Beyond the Horizon
By Pradep Kumar
Democracy is a ‘mathematical game’ in which ‘might’ (numbers) has always been proved right. But Arunachal Pradesh, which graduated to parliamentary democracy on 15.08.1975 with conversion of Pradesh Council into Provincial Legislative Assembly, is unique in political map of India.
First general election to 30-member assembly (2 reserved for ST) of union territory was conducted on 25.02.78. There were total 86 candidates. [29 Janta Party (JP), 21 People’s Party of Arunachal, 1 INC (Tasso Grayu) and 35 independents] – maximum six from Ziro while one each from Dirang-Kalaktang (Prem Khandu Thungon) and Niasua-Kanubari (Noksong Boham) and both were elected unopposed. Two females (Nyari Welly and Omem Deori) were in fray but were defeated.
Members of same families (even brothers) or clans had fought against each other from different parties, the most peculiar situation. But, JP had won 17 seats, PPA 8 and 5 independents.
Thungon-led JP Govt was sworn in on 14. 03.1978 with Gegong Apang, Tadar Tang, Soben Tayeng, Nokme Namati as ministers. Three members were nominated by the governor including Sibo Kai. The first assembly session was held in Itanagar on 21.03.1978.
I would like to recall that state Nationalist Congress Party president Tadar Taniang during an interviewing in 2005 had admitted that “money and muscle power has eaten into the vitals of Indian democracy to such an extent that money alone elects leaders”. Claiming that poll expenditure in Arunachal was highest in the country and lowest in Mizoram where Young Mizo Association and Church Associations have prohibited wasteful expenditure.
Taniang had hinted that the actual expenditure in Parliament and assembly polls in Arunachal go up to Rs. three crore and Rs. 50 lakh respectively. Then APCC spokesman Habung Payeng had estimated it to Rs one crore and Rs 50 lakh, the then state BJP president Kangir Jamoh put it at Rs. one crore and Rs. 25 lakh against the prevailing Election Commission of India limit of Rs. 25 lakh and Rs. 10 lakh respectively.
Though Indian politics has passed many a trial and tribulations since the Constitution in January 1950 gave democracy as gift to the people of this country, the naked use of money and muscle power has polluted the body polity to its core. And many devoid of ethics and principles join it not to serve the masses but to serve their vested interest alone. Massive rigging and both capturing have raised many a questions about the very election process, the bedrock of Indian democracy. Thus, I had written “Electoral System Requires Change” advocating drastic electoral reforms on 31.12.1989.
Cleansing the politics from the menace of money and muscle power to facilitate elector to exercise their franchise in a free and fair manner has been debated for long but without any tangible outcome. The reality of the polluting electoral system had dawned on the present Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government and the cabinet had approved a Rs. 1,200 crore plan for non-cash state funding of polls.
Accepting the suggestions of reforms by Indrajit Gupta panel, the plan had envisaged making a provision in Union Budget to help parties with publicity materials, microphones, telephones, petrol and other poll-related expenses. This aimed at helping politicians overcome dependence on non-transparent funding sources.
The astronomical poll expenses prompt the politicians to resort to unethical practices to win election, which later force them to commit crimes even without batting an eyelid. Why to talk about the poll expenses in other parts of the country, when there was no dearth of example of ‘limit-crossing’ expenditure in Arunachal Pradesh!
‘Limit’ a mockery as money buys the votes, an opinion poll, published by me on 31.10.2003, had cleared the doubts about high expenditure in election. Moreover, 11 MPs expelled from the Parliament in “cash-for-query” scam for allegedly taking bribes for raising questions in the house had exposed the rot in the system and shacked the conscience of the nation. The proposed reform then, if introduced, may not bring a sweeping change, but would be an appreciable attempt.
But regrettably, ‘vote-for-cash’ has seemingly turned into termites, which work divided into male and female “workers” and “soldiers”. Or else, democracy would not have been redeemed into such a low level institution.
That was high former Secretary-General of Lok Sabha Dr. Subhash C. Kashyap and expert on Constitution, in an exclusive interview at Naharlagun on 20.12.13, in his candid reply, had said, “The representative legitimacy of the representatives of this democracy is in doubt. Democracy is facing many challenges; the worst is nothing could be more tragic than the masses losing faith in their representatives. There is of course a way out for the democracy to reinvent itself to win the confidence of the masses. The need of the hour is fundamental systemic changes, not from democratic form to presidential form, but to regain the faith to make the masses the real masters,”
“The British parliamentary system has 12 main characteristics and none is applied to Indian democracy. The first fallacy is that the vulnerable founding fathers of our system accepted it and it continues till date. This means we defied and defaced the western concept of democracy. We don’t have a sovereign democratic republic in real sense. The rulers still are masters and ruled are subjects, where as in a sovereign democratic republic, the people are real masters,” he had said without mincing any words.
However, Arunachal Pradesh Catholic Association has launched a campaign with release of pamphlet of “Make Arunachal corruption-free state” by former chief minister Nabam Tuki on 12.08.18, saying “the future of Arunachal Pradesh looks bleak due to rampant corruption”.
Such move against electoral corruption seen for first time in the state would go down state history as many NGOs have pitched support across the state.
Arunachal Pradesh, unlike many states whose legislative assemblies witness walkouts, members rushing into the well or indulging in sharp exchanges leading to pandemonium, hardly sees any. This is because of the simple reason that this predominantly tribal state has a brand of politics unique in the country, which I had highlighted as – Consensus – the hallmark of Arunachal Assembly – on 18.09.08.
Moreover, the National Voters’ Day was celebrated across the country on 25.01.19 with voters taking vow to exercise their adult franchise in free and fair manner and chief secretary Satya Gopal administered the oath at Yupia. But, how the voters will vote to elect their representatives during ensuing Lok Sabha and assembly elections would be known with few months and till then we have to keep our fingers crossed.
