- Analysis and suggestions
By Robin Hibu
Background: Repeated goof-ups by offices of public service commission (PSC) of NE states in conducting prestigious exams have resulted in repeated stirs, litigations and arrest of high-ranking PSC officials in a neighboring state recently.
The alleged ‘fiascos’ have caused massive uproar in media, social media, and even there are instances of arson and attacks on PSC members (when I was Papum Pare SP).
Hundreds of aspirants have expressed deep anguish and the PSC image has been tarnished. However, it seems to me that scrambling, knee-jerk reactions is a worrisome trend. After all, the constitutional objective of such PSC is to fearlessly select most eligible brains of the time for high-ranking public offices, persons who would spend their lives in public services with honesty being the permanent machinery to ensure progress of the society.
We cannot afford to tinker with this cardinal pillar stone of our society. History is witness that civilizations like the Roman, the Greece, the Maurya and the British, who ruled for centuries, had robust, transparent, egalitarian systems for recruiting the best and the most intelligent citizens as permanent officials to govern. The day the systems were tinkered with by unscrupulous elements at the helms of affairs, disastrous results ensued leading to collapse of mighty civilizations due to chicanery, favouritism and mediocrity at the cost of merit.
Experiences: Apart from my routine police job, I was a member of the viva voce board of Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission thrice, and I conducted a special recruitment of candidates from eight NE states for Delhi Police within a month, right from advertisement to declaration of results, in all eight state capitals, creating a record.
‘Fault lines’: Too many unbelievably unfair means are adopted during examinations which have grey areas where fissures for an unequal competitive milieu emerge. These ‘fault lines’, as perceived by the candidates, are:
1) Unprofessional approach and lack of foolproof setting of questions papers; lackadaisical checking of answer papers; and scope for awarding marks at whims and fancies due to lack of straight-jacketed guidelines or double-checking of answers by other subject experts to find imbalances and discrepancies.
2) Leakage of questions papers before examinations.
3) Disparity in awarding marks. Arts students can never get 100% whereas science students can easily score 100%. Even during the time of my IPS training along with IAS and IFS trainees, most trainees were from science background.
4) Unfair means of cheating, such as using tiny Bluetooth devices connected to persons outside the examination halls, impersonating for someone in the exams, copying in the exam halls or in the bathrooms, etc.
5) Emergence of middlemen (especially for subordinate jobs) who somehow try to woo gullible candidates, promising selection in lieu of cash or in connivance with PSC staffers.
6) Lack of holistic planning of job recruitment. Sometimes hundreds of jobs are advertised in a particular year and then there is no recruitment for a few years, thereby depriving the brightest youths during the no-recruitment years. Many bright Arunachalee students have confided in me personally of this situation which has resulted in candidates becoming overage or being unable to compete with fresh graduates. Sometimes yearly recruitment is conducted at random for various reasons, depriving many bright youths of joining elite state services.
7) Too many marks allotted for interview. Such huge marking for the interview round can topple the ranks and even eliminate the toppers in written exams.
8) Untrained personnel manning supposedly hallowed PSCs, right from top to the bottom of the hierarchy. Lack of specific training for the specialized jobs adds to the problem.
9) Lack of latest know-how and technology to ensure foolproof confidentiality and to effectively hinder leakages. The personnel manning these PSCs should be put under hawkish supervision and surveillance.
10) Outsourcing state departments concerned to conduct recruitment for their vacancies or allowing them to do so is another bottomless black hole where department officials are virtually given a free hand. No wonder that recently, one department selected all its lower subordinate officials from a particular sub-clan from a particular village. The officer who was in charge of the recruitment was from that particular tribe.
11) Lack of interactive social media forum for FAQs (frequently asked questions or queries) to allay doubts about the process, syllabus application, results, etc.
12) Lack of orientation and induction training for members, staff and officials of state PSCs.
13) Lack of background or proven experience of PSC members and staff matters the most. Rigorous scrutiny is sine qua non for manning the hallowed institution.
14) No feedback/stock-taking after every exam to conduct future exams better.
15) Lack of an annual calendar for recruitment by the PSC to ensure advance planning for logistics, secrecy, technology, foolproof papers, etc.
16) Unavailability of IT-based personnel to devise or delve into latest know-how for advance planning, precision execution and data bank generation-cum-storage in secure domains with latest impregnable anti-virus apps.
17) Lack of serious pruning and orientation of PSC members and staff for entire gamut of recruitment. (to be continued)
