The Goods and Service Tax, an uniform revolutionary nation-wide tax regime, was introduced on Saturday. This is undoubtedly a welcome move, but some of its clauses impose huge tax burden on the masses for the reasons best known to the law framers. The GST having far reaching consequences leaving none from its impacts irrespective of men or women, rich or poor and handicapped or beggar, has been hogging the media limelight.
The Times of India in its June 30 edition highlighted the impact of GST in – Singara, kachori, sandesh to leave bitter taste in mouth. Relish your favourite savouries and sweets today. Come tomorrow, it just might taste a tad bitter. Your favourite snack — Singara, kachori, radhaballabi and the like – sold 24×7 at Kolkata’s ubiquitous mishtir dokaan and consumed at all times of the day will be taxed under the GST regime, wrote Udit Prasanna Mukherji.
The highlights were mindboggling:
* With all major branded stores that retail snacks and sweets now under GST net, the kachuri, singara will be costlier as snack items will attract 12% GST.
* If they are consumed in the store, the GST will be 18%.
* Industry observers said the effective price of all products is likely to go up by 6%-8%.
Is it not for the first time in India that eatables are taxed in such mindless manner? Or does it justify Prime Minister Narendra Mdoi’s pet quote – na khaunga na khane dunga? Is PM not proving the common Hindi saying Aadmi ki pehchan baton se hoti hey (A man is known by the way he speaks) right through the GST?
“From chocolate bars to chocolate sandesh, black forest cakes to chocolate ice-creams, anything with a hint of chocolate will sting as Jaitley & Co has put chocolate in the highest GST slab of 28%.
With all major branded stores that retail snacks, sweets and savouries like Ganguram, Haldiram, Balaram Mullick & Radharaman Mullick, Banchharam, Kamdhenu, Mouchak, Sen Mahasay, Haldiram, Bikharam Chandmal and Tewari now under the GST net, the kachuri/kochuri-samosa/singara fare sold from these stores will be costlier as namkeen snack items will attract 12% GST. If they are consumed in the store, the GST will be 18%.
Industry observers said the effective price of all products is likely to go up by 6%-8%. “While no GST has been imposed on fish and vegetables as they are perishables, no such benefit has been granted to snacks and sweets that also don’t have shelf-life,” rued Sudip Mullick of Bhawanipore’s heritage brand Balaram Mullick & Radharaman Mullick.
Some of their best-selling sweets like chocolate rosogolla, chocolate sandesh, chocolate mudpie sandesh, black forest sandesh, rice ball, chocolate chips, chocolate singara and chocolate jalbhara may get badly dented by the 28% GST levied on them.
“The impact will be so huge that one cannot possibly absorb the impact. There are two things that can be done. One is to retain the size and hike the price. The other is to retain the price and reduce the size. We haven’t yet taken a decision but no matter which of the two it is, the customer will not like it,” said Rana Nandy of Girish Chandra Dey & Nakur Chandra Nandy.
Modi’s sarcastic comment “Na Khaunga na khane dunga”, was against corruption, not eatable, reacted a journalist friend. There was clear efforts in getting black money back in India since day one of Modi Govt and more than Rs 3.5000 crore black money have been recovered from one time compliance window. Even entrepreneurs have acknowledged that corruption has reduced at top level at Modi Govt.
But GST has reversed BJP-led NDA Govt’s policy “sabka saath, sabka vikas (Cooperation of all, development for all). This is not just for domestic programmes but also for international cooperation. We want to carry everyone along for development,” PM Modi had said during a panel discussion at St. Petersburg International Economic Forum on 07.04.17, reported ANI, as the GST has proved otherwise.
Nobody is fully prepared for GST: ‘The near term will be challenging, as most will struggle to adapt to the new regime.’
Future Group CEO Kishore Biyani believes the GST has multiple implications for his sector. While the near-term will be challenging, the long term will augur well for both the retail and consumer markets as ease of doing business improves, he tells Viveat Susan Pinto, as reported by Business Standard.
How prepared is your group for GST? Nobody is fully prepared for the GST.
Everybody is learning along the way and so are we. I believe there are multiple implications due to this tax reform.
The near term will be challenging, as most will struggle to adapt to the new regime. In the long run, however, there are benefits; the biggest being the ease of doing business.
For retailers, benefits accrue at the front as well as back-end.
At the front-end, they will be able to set up more stores because execution challenges will reduce. At the back-end, the logistics and warehousing issues will ease. It will become more efficient because of the concept of a unified market.
Top retailers recently met to discuss some of the challenges the sector would face. What were these?
The discussion was about pricing and protection of margins. Will margins get squeezed in the event if there are price hikes? How are FMCGs dealing with this issue and what will be the impact on consumers and retailers due to this?
What is the extent of price hikes?: There was a need to come together and put our minds to these issues. There are also some other teething problems that require attention such as including GST as a component in the product price, as opposed to raising a separate bill for it.
There are also discrepancies that could creep in due to the variable GST structure on products.
For instance, packaged commodities will be charged at 5%, while those sold loosely will be exempt from GST.
How do we deal with this dynamic?: Future Group is also a manufacturer and distributor of consumer products through Future Consumer.Do you propose to raise prices of your products once GST kicks in?
No, we do not. Our plan is to reduce product prices by 2 to 22% across categories. This is because GST rates will be lower. This will be beneficial to consumers.
Will that give you greater scope to compete with e-tailers, whose biggest advantage is the lower price that they bring to the table?
I can only speak for myself. We will bring down prices across products, so I see this having a positive impact on business.
What is happening to that industry (e-tailing) is visible to all. But I do think that everybody will do what is right for their respective businesses.
What are the investments you’ve made in your business to be GST-ready?
We are ready to file invoices based on the new structure on July 1. We had set up teams internally to help us make that shift.
It is a nationalist Govt and could practise exactly the opposite of what they preach as long as they hold the rein!, isn’t it?
Meanwhile, directorate of field publicity, Tawang unit, in a special outreach programme at Lumla village on Friday highlighted about the revolutionary GST and various flagship programme taken up by Narendra Modi govt during the last three years.
