NCERT a goof up master
Justifying the commom adage – Der ayae drust aye – the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) has woken up after long deep slumber to develop comprehensive book to sensitise students about NE India, its history, culture and war heroes that too after 20-year-old student Nido Tania was killed in a racial attack in New Delhi in 2014 followed by more such attacks.
Nido Tania, young son of MLA Nido Pavitra and APSWB chairperson Marina Nido, symbolised the causes of NE people and his sacrifice has brought never seen before national momentum against racism, then Chief Minister Nabam Tuki and Lok Sabha member Takam Sanjoy and few MLAs had said on 06.02.14, as highlighted by me – Martyr Nido Tania would propel anti-racism law: Tuki.
Addressing a group of youth who have conscientiously taken up the cause of Tania in CM’s bungalow here, Tuki had enlisted steps taken by him since 30.01.14.
The group without any affiliation what so ever highlighted the reforms needed for mainstreaming the NE people with their mainland counterparts and suggested steps to the CM to move the Centre to achieve the goal. The steps to safeguard future of the NE people and end racism against them included death penalty for Tania’s murders, enactment of anti-racial law, setting up of a special cell for NE students in Delhi, inclusion of history and culture of NE in national textbooks printed by NCERT, inclusion of Arunachal in national anthem, setting up of higher institutes of education, particularly engineering and medical in Arunachal, conducting seminar in different parts of the country to bring mass awareness on NE, particularly Arunachal.
“Tania has been made a sacrificial lamb but I’m confident that his sacrifice would bring solace and end racism against the NE people,” an emotionally charged Sanjoy said, adding Rajya Sabha member Mukut Mithi had led a delegation on 06.02.14 to meet AICC vice president Rahul Gandhi on the issue.
The isolated location, geographical barrier, unique features and life styles, the NE tribals carry with them their fierce independent attitude which obstructs them from assimilating with their mainland counterparts, lawmaker T Norbu Thongdok said, adding “When Tania has turned the voice of our cause, we have to realise the truth and propagate ourselves in right perspective for the rest of India to accept us. Let us forward one step for other to emulate. We have to decide conscientiously steps to bring national awareness about u.”
Lawmakers Gojen Gadi, Thangwang Wangham & Kimsi Sidisow had expressed their grave concern.
It was interesting but praise worth that Chief Minister Nabam Tuki during his recent visit to America received assurance from the global service provider Google to rectify its maps that projects Arunachal Pradesh wrongly that too differently in its different web portals to please its global clientele, unmindful of the impacts of such acts, particularly for Arunachal, an indivisible part of India, I had highlighted in Blame yourself India, why only Google!, in Beyond the Horizon on 24.11.14.
An in-depth analysis of the entire issue would lead to a conclusion that Google cannot shrink its responsibility but the central and state Govts are more to be blamed.
Why because racial discrimination of NE people in the mainland have been rising since last few years and getting wide negative publicity in media, but the mistakes about Arunachal Pradesh maps and tribes are equally on a rise reflecting the insensitivity of the central and state Govts.
It was the ‘Board of Studies’ of Maharashtra state education department which had committed the mistake in the Class-X Geography textbooks, in which maps did not depict Arunachal Pradesh as a part of India
Then chief minister Prithviraj Chavan, in response to a letter to his Arunachal counterpart Tuki in May 2013, had said that directives have been issued to the department concerned to stop circulation of books with the map in question and withdraw books which have already been circulated.
VC Shukla killed to avenge violence perpetrated by Salwa Judum, say Maoists“I have also directed the department to take disciplinary action against the officials responsible for the printing error,” he said in the letter. The Maharashtra Govt, simultaneously, is making the correct version of the book available to students through their respective schools. The Govt is also making earnest efforts to ensure that students do not have access to books carrying the incorrect map. Due process has been initiated for disbanding the ‘Board of Studies’ responsible for approving the book with wrong maps, the letter added.
That was not enough. Even after the derogatory word Dafla was replaced by Nyishi by a constitutional amendment on 15.02.08, the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) committed the blunder in its Geography textbooks for Class XI, where it was mentioned “Dafla Abor and Nagas inhabit the Arunachal Himalayas”. The text book was originally printed in 2006 and reprinted in January 2013.
In April 2012, the Republican Party of India (RPI) Athavale group demanded a ban on an 11th grade text book saying that a cartoon in the book insulted Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar. In the cartoon, former Indian PM Jawaharlal Nehru, holds a whip and along with Ambedkar is driving a snail, which represents the Indian Constitution. Then HRD Minister Kapil Sibal had apologised to the nation and asked NCERT to remove the cartoon from their textbooks.
If law says ignorance is not an excuse. Should the NCERT authorities go scot-free?
But the goof up continues. This time by the Bihar Govt which released a map of Patna’s Master Plan 2031 of urban development department on 18.11.14 in which Jammu & Kashmir and Arunachal Pradesh were missing from map of India.
The Bihar Govt was prompt in suspending two officials for the mistake after the BJP termed it as a serious issue and demanded action against those responsible for this negligence.
“It’s a criminal negligence and action must be taken against those guilty for this,” was the reaction of senior RJD leader Raguvansh Prasad Sigh.
Following the widespread criticism, state’s UD Minister Samrat Chaudhury suspended two department officials for negligence on the issue.
