NEW DELHI | May 11 | Supreme Court of India judges Dipak Misra and A M Khanwilkar, while dismissing Kameng Dolo Vs. Atum Welly (Civil appeal No. 2991 of 2017) on May 9 last, ruled that “in view of the aforesaid, there is no merit in this appeal and the same stands dismissed”.
“When there is no contest, and a desirable candidate for some reason is kept out of fray, the principle laid down in Vishwanatha Reddy (supra) has to be made applicable. We are disposed to think so, when in transgression of the statutory provision, a candidate’s candidature is allowed to be withdrawn, it will tantamount to sacrilege of democracy. That is why, the mandate of Section 37 of the Act has been so carefully worded. The legislature has taken pains to provide safeguards since illegal acceptance of withdrawal has the potentiality to destroy the base of democracy and corrode its primary roots.
“The principle stated in Krishnamoorthy v. Sivakumar [40], are to the effect that the sanctity of the electoral process imperatively commands that each candidate owes and is under an obligation that a fair election is held and freedom in the exercise of the judgment which engulfs a voter’s right, a free choice, in selecting the candidate whom he believes to be best fitted to represent the constituency, has to be given due weightage, are never to be eroded. The responsibility of a returning officer being statutorily significant, he has to keep himself alive to every facet and not act in a manner that will create a dent or hollowness in the election process, the order of the justices read.
It may be mentioned here that the SC on March 10 last had stayed the Gauhati High Court ruling of February 8 (Election Petition No. 2, 2014 Atum Welly Vs Kameng Dolo) in which the court had declared the election process of Pakke Kesang assembly constituency held in 2014, void. A three-judge bench of the top court passed an order staying elections and listed the matter on March 28 for a final hearing.
Dolo had won the seat unopposed on a Congress ticket, while Welly was his BJP contestant. Welly had filed a petition claiming that he had not withdrawn his candidature from the 2014 elections and that his signature was forged.
Dolo had earlier moved Supreme Court to stay the HC order but the SC had rejected his petition.
