Contentious Chakma-Hajong issue
AG speaks on legal aspects: Legally speaking, state’s advocate general Nilay Dutta who was present in the house at speaker’s invitation to advise on legal aspects on the issue, highlighted ‘dos’ and ‘don’ts’ of contentious the matter.
A legal practitioner at Gauhati High Court and SC, he advocated no to act in any manner that could amount contempt of the apex court and requested the GoAP to scrutinize & verify all Chakma-Hajong applications and recommend to dispose them off.
Referring to Tuki’s observation, he said that not a single person has so far been granted citizenship. The AAPSU Vrs ECI under Article 372 was missed by the HC and SC. Thus there is time which calls for strong political supported with legal aspects to deal with the case.
“We should always look forward, not backward, a position of dominance in the court of law in public perception. Accordingly, one has to frame strategic move legally, “ he said, adding that they were displaced by hydropower project in Chitagong Hill Tracts of Bangladesh and not refugees.
He suggested to make a population data base as on 01.01.18 of all indigenous population and displaced Chakam-Hajong in the state.
By Pradeep Kumar
ITANAGAR | Oct 18| The assembly on concluding day of its 6-day session had threadbare discussion after Parliamentary Affairs Minister Bamang Felix moved a Govt resolution: “This house do take immediate steps to take immediate steps to protect the territorial & other consequential rights of its tribal population as protected and guaranteed under the Constitution of India & other relevant laws enforce in the state with regard to granting citizenship to Chakma & Hajong refugees”.
This vexed Chakma-Hajong issue has been interfering in daily life of the people for last five decades, he said adding dislocated by building of Kaptai dam in Chittagong Hill district of then Bangladesh they had migrated to India and some were settled in the state. He read out potion of Chief Minister Pema Khandu’s letter written on 08.09.17 to Home Minister Rajnath Singh -“the issue is of deep emotional concern to state’s people as the state is protected by Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, which prevents any other Indian to enter the state without innerline permit (ILP)”.
Arunachal is not authorized to grant citizenship, he said, adding AAPSU, of which he was a leader, has been spearheading the anti-refugees movement, apprehending that they would become future problems. These refugees have gone to GoI, National Human Rights Commission and UNO to plead for their rights, he said, and urged all to deliberate rising above all blame game reflecting the voice of true sons of this soil.
C T Mein said that he belonged to Chowkham where 5,000 Chakmas are living and associated with the problem since 1974-75. The issue has remain unresolved though original Chakma-Hajong population of 14,888 has swelled to more than 1,00,000, with migration from Tripura & Bangladesh, higher than local indigenous people. While the Tibetan refugees are docile and create no problem, many Chakmas are in police custody at Diyun. Informing that one of his employee was kidnapped by Chakmas and Rs 50 lakh was demanded, he said in their inhabited areas there is always conflict as they encroach land of Mishmis. Many Chakmas are settled in Diyun reserve forest where police and forest dare not to go, he said.
These refugees are not law abiding and engaged in underground & anti-social activities, he said, adding more than 3,000 Chakmas are voters of his Bordumsa assembly constituency and apprehended that granting them citizenship and letting them to settle in Arunachal would have far reaching consequences.
It was a blunder of then Govt to settle them in NEFA. There is record of Chakmas living in Chowkham but no record for Diyun, where they are migrating from various places after committing crimes and have totally finished reserve forest, he said.
The Chakma who killed a GB was from Tripura while a CO was also manhandled by them, he said and sought identification of original Chakmas in Chowkahm and Bordumsa constituencies for finding a permanent solution.
The state suffered for Chakma issue and many lost their lives including Kipa Kache (shot dead by CRPF at Nyapin), Tanga Byaling said, adding “we should unite to protect our rights and land”. One ADC U Chakma had tried to settle Chakmas in many districts but succeeded as DC in Changlang where their population has crossed local tribe Tangsa population. He quoted their threat issued to locals through WhatSsap. They should be given citizenship but not Arunachal residentship,” he said, adding Arunachal land and tribal rights cannot be sacrificed. He told CM that he should have refused HM Singh during his meeting at New Delhi (13.09.17).
About 90% of total around 1.25 lakh Chakma-Hajongs live in Changlang district, Tesam Pongte said, adding many of the MLAs, who were AAPSU leaders, have received CRPF baton during stir against them. Why legal actions are not taken against them though they have encroached upon 7,299 hectares reserve forest have in Changlang. An official survey should be conducted to assess their population, their occupied land and all of them should be brought to one place, he said and cautioned against Rohingya refugees, who have been fleeing from Bangladesh.
Nabam Rebia said this emotive issue could decide the state’s destiny while the house should salute all martyrs of the cause. He recalled his statement in Parliament when Atal Behari Vajpayee was PM and L K Advani home minister about the move to create a Bengali speaking Muslim nation in NE India. Advani in his replay had asked why Arunachal Govt failed to seriously pursue GoI on refugees issue which was helpless then, said Rebia, a former AAPSU president. There was no freedom of speech, 50 cases were registered against AAPSU leaders and there was even attempt to eliminate him, he claimed, adding everything then was termed a politically motivated.
