Editorial: Does bandh serve desired purpose?

Satyagraha, loosely translated as ‘insistence on truth’ (satya ‘truth’; agraha ‘insistence’) or holding onto truth or truth force, is a philosophy and practiced generally known as non-violent resistance or civil resistance. The term satyagraha was coined and first used by Mahatma Gandhi during his struggle in South Africa for Indian rights. The term originated in a competition, in the news-sheet Indian Opinion in South Africa in 1906, as one of the entries in that competition. It was an adaptation by Gandhi of satyagraha theory that influenced Nelson Mandela’s struggle in South Africa under apartheid, Martin Luther King Jr’s and James Bevel’s campaigns during Civil Rights Movement in the USA and many other social justice and similar movements.

Gandhiji had applied the democratic weapon against the British Raj. But bandhs, dharnas, demonstrations, strikes and various protests by various organizations, including national political parties to press for any demand became order of the day in post-independence era. However, Kerala High Court had pioneered the ban on bandhs in 1997. Upholding Kerala HC ruling declaring bandhs illegal, the Supreme Court in its 1998 verdict had made it applicable to entire India, making it clear to Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) and especially its supremo M Karunanidhi that questioning SC’s decision would amount to contempt. Bombay HC on 23.07.04 after disposing of a PIL had fined  Shiv Sena and BJP Rs 20 lakh each for calling a bandh in Mumbai on 30.07.03 in the wake of a blast there that reportedly had resulted in losses worth Rs 50 crore. This judgment was termed a landmark for laying down the principle of public accountability. The SC in an extraordinary session on 30.09.07 had declared bandh per se illegal and unconstitutional. This had prompted this editor to wonder on 23.01.09: Will it end  bandh culture in India?

Bandh culture had hit hard India’s industrial-capital Calcutta and its worst jolt was when Ratan Tata had shifted his multi-crore Nano project to Gujarat in 2014. It had ruined Assam economy as reported by Times of India on 10.10.15 — Rs 2,943 crore lost to 68 bandhs in Assam in 2014, means Rs 43.28 crore loses each day based on 2014-15 GSDP prices. The estimate was calculated by Assam Govt toeing a Gauhati HC order in response to a PIL filed in 2012. Kerala faced the same fate before it made inroad intro Arunachal Pradesh.  However, it had ended at the initiative of former CM Nabam Tuki. But, the Abo Tani Clan Organisation (ATCO) has given 12-hour capital bandh on Dec 29 for the failure of Chief Minister Pema Khandu-led Govt to fulfill its charter of demands.

The bandh is called against the GoAP. Whether the Govt or the masses would be affected by it is a million dollar question? ATCO may be justified in its demands to meet the aspirations of and greater welfare of Nyishi, Adi, Tagin, Apatani and Galo communities.  However, daily workers and wage earners usually are the worst sufferers during bandh. Many local chicken traders in Naharlagun daily market resenting against bandhs many a times univocally ask: “Do you know the number of my family? If I don’t earn who will feed them?”

When asked Capital DC Prince Dhawan reiterated ‘no tolerance policy’ against any bandh. But former  Capital DC Mige Kamki on 04.02.14 as per GoAP decision had demarcated Tennis Court, I G Park as a site designated for non-violent stirs without disturbing anyone to drawn attention of the civil society. Such agitation, contrary to bandh, would draw media attention without affecting anyone  while the GoAP if desires would fulfill demands whether bandh is called or not!

Arunachal boasts of its  vast natural resources including:  a) This state with 58,000 MW hydropower potentials could meet one-fourth power requirements of India; b) Oil reserves trapped in coal deposits in this state and Assam could produce 140 million tons of oil per year to sustain India’s fuel need for next 100 years according to former OIL CMD Chudamani Ratnam, more than India’s entire current consumption, high enough to make India an OPEC member. This was confirmed by Union Petroleum Minister Mani Shankar Aiyer  on 10-11-05  at Banquet Hall, after chiding me as ‘awful journalist’, in presence of host of ministers, including then CM Apang and PRI leaders, C) One of the eight global biodiversity hotspots with India’s highest forest cover (82%). These could be tapped by only speedy industrialization.

When the state posing to facilitate industrial revolution with a people-friendly Govt, as announced by DyCM Chowna Mein on Dec 21, it is time for everyone to introspect. The NE, especially nature strove Arunachal Pradesh with huge manpower and land resources, alone could push up India’s GDP. If every Arunachalee is part of nation building process, shouldn’t we be ‘Team Arunachal’ in all senses as advocated by former governor ‘Gen. JJ’?

‘Hum bolega to bologey ke bolta hai! Lekin na boloon to kaisey? Kisiko to sach bolna hoga! (If I say, you resent that I’m saying. But why should not I say? Someone has to tell the truth).’

Related posts