By Prof. Atul Sarma & Prof. S.K.Nayak
As part of the stimulus package under ‘Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan’, the GoI has provided a package of Rs 1 lakh crore to finance agriculture infrastructure projects at the farm gate and product aggregation points. Simultaneously, it has also unfolded agriculture reform programmes.
These reforms have aimed at pumping sufficient liquidity into the economy and putting money into the hands of people, at one level and using the present COVID-19 crisis as an opportunity to bring in much needed reforms in agriculture, at another. In a nutshell, these reforms attempt at ramping up agriculture infrastructure to enhance supply chains, market facilitation of perishables and to provide better market access to farmers and eventually to create a farm to fork eco-system.
As a quick follow-up, the government has brought three ordinances on June 5, 2020 to facilitate reforms. First, ‘The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Ordinance, 2020’mainly focuses on removing restrictions on stocking food produces.
Second, ‘The Farming Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Ordinance 2020’ aims at ending the monopoly of APMC and allowing anyone to freely take part in purchase and sell of farm produces. A facilitative legal framework is expected to enable farmers to take part in inter-state trade and facilitate e-trade.
To avoid any legal arguments with the states, the Central Govt has simply designated all areas outside the physical ambit of APMC as trade zone. This means that it is left to the states to deal with their APMC Acts and regulated mandis. The central law simultaneously would provide an additional platform to farmers with adequate safeguards.
Third, ‘The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on ‘Price Assurance and Farm Services Ordinance, 2020’ provides legal framework for processors, aggregators, large retailers and exporters to directly engage with the farmers in a fair and transparent manner. Farmers and buyers can enter into contracts in which the former is assured of a certain price at the time of sowing while the latter gets to procure all harvested produce at the pre-decided rate subject to quality norms.
These three ordinances have attempted to serve farmers’ interest in different ways, including a provision of dispute resolution mechanism at one level and enhancing competitiveness in agriculture by liberalizing barrier free regulatory framework at another. In short, they provide a facilitative legal framework that protect and empower farmers to engage with business firms for remunerative price for their farm produce.
The pertinent question is: would Arunachal Pradesh farmers be able to take part and gain from these reforms? This issue has to be viewed in the context of characteristics of state agriculture.
Arunachal Pradesh is perceived as a land rich state with low population density, around 17 per square km in comparison to the national density of 382. It is a hilly and tribal state in which 26 major tribes and more than 100 minor and sub-tribes inhabit. Around 65% of its population is dependent on agriculture. And habitats are scattered. In reality, land available for agriculture in the state is small. Only 5.87 % (including hill slopes which are not suitable for multiple cropping) out of the reporting area of 72, 28, 000 hectares are land available for cultivation. Even out of this small cultivable area, 20% are classified as suitable and most suitable while 9.9% as moderately suitable and 10.07% as least suitable (Arunachal Pradesh Development Report 2009).
The state area under food grain is 66 hectare per 1000 as compared to the national average of 98 hectare. Another characteristic is that 0.86 % of the available land is under jhum cultivation, which is associated with low productivity.
What is worse, state’s agriculture productivity is very low. For example, food grain production per hectare of land is 2.13 metric ton as against the national average of 2.30 MT. The low agricultural productivity together with limited land availability for cultivation leaves no marketable surplus. On the contrary, the state suffers from food insecurity. The per capita per day intake of energy is lower than the Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) in Arunachal.
What is more, the state has also shown a declining trend in per capita per day intake of energy in between 2004-05 and 2011-12. A Govt of India report named “Food and Nutrition Security Analysis, India, 2019” has observed that “among the lowest 30 percentile of Monthly Per capita Expenditure (MPCE) class, per capita intake of energy has shown a declining trend in three states of Arunachal Pradesh, Bihar and Manipur. It can be argued that low productivity of agriculture has one way or the other has led to low purchasing power of lowest segment of the population.
However, horticulture has a huge potential in the state. State’s important horticulture products are orange, pineapple, apple, banana, kiwi and walnut. Out of 60,729.89 hectare of land used for horticulture, around 82% of land is used for producing fruits, 1.8% for vegetables and 16% for spices.
For fruits, land used for orange cultivation is around 65.9%, 5.8% for pine apple, 12.4% for apple and around 8% for kiwi cultivation. In all India level productivity of orange per hectare of land is 11.9 tonnes while in Arunachal Pradesh it is 2.41 tonnes. In case of pineapple all India productivity is 16.6 metric tones, compared to Arunachal productivity of 7.8 MT. In case of banana national productivity is 34.86 MT, where as state productivity is 1.88 MT. In case of kiwi, the national productivity is 3 MT per hectare of land where as in Arunachal productivity is 2.34 MT per hectar. Similarly, national productivity of walnut is 2.75 MT where while state’s productivity is 0.335 MT. Similar trend is also observed in productivity of cabbage, cauliflower, cabbage and other vegetables.
Clearly, there exists diversity in horticultural products, but they hugely lags in productivity. However, spices which claim 16% of the land under horticulture have recorded higher productivity, particularly large cardamom, black pepper and ginger as compared to the national average. However, spices producers do not get right prices for lack of market linkage and high logistic cost.
It can be argued that state’s horticulture with huge potential suffers from low scale of operations and lack of market access and infrastructure. In fact, the latter two are both causes and effect of low productivity. For lack of market access and infrastructure, farmers are not sufficiently incentivized to realize full potential of their horticultural products.
The above discussion brings out that both grain production horticulture are associated with low productivity leaving little marketable surplus while spices even with better productivity do not fetch remunerative price to the producers. It is because of lack of market access and market infrastructure as also because of smaller quantity of marketable surplus being available from the scattered producers over a long stretch of area.
Keeping these in view, policy makers should adopt two-pronged strategy to leverage the state’s agriculture from recent agriculture reform programes. One, the state should avail fully the infrastructure fund to create adequate logistics for market access particularly for horticultural products. The other is to encourage group/ community farming to scale up production adopting new technology and availing institutional credit.
Unless marketable surplus is large, it would not be possible for farmers to avail of the benefits from market facilitation as offered under reform programme nor would it be possible to attract large private investment flows for agro processing and so on.
(Prof. Sarma was former vice chancellor, Rajiv Gandhi University and Prof. Nayak if from RGU’s economic department)
