By Pradeep Kumar
Education, I believe begins at the womb and ends at the tomb. Great archer Arjuna’s son Abhimanyu had entered the Kaurava’s chakravyūha as he had learnt the technique while in his mother’s womb. The ranbhumi had turned his tomb as he could not learn the technique to come out as his mother had slept away while Arjuna was explaining.
Abhimanyu was a product of ancient but sacred gurukula system famed as guru-sihsya parampara (teacher-student tradition) as finds mention in English and other Western languages. It served as South Asia’s primary educational system Before the British rule. Discarding the guruku system; the Britishers adopted education system to produce an educated group only to serve their purposes.
The British ruled over India for two centuries – East India Company (1757-1858) and by Queen Victoria (1858 and 1947). But Mahatma Gandhi’s non-violent movement forced the Britishers to free India which turned into secular, sovereign, democratic republic on midnight of 15th August, 1947, but the same education system continued.
India had set up adhoc National Education Commission (1964-1966), popularly known as Kothari Commission, to examine all aspects of educational sector, evolve a general pattern and advise guidelines and policies for the development of education; followed by University Education Commission (1948-49); Secondary Education Commission (1952-53); Education Commission (1964-66); National Policy on Education (NEP-1986) and National Knowledge Commission (2009); but hardly any quality change has been seen except addition or deletion to present system. Why? There has been no fundamental change in the system where the crux of all problems lies.
This was best explained by former Secretary-General of Lok Sabha Dr. Subhash C. Kashyap, a great expert on Constitution of India: “The promise of democracy is flawed as the ‘White masters’ (Britishers) transferred power to the ‘Brown masters’ (Indians) and the slaves remained slaves in the slums and in remote rural India without feeling the glory of transfer power to become independent and true citizens”.
Responding to question from this editor on the fallacy of Indian democracy for which Indian masses have been losing faith at Naharlagun on 20.12.13, Dr Kashyap had said: “The slaves like what their masters do, eat and wear. The middle class Indians after independence are taking pride in their British style living and getting educated in English instead of in mother tongue. Those who struggled against slavery, they were not against slavery but wanted to take the place of the masters and have succeeded in doing so and that is democratic system in operation in India”, he had said to drive home his point.
But, present central government has introduced NEP-2020, approved by Union Cabinet on July 29, 2020 to replace 1986 policy. But, India is yet to adopt western style of education which is student-oriented, developing such qualities as critical thinking, problem-solving skills and generating new ideas. The main task of American or European education is to teach a student how to acquire knowledge independently. The teacher acts as a facilitator in the world of knowledge, guiding and helping students. Each student is responsible for their learning process.
In contrast, Eastern education is based on the imperative teaching method. Students receive most of their knowledge directly from the teacher, remaining mostly as observers.
However, the NEP-2020 would offer a mixture of both systems anticipating qualitative change. Are the students and teachers ready is a million dollar question. The reply however is hidden in the womb of future!
