Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
The ongoing controversy whether Defence Minister Rajnath Singh on June 17 inaugurated 12 roads developed by the BRO at Kimin is Arunachal Pradesh territory or Assam territory is intriguing but condemnable as such mistake with far reaching consequences was unexpected and in excusable.
DM Singh had tweeted an official statement of his ministry about attending the function in Lakhimpur district of Assam. The controversy evoked strong protests from various sections of Arunachal while Chief Minister Pema Khandu, Union MoS (Sports & Youth Affairs) Kiren Rijiju, Lok Sabha member Tapir Gao saying “Kimin is in Arunachal, not in Assam”.
Interestingly, the place where DM Singh’s inaugural function was conducted, i.e., present ITBP headquarters taken over from Assam Rifles, is divided by a road between Arunachal and Assam, but the ITBP functions as one unit. Interestingly, the raksha mantri office’s (RMO) official Twitter handle had explicitly mentioned Kimin as being in Assam. In its tweet, the RMO stated, “Raksha Mantri Shri Rajnath Singh at the inaugural ceremony of border road organization. The programme was held in Assam.” However, the DM’s tweet had intriguingly mentioned the name of place as Bilgarh. Such a place in Kimin area, if existed, is never known.
Erasing name of Arunachal Pradesh by white ink has surfaced and the BRO well could be accused of this mistake. If at all such a move, what was the intention? By any chance, was it apprehension that China as usual would react to visit of any top central leader to Arunachal? China is known for dog’s tail policy on India. When god failed to straighten dog’s tail, can anyone do it? But the BRO set up on 07.05.1960 to secure India’s borders and develop infrastructure in remote areas of north and north-east states of the country under Border Roads Development Board with Prime Minister as chairman and Defence Minister as Deputy Chairman has been doing appreciable works.
There was prolonged controversy about location of 2000-MW Lower Subansiri Hydro-Electric Power project which is located in Arunachal. But ignorantly projected as Assam initially by National Hydro-Electric Power Corporation (NHPC), a central PSU.
The Kimin controversy brings into limelight the decades-old inter-state boundary dispute between both neighbouring states of Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.
An official statement by the central or Arunachal or Assam Govt about the status of Kimin is not going to make any difference until the inter-state boundary dispute is amicably resolved.
This issue has been decorating the state assembly and Lok Sabha election manifestos since past decades while the Supreme Court had constituted a boundary commission but still the solution has remained a far cry.
In fact, the father of this inter-state boundary row is then Assam Prime Minister Gopinath Bordoloi, who as member of Constitution drafting committee, was well aware of implication of boundary line. Thus, the boundary between Assam and Arunachal Pradesh (known as North East Frontier Agency -NEFA- then) was drawn on the basis of single-man Bordoloi Commission, 1951.
This again reminds illegal eviction drive by 300-armed police personnel led by Assam’s Dhemaji district SP, ADC and SDO, who armed with excavator had demolished the pandal etc. erected at Malini Mela ground at Likabali under W/Siang district and took away the CGI sheets and other materials of the organizing committee around 2.30 am Thursday without any prior notice.
Then chief minister Nabam Tuki, after conducting an aerial survey of the evicted area 05.04.12 when I accompanied him, had termed it provocative.
“It is breach of trust that could jeopardize the bilateral relations between the two sisterly states. Such condemnable and uncalled for evictions should be avoided at all costs,” then Lok Sabha member Takam Sanjoy had rued.
Assam Health & Education Ministers Himanata Biswa Sarma (present CM) had pleaded his ignorance, when Sanjoy had drawn his attention over telephone towards illegal eviction but had assured to direct the DGP for immediate steps to not repeat it in future in mutual interest.
Status-quo: It would be worth mentioning here that CMs of both states had agreed to honour status quo on 10.07.87, 12.08.95 and 20.07.99. Further, they held a joint meeting on 31.08.91 and a joint ministerial meet on 27/28.05.98. The Assam Govt had moved the Supreme Court in September 1989, which constituted Local Boundary Committee in Sept 2004 to identify the boundaries of Assam, Arunachal and Nagaland.
