Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
‘Aapka votes, Hamara Bhavishya’, a message to all eligible AAPSU voters, doing rounds in social media, reflects not only money culture but also sincerity and honesty to end the menace anticipating a brighter future for Arunachal Pradesh where ‘corruption is an icon of success’.
Today’s youth being tomorrow’s citizens and AAPSU being a platform for future leaders, AAPSU chief election commissioner Dr Chera Tamak deserves appreciation not only for such maiden initiative but also for conceiving the idea and Nengkar Tagia for translating it into reality through a documentary film.
However, such campaign is more essential during general elections when only cash rules the roots in every corner of this developing state.
I, under ‘In Retrospection’ column, in 31.12.1989 edition of Echo of Arunachal, had written “Poll expenses: Sanity resurrected” advocating need for drastic electoral reforms that had failed to draw any attention.
“Though Indian politics has passed through many a trial and tribulations since the Constitution of India adopted in January 1950 gave democracy as gift to the people of this country, but naked use of money and muscle power has polluted the body polity to its core. And many devoid of ethics and principles join it not to serve the masses but to serve their vested interest alone. Massive rigging and booth capturing have raised many a questions about the very election process, the bedrock of Indian democracy.
“Cleansing the politics from the menace of money and muscle power to facilitate the elector to exercise their franchise in a free and fair manner has been a debatable topic for long but without any tangible steps so far to achieve the goal.
“The reality of polluting electoral system dawned on the then Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government prompting the cabinet to approve a Rs. 1,200 crore plan for non-cash state funding of polls.
“Accepting the suggestions of reforms by Indrajit Gupta panel, the plan envisages making a provision in the union budget to help parties with publicity materials, microphones, telephones, petrol and other poll-related expenses. This aimed at helping politicians overcome dependence on non-transparent funding sources.
“The astronomical poll expenses prompt the politicians to resort to unethical practices to win election, which later force them to commit crimes even without batting an eyelid. Why to talk about the poll expenses in other parts of the country, when there was no dearth of example of ‘limit-crossing’ expenditure in Arunachal Pradesh itself’?
“‘Limit’ a mockery as money buys the votes—a opinion poll by this columnist published in 31.10.03 in a local daily had cleared the doubts about the high expenditure level of elections.
“The then state Nationalist Congress Party president Tadar Taniang had admitted that money and muscle power has eaten into the vitals of Indian democracy to such an extent that money alone elects leaders.
“Claiming that poll expenditure in Arunachal was highest in the country and lowest in Mizoram where the Young Mizo Association and Church Associations have prohibited wasteful expenditure, Taniang had hinted that the actual expenditure in Parliament and assembly polls in Arunachal go up to Rs. three crore and Rs. 50 lakh respectively. The then APCC spokesman Habung Payeng had estimated it to Rs one crore and Rs 50 lakh and the then state BJP president Kangir Jamoh had put it at Rs. one crore and Rs. 25 lakh against the prevailing limit of Rs. 25 lakh and Rs. 10 lakh respectively.
“In 2005 ‘cash-for-query scam’, a sting operation by Cobrapost aired on a private TV channel on 12.12.05, had shown 11 MPs taking money to raise questions in Parliament. Out of the 11 MPs accused in the case, six were from the BJP, three from BSP, and one each from the RJD and Congress. A Delhi court special judge Kiran Bansal had framed graft and criminal conspiracy charges against the MPs.
“The Lok Sabha had expelled 10 members while the lone Rajya Sabha member was also expelled. On 24.12.05, the Parliament had voted to expel the 11 MPs in a historic move. Then leader of the house Pranab Mukherjee had introduced a resolution seeking expulsion of the members while then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had done the same in Rajya Sabha”.
However, reforms, if introduced, may not bring a sweeping change, until the people and their leaders become conscious. Mizoram is the best example as Mizos, Young Mizo Association and Church Associations have worked conscientiously to make state’s election expenditure lowest in the country.
“Voting is legally adhered to the principle of secret ballot to make voters anonymous while preventing him/her from outside influence. Regrettably, the ground realties are dismal even today with votes being sold or bought while the expenditure limit for the Assembly and Lok Sabha candidates are for namesake,” I wrote on 08.05.14 in “Electoral frauds demeaning democracy!”
Election Commission of India (ECI) appointed teams had seized Rs 195 crore cash. Andhra Pradesh topped the list with Rs 118 crore cash followed by Tamil Nadu (Rs 18.31 cr), Maharashtra (Rs 14.40 cr), UP (Rs 10.46 cr), Arunachal Pradesh (Rs 4.4 cr) and Punjab (over Rs 4 cr) besides many small states, according to data of election expenditure observers up to 08.04.14.
The seizure is only about 6% of the Rs 3,050 crore projected to be spent by the candidates and parties of total 2014 election expenditure estimated at Rs 35,000 crore, an analysis by Association for Democratic Reforms says.
Are the votes for auction? Should the citizens sell their votes to be happy in discharging their right? Why grumble then when the Govts fail to meet their expectations? That was why former Chief Election Commissioner TN Seshan had commented: “Good government is not an accident.”
It was Seshan who had had also enforced campaign spending limits (Rs 20,000 to 40,000 for assembly and Rs 1.5 to 1.7 lakh for Lok Sabha), but the ECI had upped the expense limit for Lok Sabha from Rs 40 lakh to Rs 70 lakh per candidate in big states.
But does this have anything to do with the reality? In 2009 General election, about 129 MPs declared election expenses of less than 50% of expense limit. Out of 437 MPs, who submitted their election expenditure statements, on an average spent of Rs 14.62 lakh (about 59% of the average expense limit) in 2009, the analysis by Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and National Election Watch (NEW) shows. (To be continued)
