By Pradeep Kumar Behera
“Media, Politics and Democracy” is not a topic for any talk or discussion as is calls for in-depth research in each aspect in the context of India, presumed to be the largest democracy and the United States of America the best democracy on earth.
The invitation letter received from Fakir Mohan University HoD (journalism & mass communication)-cum-convenor of International Media Conclave Dr Bharati Bala Patanaik has explained well the boundary of the paper to be presented. Please pardon me, if I cross the boundary as I shall be delving into my personal experiences.
Let me define three words first: Media aims at communication, derived from Latin word communis, means ‘common’ or Communicare, root of communication, means ‘to impart’, ‘to participate’ or ‘transmit’, But, according to it is mein diya; Politics is an art or science concerned with guiding or influencing governmental policy and Democracy, a Greek word (demos means people and kratos means power), but its globally accepted definition by former USA President Abraham Lincoln is “of the people, by the people, for the people”.
India graduated to parliamentary form of democracy on gaining independence from British rule on the midnight of 15.08.1947. Though Constitution of India was ready by 26.22.1949, India formally became a sovereign republic only on 26.01.1950. The Preamble to the Indian Constitution reads: “We, the people of India, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic Republic and to secure to all its citizens: Justice, social, economic and political; Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and of opportunity; and to promote among them all”. Article 19(1)(a) guarantees all citizens the right to freedom of speech and expression. This includes the right to express opinions freely through words, writings, pictures, movie and banners.
On analyzing socio-cultural, financial and political aspects of India right from 1947, which I have been doing since 20.02.1987 as the pioneer print and electronic journalist of Arunachal Pradesh, official corresponded of PTI, anchor of Itanagar AIR and Doordarshan and served as ANI consulting editor for North East India and introduced mass communication in state’s Arunachal University (now central Rajiv Gamdhi University) in 2004 to serve as visiting faculty and my loving student Ms Moti Pangkham serves in this department. I totally disagree that India is a democratic nation. Don’t scoff at me as I would like to quote world famous constitutional expert Dr Subash Chandra Kashyap, who in his candid interview to this Editor on 20.12.2013 at Itanagar, had opined:
“Though Congress party struggled for independence, but their resolutions favoured to adopt British system, institutions and education. Thus, what India inherited is the colonial system the Britishers had evolved to rule India.
“The British parliamentary system has 12 main characteristics and none is applied to Indian democracy. The first fallacy is that the vulnerable founding fathers of our system accepted it and it continues till date. This means we defied and defaced the western concept of democracy,” rued Dr Kashyap, who had served the Parliament for over 37 years including during the time of Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Lok Sabha speaker Ganesh Vasudev Mavalankar, known as Dadasaheb, adding “This means we defied and defaced the western concept of democracy.”
“We don’t have a sovereign democratic republic in real sense. The rulers still are masters and ruled are subjects, where as in a sovereign democratic republic, the people are real masters.
“The people rule over them through their representatives who are not true in India as those elected are not their true representatives,” he said, citing an example that 83.6% of all sitting members of (Outgoing) Parliament are those against whom the majority had voted.
“The promise of democracy is flawed as the White masters transferred power to the Brown masters and the slaves remained slaves in the slums and in remote rural India without feeling the glory of transfer power to become independent and true citizens,” he argued.
“The slaves like what their masters do, eat and wear, after independence the middle class Indians are taking pride in their British style living and education instead of in mother tongue,” he said to drive home his point.
“Those who struggled against slavery, they were not against slavery but wanted to take the place of the masters and have succeeded in doing so and that is the democratic system in operation in India,” said Dr Kashyap, who was honorary constitutional adviser to Govt of India on PRI laws.
When his attention was drawn to money-muscle free elections in Mizoram dictated by Young Mizo Association supported by powerful missionary groups, he admitted that the state is a role model in the entire country and could serve as panacea to present ills of our democratic system.
