Are Legislative & Judiciary in a whirlpool?

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

The Supreme Court and central Govt currently engaged in a spat on issue of judges’ appointment recommended by collegiums signaling a whirlpool in which two wings of democracy are stuck.

Of the three pillars of democracy, the legislature enacts laws for other two organs to function, the executive as head of the government with prime/chief ministers, ministers and president/governors implements the laws. However, the judiciary interprets the law, settles disputes and administers justice to all citizens. It is considered the watchdog of democracy and also guardian of the Constitution. It comprises of the Supreme Court, the high courts, district and other subordinate courts.

In 1998,   the S in its verdict, laid down strict guidelines for appointment of judges of SC and HCs which is currently known as Collegium System, which will recommend names of candidates to the central Govt.  The GoI will send those names consultation. If the Collegium resends the same name again then the GoI has to give its assent to the names.

The Collegium System faced a lot of criticism not only from the government but also from civil society due to its lack of transparency and accountability.  This led to 99th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2014 (the National Judicial Commission Act- NJAC) to replace the collegium system for appointment of judges.

In March 2021, the SC had asked the Govt to clarify the status of 55 recommendations made by the Collegium for judicial appointments to high courts six months to nearly a year-and-a-half ago. The SC has been repeatedly conveying to the Govt its growing concerns about the judicial vacancies in high courts.

GoI wants to capture judiciary: Sibal

On 16..01.23, Rajya Sabha MP and former law minister Kapil Sibal accused the GoI of attempting to “capture” the judiciary and said it was trying its best to create a situation in which National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) in “another avatar” may be tested in the Supreme Court once again.

Sibal claimed the GoI has not adjusted to the fact that it does not have the final word on appointments in higher judiciary and resents it. He said that though he was critical of the collegium system, at this juncture of our polity, appointments to the higher judiciary cannot be handed over to the Govt.

Sibal, 74, asserted the basic structure doctrine as enunciated in Kesavananda Bharati verdict was very important in current times and dared the Govt to openly say if that is flawed.

Meanwhile, the Congress escalating its attack over Vice President (VP) Jagdeep Dhankhars comments on judiciary on Wednesday cited his predecessor M Venkaiah Naidu’s remarks in 2020 in which he had stated that none of the three organs of the state can claim to be supreme as only the Constitution is supreme.

VP Dhankhar had said “one-upmanship and public posturing” from judicial platforms is not good and these institutions must know how to conduct themselves. Dhankhar’s virtual censure of the judiciary had come following the apex court’s remarks on the issue of collegium system.

Stepping up the party’s attack over the issue, Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh tweeted, “Mr. Chidambaram has pointedly countered the Vice President’s assault on judiciary by saying the Constitution and not Parliament is supreme. Just a year ago, Mr. Dhankar’s predecessor Venkaiah Naidu-garu had said exactly what Mr. Chidambaram has.”

Addressing 83rd All India Presiding Officers Conference in Jaipur, Dhankar had again criticised scrapping of NJAC Act in 2015 and questioned the landmark 1973 Kesavananda Bharati case verdict, saying it set a wrong precedent and that he disagrees with the Supreme Court ruling that Parliament can amend the Constitution but not its basic structure. (Agency)

‘Set up panel to shortlist names for SC & HC judges’

On 17.01.23, Union Law Minister Kiren Rijiju has wrote  to Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, seeking setting up of a committee where the GoI will also have a say to shortlist the names for judges to the SC and HCs.

The GoI is an “important stakeholder” in the process of appointment of SC and HC judges and its views should also find a place in preparation of the panel of people who are eligible to be appointed as judges, Rijiju wrote in his letter, dated 06.01.23.

He suggested that a search-cum-evaluation committee be constituted for the purpose. The committee would create a pool of names and forward that to the SC and HC collegiums for final selection, he wrote in the letter.

People in the know said he had demanded that there should be a nominee of the central Govt in the proposed committee for the appointment of judges to the top court. For high courts, the respective state Govts should also get representation, he wrote to the CJI, according to these people.

The Govt had in 2017, 2018 and 2021 also written to the top court on setting up a search panel for shortlisting judges to the higher judiciary. In those communications, the Govt had proposed that the evaluation committee could comprise former judges, academicians and other area experts and that the constitution of it could be decided by the CJI in consultation with the central Govt.

In the latest letter, the law minister has stated that from the panel of eligible candidates prepared by the proposed committee, the respective collegium could make recommendations and send those to the Govt with the requisite documents. The letter suggested that senior judges who are not part of the collegium may also send their recommendations to the evaluation committee.

People in the know said the Govt had underscored the need for setting up of the committee as part of its endeavour to strengthen the memorandum of procedure (MoP), which lays down the procedure for the appointment of judges to the SC and HCs.

The revised MoP is yet to be finalised after the SC in December 2015 struck down the National Judicial Appointment Commission (NJAC) Act brought in by the Modi Govt.

Rijiju on Monday described the letter as “just the precise follow-up action” suggested by the top court while striking down the NJAC.

Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal tweeted that the GoI’s communication was “extremely dangerous” and that “there should be absolutely no GoI interference in judicial appointments”.

On 25.01.23: Rijiju said putting “sensitive” opinions or reports of Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) and Intelligence Bureau (IB) in the public domain by Supreme Court Collegium is a “matter of grave concern”

On 03.02.23, the SC warned the Centre for sitting over files on judges’ transfer and appointments. Things have not been happening for years together, the bench said, and warned of ‘uncomfortable’ action if it fails to clear names for transfer of judges in 10 days.

The SC, on Friday, remarked that the incessant attacks on judiciary by the other authorities, especially with respect to the process of appointment of judges‘does not bother it beyond a certain stage.  The bench comprising justice S K Kaul & jutice A S Oka reckoned that the concerned higher authorities attacking judiciary should decide for themselves what is appropriate comment and what is not.

The Centre and Supreme Court, were both, once again seen posturing and firming up their stance on the highly-contentious issue of judicial appointments. In a hearing scheduled before the top court, Justice SK Kaul warned the attorney general that the court should not be forced into passing orders that would make the Centre “uncomfortable”.

Related posts