GDP growth set to slow down to 6.7% in 2017-18
Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
The GoI on one hand has launched Swachha Bharat Abhiyan (SWA) to clean the country to make every Indian healthy and on the other has introduced GST that turned out to be Ghutghutke Shrif Tadpo, particularly for the rag pickers.
With the GST rate on recycled plastic rising up from 5.5% to 18%, rag picking as a livelihood seems to be turning unviable while rage pickers getting disinterested in collecting the waste and contradicting the SWA with far bearing impacts on urban environment.
Mohit Rao of The Hindu cited befitting examples in – Ragpickers hit hard by GST, on 26.07.17 to prove the horrifying impacts of GST.
“Take the case of Nagaratna and her self-help group (SHG) at Mahadevapura. Nearly a month post-GST, the Mahadevapura Mahila Okkuta, a collection of 17 SHGs that collects and segregates waste in Garudacharpalya, is staring at the prospect of their profits being wiped out.
“Before GST, they had consistently made Rs 30,000 as surplus. “This month it is zero,” says Nagaratna from the Okkuta. “We have been collecting and recycling waste for over 12 years now. We have never faced a situation like this. We’ve even had to cut down on the lunch we give our workers.”
“After the onset of the GST, the 18% tax imposed on waste plastic has sparked a downward spiral in prices in the waste recycling markets. Plastic recyclers faced with the new tax are protecting their margins by slashing the prices at which they buy from the thousands of waste managers and rag pickers.
“The price of mixed plastic has come down from Rs19 per kg to around Rs 13 now. Lucrative PET bottles fetch Rs 17 per kg, as against Rs 22 last month; empty milk covers sell at barely Rs 7 per kg, down from Rs 16; glass bottles (750ml) go for 50 paisa per kg, instead of Rs 1.5 per undamaged bottle. These figures were collected by The Hindu from various waste collectors.
“We work on tiny margins, of barely Rs 1.5 per kg recycled. When prices drop, our business sinks. We can only hope that this is temporary, for otherwise it would become difficult to recycle. This being an informal sector, not many have TIN (Taxpayer Identification Number). Taxes paid by the recyclers are recovered from us instead,” says Mansoor Ahmed Ghouse, who manages a dry waste collection centre where 12 workers process 2.5 tonnes of waste daily.
“Similarly, Hasiru Dala, an organisation of waste workers that manages 43 such centres, says that civic workers have significantly reduced selling plastics to collection centres as the prices are “no longer lucrative.”
“At Jali Mohalla, one of the largest open markets for recyclable products in the city, the lower demand for recycled products, coupled with the “sudden introduction of confusing taxes” has resulted in lower purchases of waste material.
“A little higher up the recycling chain, Rasool Khan of KK Plastics, which fashions recycled waste into bitumen, says the hike in tax rates from 5.5% to 18% has made their products uncompetitive. “All we can do is cut our margins so that even with the higher tax rate, the product is sold at the same rate. I don’t understand how an environment-friendly initiative such as recycling can be taxed at this high rate,” he said.
“Incidentally, the GST has hit the civic corporation too. Under the present system, it has outsourced the sweeping of streets, collection of segregated garbage from homes, and transportation of waste. All these activities have overnight become a ‘service’ under the GST regime. Considering that the corporation spends more than Rs. 400 crore on these ‘services, the 18% tax burden works out to Rs 72 annually.
On the other hand, the GoI tax policy indicates to make the richers and push the poor to a road of no return.
Vodafone turns text to pretext
The I-T Department had issued Vodafone a reminder over its Rs 14,200-crore tax demand and threatened to seize assets in the case of non-payment, a move the UK firm said shows disconnect with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s’s promise of a tax-friendly environment.
The department on February 4 (Feb 16, 2016) had sent a notice to Vodafone International Holdings BV seeking Rs 14,200 crore in taxes, which it says are due from its $11 billion acquisition of Hutchison Whampoa’s India telecom business in 2007. The matter is under international arbitration.
“We can confirm that we have received a tax reminder from the IT department with references to asset seizures in the event of non-payment,” a Vodafone spokesperson said.
The British telecom major has disputed the tax demand over its acquisition of 67% stake in Hutchison, now called Vodafone India, arguing that no tax was due as the transaction was conducted offshore.
But the tax department’s contention is capital gains were made on assets in India.
“The Indian Govt stated in 2014 that existing tax disputes, including ours, would be resolved through the existing judicial process,” Vodafone said in the statement. The company also made a reference to the promise made by Modi at Make-in-India event in Mumbai on Saturday.
Jaitley recuses himself
Finance minister Arun Jaitley is believed to have recused himself from Rs 20,000 crore Vodafone tax dispute and delegated his junior minister Nirmala Sitharaman decision to decide, PTI reported on 18.06.14.
Jaitley has on file recorded that all issues relating to the Vodafone tax case be referred to MoS (Finance) Sitharaman or revenue secretary Shaktikanta Das, sources said. No reason for Jaitley’s decision was given but it may be linked to the fact he could have been associated with either parties in the case in his capacity as a senior lawyer. In case of an unresolved issue or a conflict, Jaitley has desired that the matter be referred to PM Modi, sources added.
GDP growth slows down
The hit in growth due to demonetisation and goods and services tax has been ‘more disruptive than expected’, India Ratings and Research (IRR) said.
The “more disruptive than expected” impact of demonetisation and the goods and services tax is set to slow India’s economic growth down to 6.7% in 2017-’18, India Ratings and Research said on Wednesday. The ratings agency had earlier pegged the growth in GST at 7.4% in the current financial year.
The agency revised its outlook following continued slowdown in the first two quarters of 2017. The GDP growth had reached a three-year low of 5.7% in the quarter that ended in June. In the first quarter of 2017, growth had slowed to 5.7% from 7.9% in the same period last year.
The negative impact of the new indirect tax system will reverse eventually, but the same cannot be said about the impact of demonetisation, IRS said.
However, growth will recover in the July-September quarter as the impact of demonetisation is waning and the Govt is looking into the problems in GST implementation, the agency said. The festival season will also support growth.
The unorganized sector and small and medium enterprises have not yet recovered fully from the Govt’s exercise to remove high-value currency notes last November, without quickly replacing them, the agency added. (Agency)
