Expansive land grabbing made China’s diplomatic ties complex

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

The image highlights countries in yellow that have border disputes with China, which has ongoing territorial disputes with several neighboring nations. To the north, China has had disagreements with Russia and Mongolia over certain border demarcations, though most have been resolved. To the west, China has historical border tensions with Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, largely settled through treaties.

However, significant disputes remain with India over Aksai Chin and Arunachal Pradesh, leading to military standoffs. In the south, China claims parts of Bhutan and has disagreements with Nepal over border pillars.

Further south, disputes extend to the South China Sea, where China claims territories overlapping with Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, Brune and Indonesia. Taiwan remains a contentious issue, as China considers it a breakaway province.

The above map illustrates how China’s geopolitical tensions span multiple regions, reflecting its expansive territorial claims and complex diplomatic relations, as reported by endless knowledge and doing rounds in Instagram.

If one recollects history, British India annexed Assam in NE India in 1826 by Treaty of Yangdabo at end of 1st Anglo-Burmese War (1824-26),annexed entire Burma  after subsequent  Anglo-Burmese Wars with a border close to Yunan province of China.

 

In 1913–14, Great Britain, China, and Tibet representatives during Simla conference agreed on Tibet’s status and borders. The McMahon Line (painted in red) , a proposed boundary between Tibet and India for eastern sector, was drawn by British negotiator Henry McMahon on a map attached to the agreement. All three representatives initiated the agreement, but Beijing soon objected to proposed Sino-Tibet boundary and refused to sign the final.

After approving a note which said that China could not enjoy rights under the agreement unless she ratified it, the British and Tibetan negotiators signed Simla Convention and more detailed map as a bilateral accord. Neville Maxwell says states that McMahon was instructed not to sign bilaterally with Tibetans if China refused, but he did so without the Chinese representative present and then kept the declaration secret.

K. Singh argues that the basis of these boundaries, accepted by British India and Tibet, was that the historical boundaries of India were the Himalayas and the areas south of the Himalayas were traditionally Indian and associated with India. The high watershed of the Himalayas was proposed as the border between India and its northern neighbours. India’s Govt held the view that the Himalayas were the ancient boundaries of Indian subcontinent and should be the modern boundaries of British India and later Republic of India.

Chinese boundary markers, including one set up by newly created Chinese Republic, stood near Walong until January 1914, when NEFA’s eastern sector assistant administrator T. O’Callaghan relocated them to north closer to McMahon Line (albeit still South of the Line). He then went to Rima, met with Tibetan officials, and saw no Chinese influence in the area.

By signing Simla Convention with Tibet, the British had violated 1907 Anglo-Russian Convention in which both parties were not to negotiate with Tibet, “except through the intermediary of Chinese Govt”, as well as 1906 Anglo-Chinese Convention, which bound the British Govt “not to annex Tibetan territory.”

Because of doubts concerning legal status of the accord, the British did not put McMahon Line on their maps until 1937, nor did they publish the Simla Convention in the treaty record until 1938. Rejecting Tibet’s 1913 declaration of independence, China argued that the Simla Convention and McMahon Line were illegal and that Tibetan Govt was merely a local Govt without treaty-making powers.

The British records show that Tibetan Govt’s acceptance of new border in 1914 was conditional on China accepting the Simla Convention. Since the British were not able to get China’s acceptance, Tibetans considered McMahon line invalid. Tibetan officials continued to administer Tawang and refused to concede territory during negotiations in 1938.

Assam governor had asserted that Tawang was “undoubtedly British” but noted that it was “controlled by Tibet, and none of its inhabitants have any idea that they are not Tibetan.” During World War II when India’s east was threatened by Japanese troops and simultaneous Chinese expansionism, British troops secured Tawang for extra defence.

China’s claim on areas south of McMahon Line in NEFA were based on traditional boundaries and India believes that the boundaries China proposed in Ladakh and Arunachal Pradesh have no written basis and no documentation of acceptance by anyone apart from China. Indian Govt has argued that China claims the territory on the basis that it was under Chinese imperial control in the past and argues that India claims the territory on the basis that it was under control of British imperial.

The last Quing   emperor’s 1912 edict of abdication authorized its succeeding republican Govts to form a union of “five peoples, namely Manchus, Han Chinese, Mongols, Muslims and Tibetans together with their territory in its integrity.” However, the practice that India does not place a claim to the regions which previously had the presence of Mayuryan Empire & Chola Dynasty, which were heavily influenced by Indian culture, further complicating the issue.

Following 1962 Sino-India boundary war, official border talks started in December 1981. There were eight rounds of these talks, with the eight round being in 1987. In 1988, through a joint press communique, the border talks were formalized as the ‘India-China Joint Working Group on the Boundary Question’ (JWG).

Thus, the Sino–Indian border dispute is an ongoing territorial dispute over the sovereignty of two relatively large, and several smaller, separated pieces of territory between China and India.

The territorial disputes stem from the legacy of British colonial-era border agreements, particularly the McHahon Line in eastern sector, drawn during 1914 Simla Convention between British India and Tibet, but disowned by China under the pretext that Tibet was not independent when it signed the Simla Convention.

Strangely, Communist leaders have forgotten simple arithmetic as Simla Convention was held in 1914 when Tibet was independent and ruled by 13th Dalai Lama Thubten Gyatso after asserting its de facto independence in 1913. But regrettably in 1950, China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA) overpowered Tibetan forces to annex and control Tibet.

The western sector of India’s dispute involves Aksai Chin, a region historically linked to princely state of Jammu & Kashmir. But, in late 50’s China controlled it up until MaCartney-Macdonald Line but after 1962 War, China controlled it up till the LAC. Lack of mutually recognized boundary agreements has led to ongoing tensions and occasional military clashes.

The Aksai Chin, administered by China and claimed by India; is mostly uninhabited high-altitude wasteland but with some significant pasture lands at the margins. It lies at the intersection of Kashmir, Tibet and Xinjiang and crossed by China’s Xinjiang-Tibet Highway.

The 1962 War was fought in both disputed areas. Chinese troops attacked Indian border posts in Ladakh in the west and crossed the McMahon line in the east. There was a brief border clash in 1967 in Sikkim region despite having an agreed border in that region. In 1987 and in 2013, potential conflicts over the LAC were successfully de-escalated. A conflict involving a Bhutanese-controlled area along Bhutan-China border was also  de-escalated in 2017 following injuries to both Indian and Chinese troops. Skirmishes have been been contrinuing since then, including dozens of deaths in June 2020.

Agreements signed pending the ultimate resolution were concluded in 1993 and 1996, including “confidence-building measures” and the LAC. To address the boundary question formalised groups were created such as the JWG on the boundary question. It was to be assisted by the Diplomatic and Military Expert Group followed creating special representative mechanism in 203 while Working Mechanism for Constitution and Coordination was framed in 2012.

The territorial disputes between the two countries result from the historical consequences of colonialism in Asia and the lack of clear historical boundary demarcations. The last aggressive melee, face-offs and skirmishes had begun on 05.05.20 between both troops near disputed Pangong Lake in Ladkah and Tibet along the LAC.

Related posts