GoAP for party-based panchayat polls

  • CM advocating no party elections: Tayeng

No-party poll would lead to

loss of workers’ faith: Ojing

“There were three friends Dhan, Gyan and Viswas, who questioned about their next meeting. Dhan said anywhere, Gyan said in library, dictionary and TV, but Biswas said never once gone. He justified no to non-party-based election that would amount to irrecoverable loss of party workers’ faith”.

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, Mar 02: The first day of nine-day Budget session of state Legislative Assembly saw lengthy threadbare deliberations on a short duration discussion moved by senior leader Ninong Ering (INC) on ‘No party system for panchayat election’ who argued that administration has gone down to grassroots level as advocated by first prime minister Pt Jawaharlal Nehru.

Responding to opinions and observation of many members on behalf of the state Govt, Panchayat Minister Bamang Felix said that the Congress had amended for party-based election which cannot be changed at this juncture for which “We will go for party-based elections on “as is where is basis”.

Thanking Ering for highlighting chronological evolution of panchayat, he said that though panchayat election was due since a year ago, but panchayat election to three terms was conducted by violating constitutional provision, which says: state having less than 20 lakh population should not have Anchal Samity, for which it was abolished by present Govt.

Moreover, Arunachal Press Club had conducted a symposium on 05.12.19 on ‘whether PRI election should be party-based or not?’, key note speaker George Mathew had said: “If political parties are there then why not contest PRI polls on party line. It cannot be effective without party line being third level democratic system”.

“Advocating that panchayat should be used as development toll not political one and quoting Lombo Tayeng who had said that ‘no party system’ prevailed originally”, he said that autonomous State Election Commission (SEC) has been conducting PRI election since 2016. Thus, GoAP is fully prepared after delimitation (8336 gram panchayats, 2215 gram chairpersons, 25 zill parishads and 245 ZPMs), e-roll completion and intimated the SEC to conduct election.

Ering had also quoted Gandhiji as advocating self governance by the people (of the people, for the people) while J P Narayan and Bhudan movement pioneer Vinoba Bhabe had said that ideas should come from village level.  While Ashok Mehata Committee in 1977 called for democratic decentralization, he also quoted comments of VK V Rao, Rajiv Gandhi and LMV Singvi. The Daying Ering Committee in 1962 recommended four-tier system that had paved the way for Agency council, zilla parisahd, anchal samity and gram panchayat in 1965 and  implemented in 1967. The state Govt effected six amendments and gave 1/3rd reservation to women was in 2017, he recalled.

Supporting his view for the multi-dimensional institution, he quoted a GoI attitudinal survey in which 800 people were against party-based election while only 200 favoued it. Pointing out violence was seen in West Bengal and even in the state during last Assembly polls; he said that non-party-based election would check money and muscle power toeing with CM Khandu’s campaign against corruption.

Moreover, the cream of the society will be missing from the system which is a loss as the villagers know who is a good person to suit them as a gram panchyat leader. Can anyone challenge bout no corruption in zilla parishad level? Or else, good people could also contest without any party funding, he added.

The candidate should have an identity or tag in any election, Nyato Rigiya (BJP) said, adding there are more disadvantages in ‘no party system election’. As election is a process to showcase strength, party-based election has to be funded. It is not the only way to check corruption the way the CM has launched movement and ‘Team Arunachal’ would achieve it, he said with conviction, adding “Election expenditure can be checked by the party in a country having multi-party system. Has Congress any apprehension after ruling the country for 70 years? Let it show its strength,” he said.

“I am a simple BJP worker and would like all workers to be from grassroots level as PM Modi before 2014 election had advocated ‘Congress mukt Bharat’. Make your party stronger through panchayat. We have never seen no-party election in panchayat since its inception for which I disagree about ‘no party-based election’,” Rigiya added.

Favouring party-based election, Ojin Tasing said that any election is a festival for the BJP. PM Modi and CM Khandu schemes would be made known to the people through party workers; he said none likes ‘ghar ki vedi lanka dhaye’. Describing a story he said that there were three friends Dhan, Gyan and Viswas, who questioned about their next meeting. Dhan said anywhere, Gyan said in library, dictionary and TV, but Biswas said never once gone. He justified no to non-party-based election that would amount to irrecoverable loss of party workers’ faith.

Sona interrupted to say that there is an App in computer to send a message to him to take part in the discussion.

Rode Bui said he is against non-party election as many panchayat schemes would be supervised by the PRI Leaders for greater welfare of the society. No party leaders if don’t work cannot be questioned, he said.

Terming Constitution of India as ambiguous about party system in panchayat, Kento Rina (BJP) quoted his workers as saying: They are working on party line which will protect their future. No-party poll may lead to undue advantages for which he favoured party-based election.

Quoting 1992 Panchayat Amendment Act which has no provision for party-based election, Talem Taboh (JD-U) asked members to rise above party line as party-based poll would have many advantages – less expenditure and facilitate cordial relations to justify ‘Hamara Arunachal’.  Why not contest on party line, he asked?

“Though we all are under ‘Team Arunachal’, I suggest no party election to check expenditure,” Dorjee Wangdi Kharma (JD-U) said while Taniya Soki (BJP) said no party election would give rise to indiscipline with aya ram, gaya ram spirit and favoured party line for lotus to bloom everywhere.

Saying that when any election seeks mandate of the people with procedure to file nomination and formation of Govt by the people and for the people, Lokam Tasar argued it has to be party-based or else the word ‘election’ should be removed and criteria changed.

“MLAs are policy makers but policies are implemented in village level and I wish party leaders in panchayat level for effective implementation. While the BJP runs without fund, but non-party election would also involve expenditure like in all students’ union elections. Arunachal has the largest number of NGOs in the world”, he said.

The Govt would incur expenditure in all forms but party-based election would be disciplined and less expensive, Balo Raja (BJP) opined.

Appreciating Ering for his presentation, Phosum Khimhun (BJP) supported party system as 73rd and 74th Amendments brought changes for five-year term and Congress had approved party-based election in the state during Mukut Mithi’s leadership. It should be party-based election to meet aspirations of BJP workers, he said.

Terming Daying Ering as panchayat system pioneer, Tarin Dakpe (NPP) said that Gandhian philosophy was grassroots level democracy, which was introduced in NEFA in 1967-68, he said recollecting political evolution of the state. The PRI ensures village level governance for which it should be fought without party which would also prevent money culture and get genuine candidates not rich ones. All 29 subjects are yet to be devolved to the PRI which calls for genuine leaders to achieve real development, he argued.

Thanpho Wangnaw (BJP), former Longding panchayat vice president, also supported party-based election along with Gokar Basar (NPP).

Tayeng (INC) urged members to support no party election in tune with the thought of present CM who has been advocating in this regard.

The INC ruled India for 70 years by suppressing the people, Much Mithi (NPP) said and questioned if the BJP was intending the same through party-based election. Last state Assembly election witnessed huge expenditure and violence, he said to justify his stand. What Mukut Mithi (his father) had done was need of that time, he said, adding Noble laureate Amarya Sen once had said “depriving poor from development is the greatest curse for them”.

Speaking against party-based election, Wanglin Lowangdon again recalled that Tirap district was not in favour of panchayat but to strengthen village councils. As the CM has declared in various forums to choose party-less election for electing genuine leaders, we should go for party-less polls, he added.

Related posts