Probe against Kholie sought

By Staff Reporter

ITANAGAR, July 31: Accusing Arunachal Rural Road Development Agency (ARRDA) chief executive officer Kapa Kholie of his involvement in a major scam in PMGSY tenders, Young Arunachal Movement (YAM) on Wednesday demanded a CBI inquiry.

YAM general secretary Tana Tamar, addressing media persons at APC here, demanded termination of Kholie, also serving as RWD secretary. He claimed that Kholie along with RWD CEs Taking Welly (WZ) & Kago Tabio (EZ) and SFAO S Bhowmick should be suspended for a free and fair enquiry by the CBI.

Union Ministry of RD (MoRD) had sanctioned 153 roads & 55 bridges in batch-I and 115 roads & 35 bridges in batch-II during 2018-19 fiscal under regular PMGSY for the state with total cost of Rs. 3882.43 crore, he claimed, adding “Tenders were floated for all 268 roads and 90 bridge projects. but unfortunately works are being awarded violating all CPWD norms, standard bid documents, operation manual guidelines and MoRD advisory under ARRDA head,” he claimed, adding pick-and-choose method was used to deprive genuine firms.

Alleging that Kholie appointed himself as ARRDA CEO and became financial bid evaluation committee (FBEC) chairman  for all PMGSY tender works, Tamar questioned: “How can an officer working for the GoAPappoint himself as CEO and later FBEC Chairman?” This clearly indicated his involvement in multi-crore scams, he charged.

YAM vice-chairman Tana Sona Tara claimed that Kholie as FBEC chairman wrongly interpreted provisions of CPWD manual clause 20.4.3 intentionally and made recommendations for tenders by pick-and-choose method instead of going by merit.

“Two firms – Dagmo Riba and PG Construction & Consultancy – were bidders for constructing Bui to Bulo road. The former was the lowest bidder, but work was awarded to the latter,” Tara claimed, adding that same was the case with construction of PMGSY road project from Yazali-Sakiang road from 40 -m point to Pilla. “Despite Ragia Ku Enterprise being lowest bidder, the work was awarded to Tamchi Kusuk,” he added.

Kholie, in his minutes of financial bid opening, had said that the work was awarded to Tamchi Kusuk because of justified amount, but working out of the justified amount, in this case, was against the CPWD manual provisions, Tara said.

“There is no need for preparing a justification statement if the lowest tender is less than the estimated cost of the tender. The whole procedure of financial bid evaluation itself is wrong and has been done with malafide intention to favour a firm by doing injustice to legitimate lower bidder,” Tara claimed.

He also questioned completion of all evaluation, justification and minutes on a single day. “35 financial bids on March 4; 26 financial bids on March 6 and 47 financial bids on March 7 were completed. Work that takes more than a week to complete was completed in a single day on three occasions,” he claimed, and wondered how the department could do this?

Kholie failed to provide detailed information of all 358 PMGSY projects in response to an RTI query but only provided information on 197 projects, the YAM said, adding Kholie later said that he would not comment on allegations as the matter is in the high court. The financial evaluation was done by a committee and the work was awarded as per the recommendation of the rate analysis team, he said.

Related posts