“Indian democracy has to reinvent itself to gain the confidence of the masses. The need of the hour is fundamental systemic changes, not from democratic form to presidential form, but to regain the faith make the masses the real masters,” former Lok Sabha Secretary-General Dr. Subhash C. Kashyap had told this editor in an exclusive interview at Naharlagun on 20.12.13.
“The representative legitimacy of the representatives of this democracy is in doubt. Democracy is facing many challenges, the worst is nothing could be more tragic than the masses losing faith in their representatives. There is of course a way out for the democracy to reinvent itself to win the confidence of the masses,” he had said.
Dr Kashyap, who has authored 100 books in English and Hindi and associated with the Parliament for over 37 years, had said that though Congress party struggled for independence but their resolutions favoured to adopt British system, institutions and education, but what India inherited is the colonial system the Britishers had evolved to rule India.
The British parliamentary system has 12 main characteristics and none is applied to Indian democracy. The first fallacy is that the vulnerable founding fathers of our system accepted it and it continues till date, he reasoned. This means we defied and defaced the western concept of democracy.
“We don’t have a sovereign democratic republic in real sense. The rulers still are masters and ruled are subjects, where as in a sovereign democratic republic, the people are real masters.
“The people rule over them through their representatives who are not true in India as those elected are not their true representatives,” he said citing an example that 83.6% of all sitting members of Parliament are those against whom the majority had voted. The promise of democracy is flawed as the White masters transferred power to the Brown masters and the slaves remained slaves in the slums and in remote rural India without feeling the glory of transfer power to become independent and true citizens, he argued.
“The slaves like what their masters do, eat and wear, after independence the middle class Indians are taking pride in their British style living and education instead of in mother tongue,” he said to drive home his point.
Those who struggled against slavery, they were not against slavery but wanted to take the place of the masters and have succeeded in doing so and that is democratic system in operation in India, said Dr Kashyap, who was honourary constitutional adviser to government of India on PRI laws besides heading many national and international bodies.
