WHO & GoI COVID-19 data disputable

India’s total 4,30,98,743,

recovery rate now 98.74%

India reported 3,805 new COVID-19 infections on Saturday, 7.3% higher than Friday, taking cumulative caseload to 4,30,98,743 and active caseload to 20,303 with 615 active cases increasing in last 24 hours. Total recoveries across India were 4,25,54,416, including total 3,168 patients in  last 24 hours making the recovery rate 98.74%, according to data shared by Union Health Ministry.

By Pradeep Kumar

ITANAGAR, May 07: Noted columnist of Hindustan Times Sukumar Ranganathan has  disputed COVID-19 death toll numbers released WHO, claiming that they are higher than the official numbers, and also higher than expected.

At the global level, the agency estimates that the real death toll is three times the reported number; and in India’s case, it estimates the number at nine times the reported one.

That these numbers were coming was known — and may have perhaps pushed the GoI to release the Civil Registry System data for birth and deaths for 2020, showing relatively more benign numbers. To be sure, these numbers are always released around this time of the year – the 2019 numbers came out in June 2021 – but if the objective was to show that multiple modelling studies, and WHO’s own report, that put India’s death toll much higher than the reported number were untrue, then that remained unmet.

Hours before the release, union health ministry even organised an informal briefing to explain why it think that WHO’s methodology is flawed, and soon after the data came out, the GoI issued a strong official rebuttal of the numbers.

So, who’s right? And who’s wrong? I’ve written extensively on COVID-19 death numbers over the past two years, most recently two weeks ago. For what it’s worth, I think both WHO and the Indian Govt are wrong, although the debate is unlikely to be settled till infection fatality rate numbers for COVID-19, across geographies, are estimated through rigorous studies and modeling.

We will continue with numbers because the Reserve Bank of India’s Monetary Policy Committee, in an unscheduled meeting, raised the policy rate as well as the quantum of their deposits banks need to keep as cash with the central bank, both efforts to tighten liquidity and reduce inflation.

While this may be difficult to achieve through monetary intervention – the cause of the inflation is not overheating of the economy in this case – the move does send out a signal that could reduce inflationary expectations. Still, it’s not going to be easy.

There was more data that came out this week or over the course of last weekend. On Sunday, the GoI  released details of the GST collection in April (for March month). At ₹1.68 lakh crore, the number was the highest ever. But as HT pointed out, “Does the role of seasonality and inflation mean that the latest GST number does not hold any message of the state of the macroeconomy at large? This is a more difficult question to answer at the moment.” Perhaps that’s why union finance ministry did not use the numbers to make triumphalist statements about the economy.

Related posts