Despite all this, Assam police and forest officials continue evictions unabated in the name of 1951 notification that demarcates the so-called inter-state boundary of the then NEFA, ab intio rejected by the people of Arunachal, who had no representative in the commission.
Evictions: To cite some major examples, 1) Assam armed battalions were guarded Shimhokho and Kamkuh Russa villages (Bimolapur in Assam), where they were all in war gear with LMGs ready to fire from trenches dug inside the tea gardens and observations posts manned by forces with binoculars after a minor incident of reported dismantling of the Assam police barracks by miscreants at 2.30 am on Aug 14.08.10 at Russa village snowballed into in inter-state tension and imposition of economic blockade by NGOs of Assam. This had led to constitution of a high-level committee headed by the then minister Setong Sena to visit Dispur and hold talks with a ministerial committee of Assam to bring back normalcy. I had accompanied the team. 2) 200 villagers of Dolung village under Papum Pare district evicted on 20.12.04, and on 05.02.05 burnt down 9 houses and a granary in Dipik village.
3) On 05.02.05 in Dipik village under Dising Passo circle of East Kameng district unprovoked eviction by forest and police personnel of Assam.
Fading hope: An 18-member team of Assamese newsmen led by the state’s deputy IPR director Hiranya Kumar Bhuyan on a four-day goodwill mission in Sept 2009 was shocked when Tarasso village gaon buri Tana Joy, who lost her everything, including traditional ornaments in April 22 eviction drive conducted by Sonitour DC, narrated in detail (in chaste Assamese) how she suffered, and questioned – “Is this eviction? Are we not Indians? Why should we be looted, tormented and left homeless for no fault of ours?”
“We are going back to Dispur as your ambassadors,” was the assurance of Dainik Purboday executive editor Ravi Sankar Ravi, while Assam Tribune EE Prasanta Jyoti Baruah had opined: “The media of both states should mobilize people’s opinion and pressurize both state Govts to settle the boundary dispute once and for all when the same party is ruling in both the states and at the Centre.” I wonder how and why the Assam media failed to keep its promise. (Boundary row – who is responsible? -12.01.09)
People of both states have been coexisting peacefully since ages but some Assam officials create skirmishes from time to time under the shelter of Bordoloi commission notification.
On 02.04.10, then Union Home Minister P Chidambaram had told media persons at Itanagar that the Centre is making all efforts to find a lasting solution to the decades-old boundary dispute. “The Supreme Court-constituted one-man Local Boundary Commission, headed by justice Tarun Kumar Chatterjee, who replaced justice Variabha recently, is looking into the pros and cons of the boundary issue and is expected to send a report to the home ministry soon”. But the issue is gathering dust with the commission while people living along the boundary, particularly the Arunchalees, continue to suffer as the Assam-Arunachal boundary dispute is sub-judice in the Supreme Court.
On June 22, if Mizoram decided to resolve its boundary dispute with Assam and Tripura, there should be no delay in this regard, particularly when BJP-led Govt is ruling at the Centre as well as in Arunachal Pradesh and Assam. Why not consult legal experts and move the Lok Sabha to replace Bordoloi Commission-1951 notification by a now boundary which should be drawn with mutual understanding?
CM Khandu has rightly proposed his Assam counterpart to solve inter-state boundary row mutually. However, a high-level committee should be formed soon to suggest the border line.
Present MLA Tarin Dakpe, who as East Kameng DC was involved in boundary row discussion with his Assam’s Sonitpur counterpart, MLA Gabriel D Wangsu, witness to Russa village controversy and instrumental in visit of then home minister Tako Dabi’s visit to Russa twice with media persons, and present political joint secretary Rajiv Takuk, having through knowledge of inters-state boundary, should be included in that panel.
