Modi & BJP befooled people of India: Jathmalini

Demonitisation vis-à-vis RBI move

The Economic Survey for 2016-17 estimated the loss in economic output arising from demonetisation to have been anything between a quarter of a percentage point to one percentage point of lost growth. GDP growth rate slowed from 8% in 2015-16 to 7.1% in 2016-17 to 6.7% in 2017-18. Output loss due to demonetisation is a little over Rs 1 lakh crore, The Economic Times had reported on 02.09.18. Thus, the RBI on 27.08.19 had approved transfer of record Rs 1.76 lakh crore dividend and surplus reserves to the GoI, boosting PM Modi-led regime’s prospect to stimulate slowing economy without widening fiscal deficit. The Opposition Congress criticised the Govt for “stealing from the RBI”, saying that the Govt was “clueless about how to solve their self-created economic disaster”. Alas… Had Jathmalini been alive his expert comment would have been more educative.

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

Eminent jurist and former Union Law Minister Ram Jethmalini who practiced law for 50 years, said to be India’s highest-paid lawyer, in an interview with Scroll.in on 31.12.15, had explained why he was representing Arvind Kejriwal (Delhi CM) for Re 1 in defamation cases filed against him by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley.

Jethmalani spoke of Jaitley’s role in removing him as Law Minister under National Democratic Alliance government of Atal Behari Vajpayee, his disappointment with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, how he was persuaded to appear for LK Advani in Hawala case and Rs 13 lakh he had paid to get an article against Jaitley published in a newspaper. Excerpts:

“Jaitley is supposed to have a lot of clout. Where does his clout come from?

Well, he certainly controls the media, which is not so much a reflection on Jaitley as much as it is on the media itself, on the media bosses. You see, I hardly appear for TV interviews. I have told them that their bosses will not permit them to carry any of the things I say.

“In April [this year], I wrote a very strong article against Jaitley. In the article I asked him some questions and sought his replies. For five years till then, I used to write my weekly piece for the Sunday Guardian. I would send my piece on Friday, they would look at it on Saturday, and it would appear Sunday morning.

When I opened the newspaper on Sunday morning, I found my article (the one asking questions) had been blanked out. There was an advertisement inserted in the slot where the article should have been. I was the chairman of the Board (of the Sunday Guardian) at that time. I resigned that day. Of course, I put the piece on my twitter and Facebook accounts.

But what I also did was to call the Indian Express. I told the Express that I wanted them to publish my article and that they could do so as a paid advertisement. I said I would pay for it. Do you know I was charged Rs 13 lakh for it?

Rs 13 lakh for the piece! Yes, but the article did appear in full [as an advertisement]. The article was on why the government wasn’t doing anything to bring back black money from abroad.This is shocking. (Laughs) I don’t know whether it went into the pockets of the Indian Express or to their agents. Perhaps the highest amount a writer paid to have his piece published. (Laughs) Ya, ya, I paid for it.

The Finance Minister wouldn’t have liked that, would he?

Jaitley knows he has no answer. If he has an honest answer to give, he should. Why is he in the public life? To give answers.

When I was driving to your place, a friend who knew I was to interview you wanted me to find out whether it was indeed true, as is the talk in the legal fraternity that Jaitley used to carry your coat in his younger days.(Silent for a few seconds) No doubt about it.

“Throughout the 2014 election campaign, Prime Minister Narendra Modi made a very strong and appealing argument against black money. There is a report of a task force of BJP itself that $ 1,500 billion, or Rs 90 lakh crore, are stashed abroad. Now, Germany is a richer country than us. I don’t believe people in Germany are more corrupt than Indians, yet they paid $475 million to an employee of the Liechtenstein Bank and got 1,400 names. The Swiss Bankers Association declared that the majority of the names were of Indians. The German Govt officially declared that it was willing to share the names with any friendly Govt, without cost, without condition. I want to know whether the then Govt was prepared to end corruption and…

That was under the United Progressive Alliance government, right?

Yes, the UPA Govt did nothing, which was the reason why the people threw them out. But what were the Opposition leaders doing? Were they not interested? Even after coming to power, they haven’t gone to Germans asking for the names, even though Modi visited Germany and German chancellor came here. The very fact that they did not ask for the names is an almost conclusive evidence that they know the names and they don’t want them to be made public. It also means both are on the list.

Both meaning leaders from the Congress and the BJP? [Laughs] On top of it, after having won the election on major plank of the UPA corruption, the party president [Amit Shah], who has been appointed by Modi, makes a public statement that all this talk of corruption, of getting back the black money from abroad, was an election jumla, a joke. It amounts to them accepting that they cheated the people. It is a confession to the grand larceny on the people of this country, that is, the BJP stole the votes of the people by making false representations.

