Innovative Pul aimed to solve state’s all perpetual ills

By Pradeep Kumar

NAHARLAGUN | Aug 14 | Former leader, late Kalikho Pul, described as people’s chief minister, acted to remove all perpetual problems of Arunachal Pradesh.

The Mera Vichar Andolan Committee, while observing his first death anniversary as Balidan Diwas on August 8 last, had recalled his contributions. He is gone but his invaluable innovative planning methods would continue to benefit the state for times to come.

Many of his steps taken during very short tenure (19.02.16 to 13.07.16) as chief minister are visible but numerous historical milestones taken by him are neither visible nor known to many.

Visible: He was aware that education is the panacea to solve all ills confronting the tribal society. He knew that numerous schools were upgraded and new ones opened on political ground without buildings or furniture or creating posts for which classes are conducted in two to three sessions to accommodate the growing number of students throughout the state and Capital Complex is no exception. Thus during visit to few capital schools, he had sanctioned funds for constructing buildings to accommodate ever growing enrolled strength.

The ongoing construction of buildings in G-sector upper primary school with 797 strength and 40 teachers, running in two shifts, is a glittering proof. So also the G sector community hall, which was damaged during 17.12.15 political upheaval as the ruling group was accused of damaging it after dissident group had their sitting there. He departed the mortal world but the ongoing works bore his indelible marks for others to emulate.

He, in fact intended to change the adhoc governing policy for state building. I described him as financial wizard for remembering decade-long financial figures of accurately besides being the longest serving FM of the country. I was very closely associated with him for which he used to open up his heart to me very often than not. Some of his very important mile stones, according to me, included:

Invisible: Some of his very important mile stones, according to me, included:

1) Departure from the past: As finance-planning minister,  he had earmarked Rs. 100 crore in 2006-07 budget for service sectors (health, education & road connectivity)  to replace the ramshackle structures of all schools and health units throughout the state by new ones to make development visible in 60 assembly constituencies without any discrimination or distinction. His “massive infrastructure development plan” released in June 2006 was the proof.

2) Highest employees: He had called on then union finance minister PC Chidambaram in September 2008 to seek financial assistance to meet  Rs 521.16 crore additional burden  for 6th Pay Commission (SPC) pay package for that year and Rs 893.61 crore next year (total Rs 1414.77 crore). But PC was surprised to know that the state has around 1 lakh employees @ 1:14 against the national average of 1:20,000.  This means that one out of every 14 persons in Arunachal is a GoAP employee, which is abnormally high. The GoAP used to divert around 47% of normal central assistance (NCA) for all non-plan and non-developmental activities including salary and wages as against the 20% admissible by the Planning Commission. The 2008 plan allocation of Rs 2264.60 crore included Rs 761.18 crore NCA, which permits diversion of upto Rs 152.24 crore only.

However, he was instrumental in implementing SPC and the last meeting with CoSSAP members in his residence had continued till late night which I had attended. He succeeded in convincing the group for them to avail the financial benefits.

3) Arunachal went for statehood early: Had the state been a union territory, all the expenditure would have been borne even now by the Centre. But Arunachal not only went for statehood, it also adopted the central pay structure in 1997 for its failure to constitute its own pay commission even after a decade.

FM Pul had commented on 11.12.08:  “Arunachal Pradesh went for statehood early for political reasons” is an undeniable fact for the simple reason that the GoAP  is now caught between the devil and the deep sea in meeting its employees’ demand to implement the 6th Pay Commission recommendations in toto wef  01-01-06.

The revenue-starved special category state finds it difficult even to avail of central sponsored schemes of 90:10, 80:20, 75:25, 70:30 & 50:50 for its failure to pay its matching shares, because it earns a meager revenue (Rs 366 crore this year). Once it earns enough revenue it could pay anything to its employees without any bar, Pul reasoned.  The additional annual burden for the pay package would be Rs 729.26 crore (average), Pul disclosed, indicating that the year-wise liability (in crore) of Rs 521.16 (40% arrear) for 2008-09, Rs 893.61 (60% arrear) for 2009-10, Rs 646.30-2010-11, Rs 774.17-2011-12, Rs 890.29-2012-13, Rs 1023.83-2013-14 and Rs 1181.02-2015-16.

