NEW DELHI | Dec 09 (ANI)| Arunachal Pradesh may be heading towards another constitutional crisis as a recent Gauhati High Court order has clearly stated that the merger of 43 Indian National Congress (INC) MLAs did not take place in accordance with 10th Schedule of the Constitution.
Itanagar permanent bench of Gauhati HC on 22 September disposed of the WP(C) 613 (AP) of 216 case and left it to state assembly speaker to decide the merit and validity of the ‘merger’ of INC MLAs with the PPA in 2016.
“The contentions raised by the petitioner that the claim of merger by 43 INC MLAs as flows from different resolutions of 16.09.16 does not satisfy the requirements of a merger, both factually as well as under the law, as well as the contention that the 43 MLAs having been elected on INC tickets by taking a recourse to the policies of the INC, which were found acceptable by the electorate, the INC would suffer loss and injuries on their claim of merger with the PPA, would now be taken up by the petitioner and other similarly situated persons of the INC before the speaker, while deciding the petition for disqualification dated 14.10.16, which had already been filed”, the HC said.
“This court does not express any opinion on its merit either on the validity or the acceptability of such contentions and it would for the Speaker to consider and decide the same. In terms of the above, the writ petition stands disposed of.”
The petition was filed by former APCC president Padi Richo against state assembly speaker, secretary, Election Commission of India and 43 MLAs.
Legally, the main significance of Arunachal Pradesh verdict lies in the clarity it provides on the speaker’s role. Following the decision of the Gauhati HC the ‘unsettled merger’ issue has queered the political pitch by bringing the issue to the forefront once again in a politically sensitive state.
To understand the matter clearly, one needs to see it in the context of the formation of state’s 6th legislative assembly as per the elections held in April 2014. The INC got 42 seats, the BJP secured 11 seats, PPA got five seats while two independents won.
INC leader Nabam Tuki formed the Govt on being sworn as Chief Minister. However, on 12.12.14, five PPA MLAs merged with the INC, thereby raising its strength to 47 members in 60-member House.
Sometime in September 2015, with the support of 21 INC, 11 BJP and two independent MLAs, Kalikho Pul revolted against CM Tuki. Then Governor Jyoti Prasad Rajkhowa, preponed the assembly session, resulting in a strong protest from Tuki camp, and inaccessibility to state assembly chambers. Then deputy speaker had to conduct the assembly session in a Karate hall, where he declared Pul as Congress Legislature Party leader via a composite floor test. Thereafter, President’s Rule was proclaimed on 26.01.16, but lifted on 19.02.16 at 5.30 p.m. Pul took oath as the new CM the same day at 10.30 p.m.
This development was challenged in the HC, which ultimately reached Supreme Court constitutional bench. The apex court in its order dated 13.07.16 restored status quo ante and Tuki-led Govt came back to power.
The matter did not rest here. After the SC order, Pema Khandu was sworn as CM on 17.07.16 with the support of 47 INC MLAs.
On 16.09.16, 43 Congress MLAs, including CM Khandu deserted the INC and passed a resolution for a merger with the PPA. On the same day, Khandu and 43 INC MLAs filled Form III and Form I. Accordingly, the speaker also gave a direction to state assembly secretary to publish Bulletin Part-II in gazette information given in Form 1 by the legislature party leader. They will be shown as PPA MLAs. Accordingly, no separate order recognising the merger may be issued,” he said.
From the above, therefore, it becomes explicitly and apparently clear that the speaker kept his decision on the merger open by refusing to decide on it. It has further been observed that had a hearing been given, both sides would have got opportunities to present their respective positions. That would have settled the issue of merger.
It seems that the issue of merger being undecided as required by law, there is in law no actual merger of INC MLAs with the PPA.
The HC has clearly stated in its order recently that no merger had taken place, and at the same time, refused to educate and decide upon the issue, saying that this would amount to usurping the speaker’s power to decide such matters.
In the present scenario, with the ball back in speaker’s court, the status of MLAs who went along with Khandu to the BJP to form the Govt, still remains in limbo. Technically, they still continue to be INC MLAs.
Arunachal is turning out to be one of those rare cases where the help of constitutionally appointed authorities has been used to allegedly subvert democracy and principles enshrined therein. So, this time, the million dollar question for every Arunachalee is whether the governor and or the speaker’s office will remain neutral and act as per constitutional provisions.
The recent use of unparliamentary language on the floor of the assembly against the Leader of the Opposition Takam Pario has angered a large number of MLAs and civil society. Post the HC order, the humiliation of Pario has raised political temperatures in the state. Many civil society groups have sought the resignation of CM Khandu as well as an unconditional apology from him.
Pario belongs to the Abotani Clan which comprises of five major tribes of Arunachal (Nyishi, Galo, Adi, Apatani and Tagin) and are represented by 31 MLAs in 60-member Assembly.
In case the alleged nine PPA MLAs and 32 BJP MLAs fail to return to INC, their disqualification is eminent.
Arunachal is widely regarded as one of sensitive and peaceful Indian states. The situation there is reported to have become volatile due to alleged misuse of powers by constitutional authorities, like governor, assembly speaker and others.
The point to note is that the speaker did not approve merger of 43 MLAs. The Gauhati HC’s judgement also endorses this. Therefore, the question of speaker not passing an order for their “Ghar wapsi” to the INC does not arise. An interesting point to note is that Khandu did not take oath after shifting to the PPA and the BJP. It was a make shift move from INC to PPA and then onward to the BJP with the entire council of ministers lock, stock and barrel. It is clear that former state governor failed to perform his constitutional duties.
The blatant misuse of constitutional authority over past year to give legitimacy to a Govt that has not been elected, and is faced with an adverse court order and unable to halt ongoing political verbals, is costing this remote NE state considerably in terms of development and allied initiatives.
