Arunachal Pradesh: 2nd global Bermuda Triangle?-I

* A scientific study of the flying zone need of the hour

Why not an IAF training centre

after 81 deaths in 14 air crashes?

In all 81 lives – union MoS for defence NVN Somu, chief minister Dorjee Khandu, an Army major general, two IAS officers, 31 IAF pilots, five crew members, 32 defence personnel and 27 others- have been killed so far since 1989 in 14 air crashes – three An-32 aircrafts, 10 helicopters and a Sukhoi SU-30 fighter jet. This, however, calls for an urgent need for a scientific study of state’s most unpredictable flying zone.

Questioning on 14.01.19- Is Indian defence preparedness adequate in 2019?, Col (Dr) P K Vasudeva, has said: “After three decades spent developing its own fighter, India put out a tender for 126 warplanes, which morphed into an order for 36 Rafale aircrafts from Dassault Aviation SA that will start arriving in 2019. Until then, IAF is heavily reliant on Soviet-era MiG-21s that fall from the sky so often to earn the sobriquet “Flying Coffins.”

“Experts suggest India could resolve some issues by appointing a single person in charge like Chief of the Defence Staff which is still not seen light of the day by the Modi Govt,” he observed.

After an AIF’s MI-17, a multi-utility helicopter, blasted into flames midair 5 minutes after take-off from Tawang helipad, killing 12 defence personnel, including 3 pilots on 19.11.11, then Lok Sabha member Takam Sanjoy in an interview to this editor had blamed the defence ministry for not giving due importance to this strategic located Himalayan state. He had demanded an IAF training centre considering the number of air crashes in the state, saying after humiliating defeat in 1962 Chinese aggression it is time to learn the lesson.

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, July 07: IAF An-32 aircraft crash in Arunachal Pradesh on 03.06.19 killing all 13 on board. This third such crash of An-32 is a grim reminder of highest air crashes in this Himalayan state, known earlier as North East Frontier Agency (NEFA).

However, the mysterious flying zone over this hilly state is turning out to be the devil’s triangle, though Kalinga Airlines of famous federal pilot Biju Pattanaik had maintained the lifeline during 1956-57 by flying from Rowriah-based directorate of supply and transport at Jorhat in Assam to drop rations throughout NEFA and at times landing at Anini and Ziro.

The An-32 crashed despite statement of Defence Minister Rajnath Singh in Rajya Sabha on Tuesday that the IAF AN-32 was completely airworthy and such accidents in the country have come down from 1.04 in 1999 to 0.33 currently per 10,000 flying hours. However, while claiming that the accident was unfortunate, while responding to supplementary queries during question hour, he noted that there was “no issue regarding the airworthiness of the aircraft”. He said 13 persons onboard lost their lives in the ill-fated aircraft.

“The average accident rate has reduced from 1.04 per 10,000 flying hours in 1999 to 0.52 in 2004. This has further reduced to 0.46 in next five years and currently the accident rate is 0.33 per 10,000 flying hours,” he added.

Singh said a court of inquiry had been ordered within hours of the incident, and that the reasons for the accident would be ascertained only after the report was submitted and accordingly the same would be shared with the members of the House. Noting that had there been no improvement, the rate of accidents would not have come down; he said the upgrading of aircraft “is a regular process” and that the MIG-29s would also come under it.

As far as planes are concerned, particularly AN-32, so far 52 have been upgraded, but we cannot say that those planes which have not yet been upgraded are not airworthy. It would not be fair to conclude that, he added.

In what has also been called the 2nd Bermuda Triangle of the world, Arunachal Pradesh mountains have the dubious distinction of unpredictable weather within minutes, zero visibility within seconds, sudden gusts of cyclonic winds or a whirlpool in mid-air tossing the helicopter like a kite in a windy sky, leading to a loss of control on many occasions.

Related posts