Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
The Supreme Court on Monday ordered the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to maintain status quo till 5 p.m. on July 26, giving the Gyanvapi mosque management “breathing time” to approach Allahabad High Court against a July 21 order of Varanasi District Court to conduct a scientific survey of the mosque premises to determine if the mosque located next to the Kashi Vishwanath temple in Varanasi was built upon a temple.
A bench headed by Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud asked Allahabad HC registry to place the appeal, if filed by the mosque management, for hearing before an appropriate Bench before the top court’s stay order expired on July 26 evening. As the debate over the Gyanvapi mosque-Shringar Gauri complex, located in UP’s Varanasi, continues in the courts, some new and old facts have come to the fore.
The 19th century English author James Prinsep had illustrated the history of the Gyanvapi mosque and the old Vishveshwar temple. Prinsep, during his stint as illustrator and traveller, decoded present Gyanvapi mosque way back in 1831 as he travelled across the length and breadth of city of Varanasi. His book “Benares Illustration” reveals surprising facts on the basis of lithography.
The Gyanvapi Mosque was built by Aurangzeb in 1669 after demolition of an older Shiva temple. In September 1669, Aurangzeb ordered demolition of the temple; a mosque was constructed in place, probably by Aurangzeb himself, sometime soon. The façade was modeled partially on the Taj Mahal’s entrance; the plinth of the temple was left largely untouched to serve as the courtyard of the mosque, and the southern wall — along with its cusped arches, exterior moldings and toranas — was turned into the gibla wall. Other buildings in the precinct were spared.
Pre-mosque history: The semi-demolished wall of the temple, pillars, and ruins are visible in a sketch of the mosque by James Princep. A conjectural reconstruction of the temple-plan by Princep based on remnants and oral evidence of local Brahmins derived from the Kashikhand. The dotted line traces the compound of the Gyanvapi mosque.
The site had a Vishweshwar temple devoted to the Hindu deity Shiva and built by Todar Mal, a premier courtier and minister of Akbar, in conjunction with Narayana Bhatta, a pre-eminent Brahmin scholar of Banaras from Maharashtra, during late 16th century. The temple contributed to establishment of Banaras as a vaunted center of Brahminic assembly, drawing scholars from across the subcontinent especially Maharashtra, for adjudicating a spectrum of disputes concerned with Hindu religious law.
Architectural historian Madhuri Desai hypothesizes that the temple was a system of intersecting iwans – a borrowing from Mughal architecture – with prominent pointed arches; it had a carved stone exterior. It gives presence of mandapas suspect, as accounts of contemporaneous pilgrims did not mention of them.
Oral accounts indicate that notwithstanding the desecration, Brahmin priests were allowed to live in the premises of the mosque and exert their privileges on issues of Hindu pilgrimage. The remnants of the temple, especially the plinth, continued to remain a popular hub for Hindu pilgrims. The mosque came to be known as the Alamgiri Mosque – after the name of Aurangzeb —but with time, the current name was adopted in common parlance, deriving from an adjoining sacred waterbody – Gyan Vapi (“Well of Knowledge”) – which, in all likelihood, even predated the temple.
Pre-temple History: What might have existed at the site prior to this temple is debated by scholars. Such history has been extensively contested by the local Hindu as well as the Muslim population. Desai notes the multiple histories of the original temple and tensions arising out of the location of Gyanvapi to have fundamentally shaped the sacred topography of the city.
Recent accounts of the history of the mosque, as purveyed by Hindus, center around a litany of repeated destruction and re-construction of the original temple which is situated in contrast to the timelessness of the lingam. The original temple, located the current site of the mosque, was allegedly uprooted by Ghurdis in 1193/1194 CE, upon the defeat of Jayachandra of Kannauj; the Razia Mosque was built in its place, a few years later. The temple was be rebuilt by a Gujarati merchant during the reign of Ilutmish (1211–1266 CE) only to be demolished by Hussain Shah Sharqi (1447–1458) of Jaunpur Sultanate or Sikandar Lodi (1489–1517) of Delhi Sultanate. During Akbar’s rule, Raja Man Singh got the temple re-built, but it again fell victim to Aurangzeb’s intense religious zealotry.
Historicity: Diana L. Eck finds medieval chronicles to affirm the Hindu notions of an Adi-Vishweshwar premises being the original home of the lingam; however, scholars have critiqued Eck’s non-contextual usage of medieval sources. Hans T. Bakker finds the temple destroyed in 1194 to be indeed located in current-day Gyanvapi precincts but devoted to Avimukteshwara. However, he speculates that Razia mosque was not built in its place but atop the adjacent “Hill of Vishweshwar”, which would force the Hindus —sometime around ate 13th century— to reclaim the vacant Gyanvapi site for a temple of Vishweshwar. This new temple would again be destroyed by Jaunpur Sultanate, apparently to supply building materials for mosques at their new capital.
In contrast, Desai, in her reading of medieval literature, rejects the existence of any Vishweshwar temple in early-medieval Banaras; she alongside other scholars argue that it was only in the Kashikhand that Vishweshwar would be featured as the major deity of the city for the first time and even then, for centuries, it remained one among the many sacred spots of Banaras.
Vishweshwar would succeed Avimukteshwara to become the principal shrine of the city only after sustained patronage of Mughals, beginning from the late 16th century. She perceives the Hindu claims as part of a meta-narrative about Hindu civilization being continually oppressed by Muslim invaders, which was reinforced via colonial apparatuses of knowledge production.
Chronology of events:
August 2021: Plea filed before a Varanasi civil court by five Hindu devotees seeking permission to offer daily prayers at the Gyanvapi mosque.
08.04.22: Civil court orders a survey of the premises and appoints Ajay Kumar Mishra as in charge of the exercise.
13.05.22: Supreme Court refuses interim order of status quo on the survey of the Gyanvapi-Shringar Gauri complex.
17.05.22: SC passes interim order directing the district magistrate of Varanasi to ensure the protection of the area inside the complex.
20.05.22: SC transfers the case from a civil judge to a district judge.
14.10.22: Varanasi district court rejects plea for carbon dating of the Shivling.
10.11.22: SC agrees to set up a bench to hear the case.
12.05.23: Allahabad High Court orders determination of the age of the Shivling using modern technology.
19.05.23: SC defers scientific survey to determine the age of Shivling.
21.07.23: Varanasi district court directs the ASI to conduct the survey — including excavations, wherever necessary — to determine if the mosque was built at a place where a temple existed earlier.
24.07.23: SC halts ASI’s survey at premises till 5 pm on July 26, asks HC to hear the mosque panel’s plea. (with Wikipedia inputs)
