Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
Though Indo-China stand-off in Ladkah has been hogging the headlines in media; few intellectuals of the state have raised questions on confusion created over the issue by Prime Minister Narendra Modi by contradicting statement of Chief of Army Staff General MM Naravane.
Few of them, including a lawyer practicing in Supreme Court and Gauhati High Court, quoted their self-explanatory statements and wondered at total contradiction.
“The Chinese neither entered our territory nor has any post been taken over by them, underscored Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the all-party meet to discuss the border incident along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in eastern Ladakh where 20 Indian soldiers died on the line of duty in brutal hand-to-hand combat with People’s Liberation Army (PLA).
“Neither have they intruded into our border, nor has any post been taken over by them (China). Twenty of our jawans were martyred, but those who dared Bharat Mata, they were taught a lesson,” said PM Modi. No one can take even an “inch of the land”, he said underlining India’s might,” as reported by Hindusthan Times on June 19.
But Sushanta Singh in his The Indian Express report – Chinese intrusions at 3 places in Ladakh, Army Chief takes stock –
With tensions mounting along the LAC following the Pangong Tso clash and detection of Chinese intrusions at three places in Galwan river area, Army chief General MM Naravane landed at the XIV Corps headquarters in Leh on May 21 to review the situation in eastern Ladakh.
His visit came a day after the Ministry of External Affairs hit back at Beijing over the LAC developments, saying “it is the Chinese side that has recently undertaken activity hindering India’s normal patrolling patterns” and “we are deeply committed to ensuring India’s sovereignty and security”.
Indian and Chinese troops came to blows on the banks of the Pangong Tso, a lake which is partly under Indian control, on the night of May 5-6. Chinese intrusions, sources said, have been detected at three places in the Galwan area, well inside Indian Territory.
There have been five meetings between local military commanders of the two sides so far, but the situation along nearly 80-km of frontage remains unresolved. Sources said Chinese soldiers have crossed the LAC at three places — at Hot Springs and in two locations 15-20 km to the north-west, Patrolling Point 14 (PP-14) and PP-15.
At each of these places, around 800-1000 Chinese soldiers have crossed over to the Indian side of the LAC, sources said, at distances of around 2-3 km. Tents have been pitched by the Chinese soldiers in the area, along with a fleet of heavy vehicles and monitoring equipment. Chinese helicopter movement close to the LAC has also been monitored by the Indian side.
Sources said Indian soldiers in equal numbers have been deployed in the area, separated by a distance of 300-500 metres from the Chinese – technically, the two sides are not in a faceoff.
Movement of additional troops as part of “creation of reserves” and “contingency planning” have also been initiated by the Army, sources said.
Distance is being maintained by the Indian side to avoid fracas like the one on the night of May 5-6 at Pangong Tso, which led to injuries on both sides, sources said, adding that this should avert any “inadvertent escalation”.
The motives for Chinese incursions into Indian Territory are still not clear. One view among official circles is that it is triggered by local factors such as creation of more infrastructures by Indians in areas close to the LAC.
Another view links it to a more assertive China which is intruding into a sector like Hot Springs where the perception of the LAC has not been in dispute.
Most officials agree that the situation at the LAC is “unprecedented” in recent memory, with tensions running very high. They also suggest that a solution to the crisis will have to be found soon since “the change in the status quo by the Chinese is not acceptable”.
Official data show there has been a marked increase in the number of Chinese transgressions along the LAC in Ladakh in the western sector.
The first four months of this year, according to official data, witnessed 170 Chinese transgressions, including 130 in Ladakh. There were only 110 such transgressions in Ladakh during the same period in 2019.
But in 2019, the year when Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping met at Bishkek and Mahabalipuram, there were 663 Chinese transgressions, up from 404 in 2018. This included a 75%t spike in the western sector and a 55% rise in the eastern sector.
Nearly three-quarters of the transgressions, data since 2015 show, have taken place in the western sector of the LAC.
“However, China has captured 60 sqkm of Indian land!” – Ajai Shukla, had reported on June 8 last.
Indian troops at Indo-China LAC
In what the army is recognising as a repeat of Pakistan’s 1999 Kargil intrusions, but this time by China in eastern Ladakh, troops of the People’s Liberation Army continue consolidating their defences in the Galwan River and Pangong Lake areas, up to 3-km inside territory that the Indian Army has patrolled and claimed for decades.
Just as the Kargil intrusions allowed Pakistani troops to dominate the Srinagar-Zojila-Kargil-Leh highway and threatened to cut off Ladakh from the north, the Chinese intrusion into the Galwan River Valley allows PLA troops to overlook the strategic Darbuk-Shyok-Daulat Beg Oldi (DSDBO) highway and cut off the army’s lone year-round connection with its isolated ‘Sub-Sector North’ (SSN), at the base of the Karakoram Pass.
PLA soldiers that have established themselves at the mouth of the Galwan River valley at its confluence with the Shyok River are just 1-5-KM from the DSDBO road.
The PLA apparently intends to dominate this road permanently. Even as top Chinese officials declare the issue can be resolved through dialogue, PLA intruders are building bunkers while PLA engineers are connecting their forward troops with China’s formidable road infrastructure on the Line of Actual Control (LAC).
Government sources conservatively estimate that the PLA has captured more than 60 sqkm of Indian-patrolled territory in the last month — equally divided between the northern bank of Pangong Lake and the Galwan River sectors.
Chinese troops now block access to several Indian ‘Patrolling Points’ (PPs) along the LAC, which Indian army patrols have regularly visited for decades to assert their claim over the area. PP-14, 16, 18 and 19 are among them.
At this time of the year, when the risk of Chinese intrusions is highest, it has been customary for the army’s Udhampur-based Northern Command to move reserve formations into the area, ostensibly for ‘training exercises’.
But this year, reserve troops were retained in their peacetime locations because of the pandemic. Consequently, there has been a dire shortage of reserve troops to react to the PLA’s multiple intrusions.
By the time the Northern Army was able to move reserves into the area, the PLA had already consolidated its hold over its newly acquired positions.
Army headquarters in New Delhi is coming round to the view that top generals in Ladakh have been caught napping. There is growing talk about replacing the corps commander in Leh, and even the Northern Army commander in Udhampur.
After the Kargil intrusions of 1999, which an enquiry blamed on ‘intelligence failure’, not a single general lost his job or was replaced. The army pinned the entire blame on a single brigadier in Kargil.
A retired defence intelligence chief, speaking anonymously, blames the current situation on intelligence and operational failure.
“The Chinese have always been ultra-sensitive to India expanding its presence in northern Ladakh. That is because this adjoins the Aksai Chin, through which China has constructed its strategic Western Highway that connects Tibet with Xinjiang,” he says.
“When we built the 255-km DBDSO Road through this area, why did the army not deploy troops on the eastern side of the Shyok, especially in the Galwan Valley, to protect the eastern approaches from Chinese side?” the general asks.
The officer cites the Chinese intrusion in 2013 into Depsang, in the Daulat Beg Oldi sector, soon after India activated a landing ground there and beefed up troop numbers.
Within the army, there is growing concern that New Delhi will allow the Chinese to retain the territory they have occupied in the last month.
In public statements, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh has already conceded that the alignment of the LAC, and therefore the ownership of territory, is unclear in this area.
