Work order move rejected after seesaw deliberations

 

Light goes off: Shocking the members, the light went off at 4.43 pm for two minutes, but the proceeding continued prompting  Wangling Lowangdong to quip: “Speaker sir, we should wait for light to come”.

By A O News Service

ITANAGAR | Oct 14 | Raising another private member’s resolution, former chief minister Nabam Tuki suggested the GoAP to take steps to restore and increase the limit of work order (without tender system) of contract work as par CPWD manual up to Rs one crore in all works departments to create scopes and opportunities for unemployed indigenous people of the state.

Tuki said that present system is excluding some sections of the society, which, if continued would ultimately zero down to rich and poor communities. Only 10% is made happy and rest 90% is neglected. Everything in the past was built on work order system including the capital road. Litigation and court involvement called for transparency for equal right, which should be applicable for major projects. But minor works in rural areas should be exempted from this system, he said.

Though it is subjudice, the assembly being the ears and eyes of the people could decide on it with reference to CPWD manual, which envisions 5% concession for STs and SCs, he reasoned.

Tender though intended transparency and equality, but highest bidders are winning now at the cost of lowest bidder. Repeated retendering of many projects have caused losses to public instead of benefitting, he said to justify his resolution and sought support of all, Tuki said.

Tribals have community life linked to culture, he said, adding anyone objecting the resolution would not be spared by the public, as 1% only are opposing District Entrepreneurship Act while 99% are happy, he claimed.

Pointing out at merits and demerits of the resolution, Japu Deru said the CPWD worked during 1981 to 1983 with work order system when people were ignorant. If this work order would have been fair, all 60 MLAs would have been elected unopposed. He said such work order had swelled up state’s liabilities up to Rs 4,000 crore but  CM Khandu has adjusted Rs 3,000 crore.

There was no tender system in 2009 when he was elected, Tapuk Taku said, with Rs 10 crore SPA given by Dorjee Khandu Govt many good works in Seppa were done but  nothing could be done by tender system.  Thus, he supported work order system.

Both resolutions were linked to unemployment, Tapang Taloh said highlighting vision of present  PM and CM to benefit each citizen. Industrial growth could solve unemployed  problem and termed work order good system as tendering process has  major setback including match fixing, black mailing. He advocated a suitable mechanism to assess how funds are percolating down to the masses and how to generate employment by work order system.

Tanga Byaling said everyone understands every aspect of this resolution. Thus, the GoAP should clarify whether it should be passed or not.

The state is following CPWD guidelines, Tage Taki said, but tender works are specified. Emergency works, VIP works etc are executed on work order system for which there is no need to pass a resolution but specific direction should be given to working departments.

Dikto Yekar supported the resolution, saying that the society is getting divided between rich and poor. Tender system hits hard unemployed youth for no fund. Below Rs one crore work order system is welcome.

DyCM  Chowna Mein said resolutions are matter of policy rising above opposition or ruling benches.  He cited the example of blocked Karsingsa road which was restored immediately, but the Centre refused to pay.

He read out CPWD manual which specifies tendering process for all works as cardinal principle. Work order involves pick and choose, poor quality and law & order problems, he said, adding the state has good number of  local contractors. The District Entrepreneurship Act has been facilitating local contractors to get works. He referred to PIL cases filed against non-tendering. Works with tender are still given under SADA which invites litigation, he said. Thus, work order system cannot be followed, he clarified and urged to withdraw the resolution.

Tuki’s intentions are good,  CM Pema Khandu said, adding all works are bound by laws. Thus, adoption of resolution would make the state a laughing stock and open another window of corruption, he said and opposed the resolution.

CPWD is applicable in the state, Deputy Speaker Tumke Bagra, said which prompted Tuki to withdraw his resolution.

Related posts