CDCN holds open debate on APPSC fiasco | Debaters unanimous on fresh recruitment

By Talo Yaku

ITANAGAR, Jan 21: “The APPSC should conduct fresh recruitment soon” – was unanimous conclusion of a deliberation on the most controversial issue involving panelists and young victims of 2017 APSC Combined Competitive Examination (CCE) at Dorjee Khandu Convention Hall Amphitheater  here on Tuesday.

Anchor Congneithem Lhouvum aka Them of organizer Capital Digital Communication Network (CDCN), initiating the hour-long debate said that even almost three year after the APPSC is yet to declare result of almost three-year old CCE evoking criticism from all sections of the society. Though the GoAP constituted RGU vice chancellor-led panel had reported re-conduct and the Gauhati High Court in its verdict had given the same opinion, but AAPSC moved double bench with a review petition whose verdict is scheduled on January 3 next. Who should be blamed for the doldrums – the APPSC, the GoAP for causing untold suffering to the examinees for last three years?

Senior journalist Pradeep Kumar as a panelist said the APPSC has been embroiled in controversy since inception in 1988 with obnoxious distinctions. It cannot be free from blemish as it took longest period to announce results of first exams held in 2006; its 1991, 1993, 1999, 2003 and 2006 exams were erratic without any calendar; called assistant director or such low ranking officers as examiners to interview engineers & doctors and called such people in  last minute to check answer scripts.

“My suggestion to toe example of then higher & technical education director Dr Joram Begi for declaring results of 5,000 aspirants of joint entrance examination in record 24 hours and bring then UPSC sectary Taru Talo on deputy to streamline the APPSC went in vain as those who mattered were not interested in reforms. All leaders including governor call for attitudinal change which should being from the top to yield the desired result, he reasoned. When there is no dearth of capable & experienced retired officers, why APPSC members are imported from outside, he wondered, adding nothing could be expected from this hollowed institution.

Next panelist IAF wing commander (Retd) Gyati Kago pitched in support, saying mistakes in 15 optional papers and such repeated mistakes indicated deliberate attitude. But, the APPSC should have conducted fresh recruitment honouring HC verdict instead of challenging it. It repeatedly changed question setting agency (QSA) thrice, but its performance, like copy-pasting of Pakistan Service Commission, has made the state a mockery. Thus, being recruitment fountain head of the state should undergo total reform, he advocated.

Stressing on confidentiality, Arunachal Civil Society president Patey Tayum said leakage of question papers & copy-paste proved total violation of its recruitment rules & guidelines and lack of monitoring system by the GoAP. Though then APPSC chairman had promised him & RGU’s Dr Nani Bath to seek compensation form QSA then but that agency should be made public now and question setters should be identified for them to quit, he said and called for transparency in APPSC actions in greater state welfare.

Terming lapses serious, APPSU debate & symposium secretary Marli Kamki said that the APPSC had lost faith of the masses by challenging HC verdict instead of re-conducting fresh exam. When Chief Minister Pema Khandu in Assembly recently admitted shortage of officers, the APPSC should hold test immediately.

(CM Khandu during the zero hour discussion on January 9 had said the GoAP has been facing shortage of 132 circle COs against 220 sanctioned posts, while 61 CO posts help up in court-APPSC litigation.)

Natung Jamoh, Mesap Lapung, Resto Loriak and Geli Roming, speaking on behalf of 221 victims, were univocal that fresh recruitment including them should be conducted.

Advocating total revamping, Jamoh suggested 20% regional questions. When the CM in Assembly said that DDO authority has been delegated to even district animal husbandry officer due to shortage officers, why delay in recruitment?

Enlisting reasons for moving the HC, Lapung said many questions were out of syllabus, mistake in many questions indicating preparation by officers, sitting arrangement  vulnerable to copying and results were announced the day the APPSC promised to do so after rectification.

Loriak suggested year-long examination calendar, time gap after every exam for preparation, marking by ink not pencil, award sheet be given along with answer sheet when sought by examinees, APPSC rules & regulations made public, feed-back system introduced.

The GoAP had pressurized the APPSC to hold exams taken plea of ensuing Assembly polls. But election is a continuing process and PRI polls are due but still the GoAP should insist on fresh recruitment.

All panelists responded to various questions, before Kumar & Kago expressed confidence that the next HC verdict would do justice to the youths while pleading to “make a mountain out of a molehill”, Kamki urged the APPSC & CM: Kaal Kare So Aaj Kar, Aaj Kare So Ub,Pal Mein Pralaya Hoyegi, Bahuri Karoge Kub (Tomorrows work do today, today’s work now, if the moment is lost, the work be done how).

Them concluded lauding fruitful deliberation and hoped the verdict would bring a new dawn in 2020 by delivering justice.

While state’s first Hindi channel head Mintu Tamuli coordinated assisted by Yanu Rumi, Tenzing Kee, cameramen Om Bahadur & Koj Hassang when CMD Toko Tacho watched curiously.

Related posts