Mr Modi doesn’t say anything. Finance Minister Arun Jaitley doesn’t say anything. What does it show?  It shows that all three – Modi, Jaitley, Shah – are in conspiracy. That is why from being the greatest supporter of Modi I have now turned into his greatest critic.

And that is because you feel he has betrayed the people? I went to Bihar. Nitish Kumar invited me to campaign for him. I told him I didn’t have enough time to go around canvassing. But I asked Nitish to organise two meetings. I also told him, “Believe you me, I will not speak for more than 20 minutes.”

So I addressed two meetings in Bihar. I told the audience that it needed to support Nitish and Lalu, that the NDA had betrayed the people and did not deserve their support. But I also told them that I had come to them for a different reason. I said I had come to seek their forgiveness. I said that this was because I am an educated person who has 75 years of experience as a criminal lawyer, and how it was that Modi made a fool of me. I said that even though I had been expelled from the BJP, I worked for him during the 2014 election campaign.

So did Modi or BJP reach out to you to campaign for him? Let me complete the story. I used to write a weekly column for the Sunday Guardian. You should read the piece I wrote immediately after the 2014 election results were announced. “Mr Modi, congratulations on your spectacular success and I am pleased I made a small contribution to your success. But I am writing this only to tell you that as far as I am concerned, I am in the departure lounge of God’s airport. I want nothing from you; nothing means nothing. Now fulfil your promises to people.”

Do you know Modi did not have the courtesy to pick up the phone to thank me even once? What does it show? To me, it shows he is non-human, to say the least. Till today, the man hasn’t spoken to me.

So I told the people of Bihar that I had come to seek their forgiveness, that even I, who is supposed to be a great criminal lawyer of this country, had been swindled.

This went viral. Nitish used this in every speech of his. See, what happened to Modi’s campaign in Bihar? He campaigned intensively, yet suffered the most spectacular defeat of his life. Modi doesn’t realise it.

Why do you think he doesn’t realise it?  Have you met Modi? He used to come here [Jethmalani’s home.] During the 2014 campaign? Yes, and before it too. On my birthday in September 2013, both Modi and Advani were present when I tried to bring some sort of understanding between them. Modi has come to my residence more than once. I got lawyers from all political parties to participate in his campaign. Between 15,000-20,000 lawyers assembled in Talkatora stadium, from every part of the country.

Nothing could be worked out between Advani and Modi? Nothing. On the contrary, Modi has disabled all of them. (Laughs.) Had Jaitley been in touch with you? What do you think of him? What has Jaitley done? I can’t remember a big case in which he has appeared, but he perhaps has a bank balance ten times of mine. You can draw your inferences.

Ever since you went public with your decision to represent Kejriwal, the media has been furiously speculating that you have done this because it was Jaitley who was responsible for your removal as law minister under the NDA Govt of Atal Behari Vajpayee. Is this true?

Well, he certainly misguided Vajpayee. At that time, the Congress-led Govt was in Maharashtra. Bal Thackeray had done something seven years ago – I forget what it was precisely – and the Maharashtra Govt wanted to arrest him. He was a BJP ally. So Prime Minister Vajpayee called me and said, “Ram, he is our ally and you have to defend him.”

I told Vajpayee, “He is a friend. You don’t worry, nothing will happen.” I was the law minister then and I made a strong public statement defending Thackeray.

By some curious incident, Chief Justice [Adarsh Sein] Anand made an attack on me. He said, “What did the Law Minister mean by issuing statements to defend Thackeray?” These statements were made in the presence of [former Attorney General] Soli Sorabjee and Arun Jaitley. Once Chief Justice Anand made the statement, I called the press and asked them to convey to the Chief Justice that I knew my job and I certainly knew more law than the Chief Justice did. In the first place, it was wrong of him to make that statement in my absence. Second, the statement was absolutely scandalous and unworthy of Chief Justice.

I believe Sorabjee and Jaitley went to Vajpayee and told him the Supreme Court had become the enemy of the Govt. They said they [NDA] would be in great trouble with the Supreme Court until I was dropped. Vajpayee didn’t have the courage to call me up. So he asked poor Jaswant Singh to do the job.

I remember I was travelling by car from Mumbai to Pune. Jaswant called. So I remarked, “Jaswant, what calls for this urgent call to me?” He said that the PM wanted me to resign. I didn’t bat an eyelid. I said, “Jaswant, tell the PM he will get my resignation letter from the nearest fax machine that I can get on the Bombay-Pune road.” (Laughs.) I did it.

Related posts