Golden chance for BJP to find an acceptable solution: NPP

Decades-old Assam-Arunachal boundary row

 

ITANAGAR | Dec 13 | Reacting to recent eviction of tourist bungalows worth Rs 5 crore built in Indian Air force bombing zone at Dollungmukh by Assam Govt National People’s Party (NPP) today said it has reminded the decades-old inter-state boundary dispute.

The boundary drawn by one-man Bordoloi Commission notified in 1951 for political and revenue purposes has been the cause of such repeated eviction drives by Assam police and forest officials victimizing Arunachalees for none of their faults though they had rejected the notification ab intio.

These evictions have deteriorated the age-old relations of people living peacefully along the boundary for ages but both state Govts have remained mute spectators. Assam and Arunachal Pradesh were ruled by the Congress for a long time when the party was in power in the Centre but no tangible step was taken to find an amicable and acceptable solution except resorting to judicial remedy, NYP vice president Nima Sange said in a release.

Both neighbouring states have been embroiled in a boundary dispute along a 792-sqkm area they share. But Assam had filed a law suit on boundary dispute in 1989 in Supreme Court, which in 2015 had framed the issues to be decided in the case.

“Whether the plaint does not disclose a cause of action? Whether the present suit for determination and/or demarcation of the boundaries between the two disputing States, is barred by Article 3 of the Constitution of India?..,” the bench, which also comprised justices R K Agrawal and R Banumathi, had said.

“Whether the boundary, delineated in the Survey of India map published in 1984 and as delineated in greater detail in 29 topographical maps prepared by Survey of India set out in Schedule I to the plaint represents the true Constitutional boundary between the State of Assam and Arunachal Pradesh.

“In case Issue No.1 is found in the negative, what is the true Constitutional boundary between the two States of  Assam and Arunachal Pradesh?,” the Sc had said while specifying the points of dispute. It had then asked Assam to lead evidence in support of its claim, they said quoting 10.07.15 Business Standard issue.

The SC responding to Assam Govt petition for redrawing the boundary, in its judgment and order dated 25.9.06 had appointed a local boundary commission for identification of boundaries of both states. The JBC headed by retired justice Tarun Chatterjee and members SP Goel and Kamal Naidu had  inspected disputed Arunachal-Assam boundary areas of Tarasso, Gumto and Kimin under Papumpare district; Likabali under West Siang, Gerukamukh and Dollungmukh under Lower Subansiri district to take stock of the ground realities while interacting with the people in November  2013, they said and wondered  why the issue has remained in limbo?

Coincidentally, BJP now ruling at the Centre as well as in Assam and Arunachal offers a golden opportunity to find a lasting solution, which if achieved, would endear BJP to the people which the party could encash during next general elections in 2019. There are seasoned BJP politicians who should realise the gravity of the issue and move tactfully faster to solve the issue, the release added.

 

1951 notification – a legal bone in Arunachal’s throat

By Pradeep Kumnar

Though the Constitution of India was ready by 26.11.1949, India formally became a sovereign republic only on 26.01.1950. All official formalities for brining North East Frontier Tract (NEFT) under 6th Schedule of the Constitution was complete by then. Bordoloi, who was Prime Minister of Assam and chairman of NE Frontier and Assam Tribal Area Excluded Sub-committee and member of the drafting committee of the constituent assembly, had pleaded before the GoI that the tribals of Assam and North East Frontier Tracts (NEFT) were different from the rest of India and should be dealt with through a different parameter, according to the records.

After completing his report, Bordoloi was waiting for India to attain its full-fledged sovereign status to move the report for the assent of the President of India. He did it when none in the NEFT (present Arunachal Pradesh) was aware of either the move or the impact it would have on this Himalayan state and its populace.

Once the presidential assent was obtained, Bordoloi, having authority formally notified the report on  23.02.1951 that demarcated the boundary between then NEFT and Assam, with legal sanctity.

However, an 18-member team of Assamese newsmen led by the state’s deputy IPR director Hiranya Kumar Bhuyan on a four-day goodwill mission in Sep 2008 was shocked when Tana Joy, gaon buri of Taraso village, who had lost her everything, including traditional ornaments, during  22.04.08 eviction drive conducted by Armed police personnel led by Sonitour DC, had narrated in detail (in chaste Assamese) how she suffered, and questioned – “Is this eviction? Are we not Indians? Why should we be looted, tormented and left homeless for no fault of ours?”

“Things hardly have changed. And another boundary dispute had cropped up at Shimhokho location of Kamkuh Rusa village under Kanubari sub-division of Tirap district bordering Sibsagar district of Assam in Aug 2010, where an Arunachalee had sustained grievous injuries in indiscriminate firing by Assam police.” The Dollungmukh eviction is latest in the series.

Related posts