GST turns ground spoiling tax or tango? – A

 

Tango Vs GST

Tango is a third-party, cross platform messaging application software for smartphones developed by TangoME, Inc. in 2009. The app is free and is popular for offering video calls over 3G, 4G and Wi-Fi networks. GST is cross platform involving manufacturers of goods & service, suppliers & consumers and the Govt.

If Tango had more than 200 million registered users as of March 2014 and, 12th most downloaded app globally among Android devices, why the GST has failed to achieve its goal is a million dollar question.

By Padeep Kumar

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) was rolled out on 01.07.17 replacing numerous taxes and levies as a single but major tax reform in India.

The GST subsumed Central taxes – Central Excise Duty, additional Excise Duty (Goods of Special Importance), Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Products), Excise Duty levied under the Medicinal and Toiletries Preparation Act, Service Tax, additional Customs Duty or Countervailing Duty,  Special Additional Duty of Customs-4%, Cesses and surcharges on goods and services and state taxes – State VAT, Central Sales Tax (levied by the Centre and collected by the states), Entertainment Tax, all Octroi & Entry Tax , Purchase Tax, Luxury Tax, Taxes on lottery, betting and gambling, state cesses and surcharges on supply of goods & services and taxes on advertisements

But none imagined that ultimately it would prove to be ground spoiling tango in very complex Indian economy? Following factual analysis will be enough to hold ground.

Aug 2, 2016

Despite multiple bans on plastic bags even in national capital, including a NGT order in 2017 that prohibited non-biodegradable plastic bags fewer than 50 microns in thickness, authorities are yet to fully clamp down on the menace. Though the number came down considerably after a couple of months due to fine, according to a 2014 toxics link study on plastic waste, plastic was contributing directly to ground, air and water pollution and ending up at landfill sites, where it stayed for centuries as it does not decompose easily.

Then MoS (Environment, Forest and Climate Change) Anil Dave, an environment crusador and BJP strategist, in a written response to a question in Lok Sabha, on 02.08.16 had said consumption pattern and consumer behaviour have changed and witnessed a manifold increase in Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) or water resistant bottles and plastic used for wrapping of products. 62 million tonnes of muncipal soild waste were generated annually in urban areas, he had said quoting erstwhile Planning Commission constituted task force report of 2014.

However, as per the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) 2014-15 report, 51.4 million tonnes of solid waste were generated in India, of which 91% was collected, and 27% was treated and remaining 73% disposed of at dump sites.

“The CPCB had estimated the generation of 15,342 tonnes of plastic waste in the country, out of which, 9,205 tonnes were reported to be recycled and leaving 6,137 tonnes uncollected and littered,” Dave had said, adding his ministry had comprehensively revised the Plastic Waste (Management and Handling) Rules 2011, and notified Plastic Waste Management Rules in March 2017.

“These rules prescribe two years’ time to phase out manufacturing non-recylable multi-layered plastic.”
“The lack of awareness and absence of effective tools to collect back the discarded plastic products including the wrapping material has led to the indiscriminate littering and disposal of plastic waste,” Dave said.

He said the new rules provide for ways and means to minimise plastic waste generation, adoption of extended producer responsibility for collection of waste and sustainable plastic waste management, recycling and utilisation of plastic waste in road construction, energy and oil generation. However, more than 15,000 tonnes of plastic waste are generated in India everyday, of which 6,000 tonnes remain uncollected and littered, he had added.

The GST enraged may corporate bodies to seek legal redressal against it and Dabur suing the GoI for denying tax sops under GST is the latest case.

“Dabur NSE 1.03% has dragged the central and Uttarakhand Govts to court for rejecting tax sops for investment in poorer areas promised under the pre-GST tax regime, joining a growing list of firms miffed at the Govt for denial of such concessions,” Sachin Dave reported from MUMBAI in Business Standard on June 22 last.

“Dabur availed of benefits such as 10-year tax holiday after investing in Uttarakhand’s backward areas but faced problems after the GST rollout when older taxes were subsumed under the GST umbrella.

“Dabur is one of the first major companies to join the writ petition filed in the Nainital bench of Uttarakhand High Court. But suppliers to some leading consumer goods companies have also complained of discrimination and lack of clarity in GST regulations about the tax benefits.
“Under the previous tax regime, manufacturers investing in backward areas of certain states would get indirect tax exemptions from the state governments – and sometimes from the central government. The idea was to encourage more investments in these poorer regions. India’s top FMCG companies such as Hindustan UnileverNSE 2.40% and Godrej Consumer have been sourcing most of their products from manufacturers in these areas. Some have also set up plants. Dabur did not respond to an email query sent on Wednesday.

“Tax experts say that transition of credits on capital investments is allowed under GST. But there is no clarity around credit on investments made in industrially marginalised areas. They added that under the earlier tax regime, there was no tax on the products manufactured or output of manufactures as the inputs-capital expenditure or raw materials-were also tax exempt. In most situations, the taxes on outputs were set off against input tax credits.

“Since there was a 10-year tax holiday and no taxes on output under the earlier tax regime, there was no question of input credit on capital goods earlier,” said Abhishek A Rastogi, partner, Khaitan & Co. Under GST cost of capital expenditure incurred cannot be set off against the GST paid by the companies, say industry trackers. This is creating problems for these companies.

“It is legitimate to expect the proportional credit on capital goods transitioned as the credit was allowed not only in the earlier regime but also in the present regime,” added Rastogi who is the arguing for one of the petitioners in the matter.

This could also end up as a flaring point between few state governments and the centre as to how such areas must be treated now. Denial of tax sops or tax holidays could mean that many manufactures may move their facilities to other areas.

The impact is huge for capital intensive units which had invested in the area-based exempt zones, say people in the know.

Interestingly, APL Apollo Tubes, a Mumbai-based pipe and tube manufacturer, had moved Bombay High Court against the central government and the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) for allegedly infringing on its right to do business, as was reported on February 21 last by Economics Times, after receiving a copy of the petition.

In a writ petition, the company alleged that GSTN tampered with the company’s GSTTran-1, which is the form for claiming credit of taxes paid under the earlier tax regime prior to the rollout of goods and services tax (GST) in July 2017. The company contended that it had claimed tax credit of around Rs 16 crore, but due to an error on the part of the GSTN only about Rs 4 crore was credited to the company. This was akin to the Govt going back on its promise to pay money in a normal business transaction, APL Apollo Tubes NSE-0.46%, claimed in its petition.

Related posts