastrous blow to Arunachal Pradesh by the GoI. (The writer is a  resource person of Himalayan University)

Related posts