Why AFH, East-West Corridor projects still in limbo? -II

* Bharatmala Project excludes AFH, India’s costliest road project

By Pradeep Kumar

Tussle in GoI over mega highway plans

“A behind the scenes tussle is on within the GoI on ambitious plans to build AFH and EWICH”, The Economics Times had reported on 10.02.16.

“The AFH was even included in initial drafts of PM Modi’s pet ‘Bharatmala’ project. But more than a year since both projects were conceived, the MoRTH has rejected the EWICH and put conditions to build the AFH, citing massive financial commitments on existing projects.

“Documents ET accessed through RTI, interview of Rijiju and a few officials of ministries related to the project reveal that there is an intra-Govt tussle over the issue. Documents show, less than three months after Rijiju took the decision of getting the highways built through the MoRTH, Minister Nitin Gadkari wrote to him asking the project to be given to Ministry of Defence (MoD)/Border Roads Organisation (BRO).

“Gadkari said that his ministry was already building 10,141-km at a cost of Rs 55,000 crore and “land compensation costs have shown a huge increase in recent months”. So it was “difficult for MoRTH to consider any additional length of road”. He suggested Rijiju to look for “alternative source of funding for the proposed infrastructure” and to “assign its responsibility to the MoD/BRO involved in developing border infrastructure.”

“It is the border link that made the DGMO feel concerned about the project. An early 2015 record of the DGMO’s concern raised with the MoHA said, “The proposal entails construction of roads and tunnels along a fresh alignment in close proximity of 15-40-km of LAC which is not operationally desirable”. The proposal overlaps existing plans, the DGMO said and suggested another alignment for the road and empowered committee on border infrastructure put the onus of land acquisition, green clearances etc on the state Govt. Rijiju told ET both the highways are needed: “Without roads, to talk about infrastructure, is meaningless.

“It is true that funding has become an issue. It’s not very encouraging at present.” Officials said funding issues, “may have also led to the AFH project being taken off the prestigious Bharatmala Project.” However, documents accessed by ET show an August 2015 communication by the PMO to MoRTH seeking to “reexamine the proposal” of Bharatmala Project and “approve project irrespective of cost”. The PMO communication did not specify any project and merely sought inclusion of a “basic list of 7,000-km of roads”. MoRTH, already burdened with past commitments in Arunachal, appears to have chosen not to include any fresh projects in Bharatmala.

“Rijiju is still optimistic about the projects: “I wrote back to Gadkariji that it is our responsibility to ensure road connectivity and money has to be found. He is very helpful towards the northeast. We will approach NITI Aayog for guidance. We have agreed with the changed alignment of the DGMO” – the report added.

The DoM & MoHA had cleared the AFH with proposed changes, like changing its starting point from Nafra, Lada and Sarli and the files and sent to the Cabinet Secretariat on 22.05.16 for clearance. The MoRTH was to prepare a DPR. The AFH to intersect EWICH and proposed Bangladesh–China–India–Myanmar Forum for Regional Cooperation (BCIM) Economic Corridor.

On 01.06.17, state Deputy Chief Minister Chowna Mein had called on Gadkari in New Delhi to urge him to consider funding of EWIHC and AFH under Bharatmala Project on priority saying that these roads are vital for the economic uplift of the people of Arunachal Pradesh as well as for all weather connectivity to the border areas. Gadkari had agreed to consider funding of EWIHC from Bhairabkhund to Ruksin and Mahadevpur to Kanubari on condition that the state Govt would make land available free from any encumbrances.

Gadkari said that the ministry had already set up a committee under the chairmanship of road development director general and special secretary in February 2017 to examine the cost and suggest innovative materials and technologies to be adopted for the AFH.

On 03.07.18,  DyCM Mein, while reviewing the EWIHC status, had said it would be  part of announcement worth Rs 50,000 crore announced by Gadkari during his visit to the state in January 2017.  The GoAP has given Rs 18 crore for the survey & investigation for package-I (Pasighat to Naharlagun) in last financial year and Rs 22 crore in current fiscal for package-II (Naharlagun to Bhairabkhun) which includes 10% state share to prepare the DPR. The survey & investigation for package-I has been complete while for package-II in progress,” he had added.

Related posts