“Let them be granted citizenship but why they should be settled in Arunachal, protected by Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation,1873 and Chin Hill Regulation Act, 1896. Though sizeable Chakma population live in my constituency who would not vote me, but truth is truth and there should be no compromise with Arunachal identity,” he said.
The Supreme Court and GoI are protecting Chakmas-Hajongs now, said Lombo Tayeng, adding the lawyers engaged by the GoAP was less paid. He said advocate general Nilay Dutta would suggest the right way but the CM should constantly monitor. When a CO, his younger brother, had tackled with Chakma-Hajong problem was pulled up by NHRC and the CS did not support for which he was about to be terminated. Hundreds of Chakmas, who were land owners in Hollongi, were driven out from their by giving land compensation as per their demand, while former CM Hiteswar Saikia had order ‘shoot at site order’ in Assam fearing them to enter that state. All India service officers would not act against these refugees, he said, saying legal battle is the option or fighting tooth and nail not to allow this state to be second Tripura.
AAPSU was treated by Govt as opposition for their fight against the refugees, Takam Pario said and opposed the resolution by questioning how to deport them. They may be given citizenship but not resident in Arunachal protected by laws.
The issue was neglected by the GoAP and treated as students’ issue, Thangwang Wangham said, “A stitch in time saves nine”, adding the GoAP was never serious to take concrete step. He supported but sought pragmatic approach as Chakmas-Hajongs settled in this sensitive state are threat to India. How could they be given citizenship when they formed Arunachal Pradesh Deprived Forum whose six cadres were arrested in September last with sophisticated arms & ammunition, besides killing a HGB and assaulting a CO. They should be settled outside if granted citizenship and those who came after 1969 should be deported to their nation. There should be biometric registration to identify them, he said.
The issue need curative medicine or surgical strike, Tage Taki said hinting at SC verdict. Pointing out that curative appeal in SC may not yield any result, he called for assessing total Chakams-Hajongs and demarcate original land given to them. In his support, he suggested signing of lease agreement with MoHA with rent and applying ILP for them to find a solution.
Japu Deru recalled People’s Referendum Rally led by then CM Gegong Apang held at Rajiv Gandhi Stadium on 20.09.95 that had sent a louder message to GoI and said much litigation do not yield desired result in theis democratic nation.
Wangling Lowangdong in his support highlighted the entire issue to reflect the seriousness, while Wangki Lowang in his support suggested that all new refugees should be deported and those who came originally and those living in reserve forest be evicted.
Nabam Tuki sought more time for valuable suggestions by members but said the AG would guide on this legal issue, but why not move a review petition in constitutional bench. In all 1,478 refugees have been given voting right, he said hinting at illegal migrants. We should fight together for the cause of the state but if no option left what to do, he asked?
Former CM Nabam Tuki sought more time for valuable suggestions by members but said the AG would guide on this legal issue, but why not move a review petition in constitutional bench. The legal battle begun in 1995 when the NHRC moved the court to protect Chakmas’ rights. The 2015 SC order was challenged by a review petition and urged GoI to follow suit but the GoAP petition was rejected.
If we do not take up the decision today tomorrow will be late. In all 1,478 refugees have been given voting right, he said hinting at rising illegal migrants. We should fight together for the cause of the state but if no option left what to do, he asked?
Tuki said that Bordumsa-Diyun is a general seat for anyone to contest, he said, adding the SC overruled many laws protecting the state in favour of the refugees. Citing Mizoram and Tripura examples, he feared of may claims for autonomous status in the state.
Insisting on permanent solution, DyCM Chowna Mein referred to numerous movement against Chakma-Hajong, whose population has risen bus 24% due to illegal influx. The original refuges may be allowed to live without land right but others should be deported.
Terming the issue half a century old, CM Pema Khandu said the data of Tibetans are available, unlike no record of Chakma-Hajoang. The issue has been agitating the minds of the people, while many youth have lost their future causing deep concern, which have been conveyed to the MoHA, he said, adding that the ILP is important in this case as Chakma-Hajong official population is around 65,000 but unofficial is more than a lakh.
Moreover, their 1,222 applications were processes, hearing of 900 over and sent to MoHA this year in two phases but were rejected. Rest 322 rejected cases would be sent again while 1588 cases are due to non-availability of claimants & incomplete, among other issue. Rejected applications are resent attaching GoAP form, he said. Some of the relief eligibility certificates, issued by GoI to them during that period, are not clear and some of them are overwritten for which the attention of the MoHA drawn recently.
The time is ripe to find a lasting solution to Chakma-Hajong imbroglio, instead of only debating on this cancerous issue, he said and hinted at the absence of Bordumsa-Dayum MLA (Nikh Kamin) in the house. He said that around 8000 hectare of land have been damaged in Changlang and Namsai districts besides many reports of their criminal activates, he said urged all members to unite for state cause.
However, enlisted private member’s resolution were not approved.
Speaker T N Thongdok, who moved the modified resolution, was passed by voice vote before he adjourned the house sine die.