The present annual salary and pension liability is Rs 750.96 crore, which would go up to Rs 1488.22 crore excluding ex-gratia payments, grants-in-aid, wages, contingency, air freight, bonus, MR bills, overtime allowances, domestic traveling expenses, foreign traveling expenses, professional services, rent, office expenditure, minor works, emergent relief & restoration expenditure, loan repayment, operation vehicles & maintenance, POL and other charges.

He cited the example of fiscal indiscipline and resource crunch that had led to a Rs 341-crore overdraft in 2005. There was no money to pay salaries and wages to the employees and stipend in April which forced the state to take Rs 200 crore short-term loan. But the financial condition deteriorated again in September, forcing another loan of Rs 200 crore from the National Small Saving Fund, said Pul, a financial wizard, and cautioned that if the financial discipline is violated, even halting of the state government’s transactions by the RBI cannot be ruled out in the future.

Pointing out that the financial position is crystal clear, Pul said if the implementation with notional fixation from 01-01-06 is effected from 01-01-09 with prospective effect, the revenue gap could be reflected in the memorandum to be submitted to the 13th Finance Commission.   Appreciating the claims of the employees, Pul said, “Hum sab hai to state hai. Yeh hum sab ka sankalit zimmedari hai ki kesey state ko theek dhang sey chalaye (We exist with the state. It is our collective responsibility to run the state smoothly). This was first such meeting that had taught a lesson on public finance and the people-centric policies of the ruling Congress Govt, which was summed up by Pul: “Cut your coat according to your cloth.”

4) India’s highest loanee: In the absence of the state’s own resource as a UT, there would have been no need for loans – which amounts to Rs 3012 crore now, making Arunachal the second highest loanee in the country, as per latest RBI report. This has cost the exchequer Rs 347.86 crore as debt servicing liability in 2008.

Moreover, if the huge fund pumped in during the state’s years as a UT had been spent in a planned manner to tap the state’s power, tourism, mining, minerals, oil, industrial sector and natural resources, Arunachal would have not only become a front-ranking state by now but wouldn’t have been facing such a situation, he had told the GoAP employees in a meeting.

5) Reducing debt liability: A leader with Exceptional memory, very organised and systematic in keeping records had always stood him in good stead to steer through any man made age-old junk system.  That was why he had taken very bold step to increase planned expenditure than non-plan to  reduce debt liability of the state.

6) A financial educator: He always presented budget as finance minister in most creative way. He used to clarify for hours together during budget discussion while the house used to listen with err silence. His explanation used to be very educative and lucid even for a lay man to understand.

7) JFW: Thrilled with the then union finance minister P Chidambaram launching Journalists’ Welfare Fund (JWF) at national level in 2008, I approached him during lunch hour during an assembly session. He wanted me give a brief and I did it by writing a single sentence  in my very small notepad. As I left by 5 pm to present budget report in AIR, my friends, to my shocking surprise, had  informed me that Pul had announced JWF with a grant of Rs 10 lakh as corpus fund as approved by then CM Dorjee Khandu, that had made Arunachal Pradesh, among very few sates to have such fund but the sole credit goes to Pul. However, Khandu who before attending as chief guest of National Press Day-2009 had asked to as to what should he announce. My suggestion was add few lakhs to JWF. But Khandu to my surprise had announced Rs 10 lakh. That was why I always termed him as laughing Buddha as he wanted everyone in the state to be happy. Alas… had both been alive! But then CM Nabam Tuki added Rs 10 lakh in 2010 and again Pul had added Rs one crore.

Last but not the least, he was far sighted and visionary and his continuation would have benefited every Arunachalee and the state immensely. His Dada…Dada call reverberates in my ears and I miss him so much. Alas…the destiny snatched him away from us. Who can question the destiny which bears the seal of almighty?

Related posts