IJU flays biased formation of PCI, calls for reformation

NEW DELHI, Aug 19: Criticising the manner in which the Press Council of India (PCI) was reconstituted recently, Indian Journalists Union (IJU) today called for formation of an independent media council.

The criticsm came during the concluding session of two-day annual IJU national executive committee meeting here when the participants advocated strengthening media freedom in the country.

PCI chairman former justice Chandramauli Kumar Prasad, earlier this year, had rejected all six nominees made by the Editors Guild of India, Hindi Samacharpatra Sammelan and All India Newspapers Conference for constitution of 13th Press Council.

The Indian Newspaper Society (INS) had moved the Delhi High Court against the PCI’s decision to reject the nomination of Hormusji N. Cama, owner of weekly Mumbai Samachar & INS member, in medium newspapers category. The HC had stayed the PCI’s decision. The INS had accused the PCI chief of “biased” selection of new members. The claims were, however, rejected by the media watchdog, which said, laid down rules were followed for induction of new members. The IJU adopted a resolution criticizing the former judge’s action.

“Shockingly, the outgoing chairman chose to brazenly do away with well-established procedures and interpreted the rules & guidelines perversely with the intent to keep out some organisations and its choice of members. Worse, he held a series of meetings of a truncated council (with 20 of 28 members yet to be officially notified) to get himself entrenched for another term as well as make/change rules and guidelines to give the Govt a handle to choose its own members by keeping out legitimate unions and organisations in the future,” the IJU said.

Calling the chairman’s action “undemocratic and illegitimate”, the IJU said that the moves “smack of a secret agenda of the I&B Ministry to have a pliable Press Council, wherein the riling Govt is not held accountable for its actions, both directly and indirectly, which are threatening & gravely impacting the independence & freedom of the press”.

The Central Press Accreditation Committee (CPAC) has been reconstituted without the representatives of organisations of working journalists, editors of the news media, “in clear violation of stipulated guidelines and amounts to veiled censorship,” the IJU said.

It said that I&B Ministry in March appointed a committee consisting of “a few hand-picked journalists”.

The largest body of Indian journalists said that the I&B Ministry’s decision “to appoint a committee consisting largely of government officials and a few organisations to recommend regulatory framework for online media, without prior and meaningful consultation with all the stake holders”.

The IJU also slammed the Govt for reconstituting the Journalists Welfare Committee with only handpicked members and demanded its reconstitution with representatives of working journalists and editors’ organizations and thee PCI chairman calls a special meeting and that new guidelines drafted to change the character & independence of the PCI be quashed forthwith and that all stake holders be invited to nominate their members to the CPAC.

The Working Journalists and other Newspaper Employees (Miscellaneous) Provisions Act should be amended to bring journalists working in electronic and internet media within the ambit of the definition of the working journalists, the IJU reasoned.

It called for urgent steps to include electronic and digital media in the WJA and also within the jurisdiction of the PCI by replacing it with Media Council of India and amend the relevant laws.

Govt curtailing media freedom: IJU

The IJU while taking note of attacks on freedom of the media said that Govt pressurizing media organisations by denying them advertisements “to conform to the diktats of ruling dispensations” not only weakens the foundations of democracy but also violates the freedom of expression guaranteed under the Constitution. The fundamental duty of the independent media and journalists is talk to power and call those in power to account”.

“Combination of forces, those in power and weak and greedy managements are undermining the freedom of the press, independent journalism and the people’s right to know,” it rued and flayed the “cease and desist” notice served by Anil Ambani led Reliance on some newspapers to block the exposure of shortcomings in Rafale fighter aircraft deal and demands that the company should withdraw this notice immediately and unconditionally.

The IJU also called for implementation of the Majithia Wage Board (MWB) constituted in May 2007 and constitution of a new board.

The MWB submitted its recommendations in 2010, the GoI accepted it in 2011 and the Supreme Court ruled in favour of employees and directed managements to implement it in totality in February 2014, which have not been fully implemented.

The IJU welcomed decision of Assam, Tripura, and Haryana Govts to enhance pension for retired journalists to Rs 10,000 and the decision of Odisha Govt to introduce medical coverage of Rs five lakh for working journalists and their families, but criticised those states which are yet to act in that direction. It urged the GoI to introduce Working Journalists Pension Scheme across the country, bring all working journalists, irrespective of their income, under the purview of health insurance scheme announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Independence Day.

It also demanded that journalists should be exempted from highway toll tax and parking fees at various locations, including airports.

“Journalists have to park their vehicles many times every day for performing their duties and have to pay heavy parking fees daily. Since journalists are serving the society with their relentless efforts to disseminate  information, they should be exempted from all kinds of parking fees,” it added.

Related posts