Onions boon for kitchens, ban for politics?

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, Dec 23: Onion (amall) prices per kg on Monday in major cities of India are: Lucknow (₹ 38); Delhi (₹ 65); Bhubaneswar, Kolkata , Patna & Jaipur (₹ 70); Bangalore, Chennai, Coimbatore, Madurai & Mysore (₹ 80); Kochi, Hyderabad, Visakhapatnam, Vijayawada &Trivandrum (₹ 100);  Ahmedabad,  Vadodara & Surat (₹ 110); Nagpur, Nashik, Pune & Mumbai (₹ 160), Oneindia reported from Kolkata.

As onion prices have skyrocketed more than 50% in a week, Maharashtra’s Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar has written a letter to Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal requesting that the Centre remove the 20% export duty on onions.

Onion, a vegetable widely used in South Asian kitchens, has turned into a major political weapon for the opposition both within and outside Parliament. The opposition parties have made their point given the sensitivities attached to the culinary staple. There’s no justification for the fact that onions are selling at over ₹200 per kg in parts of Karnataka and that prices are ranging between ₹100-180 per kg in other states. The only state that has perhaps partially cushioned itself against the secular rise of onion prices is Maharashtra, a hotbed for onion-based politics.

Historically, onions are the most nightmarish vegetable for Indian politicians, The Qunit had reported on 20.08.2015.

Long before there was Anna Hazare, we had the humble onion to credit for bringing down Govts. 500-km from the anti-corruption crusader’s village is Lasalgaon – the largest wholesale market of onions in India. Delay in supply from this wholesale mandi, among others, has led onion prices to skyrocket in Delhi. Currently being sold at ₹ 80/kg, this upward spiral should be closely monitored by the Govt.

The Onion Election: Let us rewind to the 1980 General Election or the “Onion Election” as Indira Gandhi had called it. Rising onion prices contributed to the fall of first non-Congress Govt led by Morarji Desai post-independence. But within a year, onions were making Prime Minister Indira Gandhi cry when prices shot up by an unthinkable ₹ 6 again in 1981.

During the winter session of Parliament that year, Lok Dal’s Rameshwaram Singh walked into the Rajya Sabha wearing a garland made of onions. When Singh complained to the Chairman of the House M Hidayatullah about rising onion prices, he shot back saying – “Let’s see what you will wear when the prices of tyres go up or for that matter the prices of shoes.”

The rest of the country was certainly, not laughing. The next jolt was felt around 1998 Diwali when festivities were bleak. But politicians still retained their sense of humour as Congressman Chhagan Bhujbal sent a box of onions to the then Maharashtra Chief Minister Manohar Joshi and explained – “Diwali is a festival where you give something precious. This time, onions are very precious.”

An embarrassed Joshi was then forced to relent and made onions that were being sold for ₹ 45/kg in Mumbai, available for ₹ 15/kg to ration card holders.

Indian satirist and comedian, Late Jaspal Bhatti (R), protesting against rising prices of vegetables in Chandigarh along with his wife Savita.

But India’s ace comedian and satirist Jaspal Bhatti trumped everyone else. A 09.11.98 report from the India Today archives elaborates: Jaspal Bhatti first created a flutter by arriving in a city market flanked by black-cat commandos. His logic: buying a precious commodity like onions warranted exceptional protection.

Later that month, Bhatti organised a fashion show in Chandigarh’s Sector 17 with models walking down the ramp wearing onions.

Things, however, got serious for the BJP later that year when Delhi assembly elections were held. In a pre-election manoeuvre, Sushma Swaraj was appointed as Chief Minister, just 40 days before Delhi went to vote. Despite her best efforts to set up fair price shops, quashing rumours about scarcity of onions and other essential commodities like salt, there was no coming back for Sushma or the BJP. Onions were selling for ₹ 40-50/kg then. The BJP has failed to capture power in Delhi after Sushma Swaraj was ousted by INC’s Sheila Dikshit in 1998 due to the onion crisis.

2010 “Grave Concern”: Along with Delhi, the BJP also suffered a stinging defeat in Rajasthan credited to the lowly onion. After his loss, Chief Minister Bhiaron Singh Shekhawat was famously quoted as saying – “The onion was after us.”

In 2010, tables turned when errant rainfall in onion producing regions led to a country-wide shortage of onions. Recognizing political dangers of expensive onions, an otherwise reticent Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh described it as a “grave concern”. Exports were stopped, import duties were cut and the Govt appeared to be in damage control mode. But a 2012 study by the Competition Commission of India suggests the Govt was up against a factor it had little control over – pure simple greed.

In December 2010, retailers’ markup over the wholesale market price was more than 150% in almost all major markets in crucial weeks. Therefore, December 2010 episode was not simply a demand and supply problem.

On 14.08.13, protesters belonging to the BJP hold garlands of onions and green chillies around portraits of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Congress President Sonia Gandhi in Allahabad.

But the heads-up of 2010 did little to soften August 2013 blow. Prices shot up to ₹ 100/kg in some parts of north India, forcing the country to float a tender to import onions from Pakistan, Egypt and China. Rise in price of onions and other essential commodities pushed inflation, making the UPA II even more nervous as it prepared for Assembly elections in crucial states, like Delhi and Rajasthan. The Congress was comprehensively routed in both states.

To give sole credit to onions for any of the electoral defeats may be a stretch, but its one veggie no Indian politician wants to mess with.

However, present Modi-led BJP Govt seems to have taken the modest commodity very lightly though the Govt had extended the export ban on onion till further orders to increase domestic availability and keep its prices under check. Earlier, it was prohibited till March 31 this year.

“Export prohibition of onions valid till 31.03.24, is extended until further orders,” the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT), an arm of Ministry of Commerce and Industry, had said in a notification dated March 22.

Memes on unacceptable cost of onions have inundated the virtual space as the price rise has the potential to destabilize modest kitchen budgets. Not tackling the onion price crisis could have serious implications and even sway political fortunes in our country. Thus, it is time for the Centre to act!

Related posts