BJP’s 400 claim for 2024 polls could be true, if EVMs not fixed, warns  Pitroda

 

Beyond the Horizon

By Pradeep Kumar

EVMs cannot be hacked

but manipulated: Expert

One of India’s foremost EVM experts Madhav Deshpande, former CEO of Tulip Software and a former consultant to former USA President Barak Obama administration, in an interview to English daily Wire on 31.01.24 had said that while EVMs cannot be hacked, because they are not connected to Wi-Fi, Bluetooth or the Internet, but they can be easily manipulated. The remedy to guard against this manipulation is simple, straightforward and inexpensive, he had added. His comment would undoubtedly hackle the ECI and potentially disturb politicians of all political parties.

Indian Overseas Congress chairman Sam Pitroda has  reiterated his apprehensions around the Electronic Voting Machines (EVM) and said the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led BJP can win 400 seats in 2024 Lok Sabha elections if EVMs are not fixed.

He said there is a trust deficit in EVMs and he even wrote to the Election Commission of India (ECI) about the same.

“I waited for the ECI to respond but when it didn’t happen I decided to speak. It has nothing to do with the fact that elections in five states are over and the 2024 election is coming. I feel there is a trust deficit based on this report. And, the ECI must respond to rebuild the trust,” he said.

“More power to them if they think they can do it. Great. That is for the country to decide. EVM needs to be fixed before the next election. If EVM is not fixed, 400 may be true. If EVM is fixed, 400 may not be true,” he said.

The questions around EVMs are not new as Opposition parties have several times alleged that the EVMs are rigged in the favor of BJP. The ECI has dismissed all such allegations and even challenged the political parties to prove their claims. The BJP has also targeted Opposition parties over the issue and called it their excuse after losing elections.

Pitroda, who recently attracted some ire for his remarks on Ram Mandir, claimed that his comments were “twisted” and that religion should not be complicated by politics. In his clarification, he said “I am basically protecting the Constitution. I am saying that religion is a very personal matter, leave it to the people. Of course you celebrate, people should celebrate what they want to. But don’t complicate it with politics,” he said, adding “I have no problem with any religion. It is okay to go visit the temple once in a while, but you can’t make that the main platform. 40% of people vote for BJP, and 60% of people do not vote for BJP. He is everybody’s Prime Minister and not a party’s Prime Minister and that’s the message the people of India want him to have. Talk about employment, talk about inflation, talk about science and technology and challenges. They (people) have to decide what are the real issues- is Ram Mandir the real issue? Or unemployment is a real issue. Is Ram Mandir the real issue or Inflation is a real issue?” he wondered.

The BJP was quick to hit back at Pitroda, saying he represents the thinking of former Congress President Rahul Gandhi. “This is Sam Pitroda who is the mentor of Rahul Gandhi. A lot of it represents the thinking of Rahul Gandhi that Hindutva doesn’t matter. Terrorism doesn’t matter because of appeasement. Inflation and corruption don’t matter because of crony capitalism. Hindu faith doesn’t matter because of their appeasement politics,” BJP MP Rajeev Chandrashekhar said.

US scientist hack into Indian EVMs

Pitroda, who was instrumental in telecom revolution in India, may be wrong as he is a Congress leader, but BBC News Science reporter Julian Siddle had reported: Scientists of a US university say they have developed a technique to hack into Indian EVMs. After connecting a home-made device to a machine, University of Michigan (UoM) researchers were able to change results by sending text messages from a mobile.

India uses about 1.4m electronic voting machines in each general election. Indian election officials say their machines are foolproof, and that it would be very difficult even to get hold of a machine to tamper with it.

Hacking: A video posted on the internet by UoM researchers purportedly shows them connecting a home-made electronic device to one of the voting machines used in India. Prof J Alex Halderman, who led the project, said the device allowed them to change the results on the machine by sending it messages from a mobile phone.

“We made an imitation display board that looks almost exactly like the real display in the machines,” he told the BBC. “But underneath some of the components of the board, we hide a microprocessor and a Bluetooth radio.”

“Our lookalike display board intercepts the vote totals that the machine is trying to display and replaces them with dishonest totals – basically whatever the bad guy wants to show up at the end of the election.”

In addition, they added a small microprocessor which they say can change the votes stored in the machine between the election and the vote-counting session.

India’s electronic voting machines are considered to be among the most tamperproof in the world.There is no software to manipulate – records of candidates and votes cast are stored on purpose-built computer chips.

Tampering difficult: India’s Deputy Election Commissioner Alok Shukla said even getting hold of machines to tamper with would be very difficult. “It is not just the machine, but the overall administrative safeguards which we use that make it absolutely impossible for anybody to open the machine,” he told the BBC.

“Before the elections take place, the machine is set in the presence of the candidates and their representatives. These people are allowed to put their seal on the machine, and nobody can open the machine without breaking the seals.” However, for their system to have any impact they would need to install their microchips on many voting machines, no easy task when 13,68,430 were used in the last general election in 2009, he added. But, the researchers said the paper and wax seals could be easily faked.

 

Related posts