“The representative legitimacy of the representatives of this democracy is in doubt. Democracy is facing many challenges and the worst is nothing could be more tragic than the masses losing faith in their representatives. There is of course a way out for the democracy to reinvent itself to win the confidence of the masses.”
“The need of the hour is fundamental systemic changes, not from democratic form to presidential form, but to regain the faith make the masses the real masters,” he said without mincing any words.
However, there could be many fundamental issues, like changing the provision in the Peoples’ Representative Act, 1952 that allows 2/3rd majority of any party switching over loyalty after election for the sake of power. Why should the Constitution facilitate horse trading in politics?
The Tenth Schedule – popularly known as the Anti-Defection Act – was included in the Constitution by 52nd Amendment Act, 1985 by the Rajiv Gandhi ministry and sets the provisions for disqualification of elected members on the grounds of defection to another political party. The 91st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2003, changed the provision: “The merger of the original political party or a member of a House shall be deemed to have taken place if, and only if, not less than two-thirds of the members of the legislature party concerned have agreed to such merger,” states the 10th Schedule.
Should the unabated splitting of India in the name of region and community continue? Why should there be different civil laws in world’s largest democracy for different set of people?
Indians had united and spoke in chorus in 1947 that won freedom. Similarly, Indians irrespective of caste, creed, religion and region had united again during consecration of Lord Ram statue in Shri Ram Temple on 22.01.24.
So far media is concerned, Hicky’s Bengal Gazette or Calcutta General or Advertiser in English, the first printed newspaper in Indian sub-continent, was published from Calcutta (now Kolkata), the British India capital, on 29.01.1780 by James Augustus Hickey, As a highly eccentric Irishman who had previously spent two years in jail for debt. Later Hicky was jailed because he earned the wrath of the Governor-General Lord Warren Hastings for write-ups mostly criticizing the activities of Lady Hastings and continued to write from jail until his movable types were seized from him under Lord Hasting’s orders. The newspaper soon became very famous not only among the British soldiers posted in India but also inspired the Indians to write newspapers of their own. The paper ceased publication on 23.03. 1782.
Though All India Radio was founded in 1936 and Doordarshan on 15.09.1959 in Delhi to serve as a bridge between the Govt and the masses, but India saw tremendous growth in print and electronic media. India on 31.03.2022 had 146,045 registered publications, including 20,821 newspapers and 1, 25, 767 periodicals while there are over 800 television channels and over 200 commercial radio stations, but social media has been ruling the roost in this IT age.
Making a law is not important, but its implementation. Instead of going into mindless violation of various Articles of the Constitution and many independent institutions stand questioned today, let me ask: Is Article 19(1)(a) guarantying all citizens the right to freedom of speech and expression?
Media is the mirror of the Govt and the society. But in present day, print and electronic media, with few exceptions, highlights only what they have been asked or paid to do by adopting cyan, magenta, yellow and black (CYAN), the chemistry of colour printing. Media is the giver and the people are receivers and no one knows who holds the control button to twist it as wished when and why! That is why despite being a senior print and electronic journalist for over 37 years: I have defined Media as mein diya (I gave). Receivers have to accept ‘what I give’ without asking any question.
While electronic media most of the time tries to highlight both side of a news simultaneously, print media offers ‘Readers’ Column’ to express their views. But, do those who matter act on such views is a million dollar question?
Media is considered the fourth pillar of democracy while legislature, executive, and judiciary are other three pillars of democracy. The Constitution framers of India built the country’s democratic governance system on these three pillars. If media stands questioned, are other three pillars functioning in tune with the constitutional mandate?
Judges of various courts are beyond the purview of media even if they commits blunder. That is why once, I on 28.01.09 had written: Who will judge the judges?
This had drawn attention of a judge of Itanagar Permanent Bench of Gauhati High Court, who had called me for a personal interaction to appreciate the painstaking writing despite limitation of print media.

Moreover, former Supreme Court of India’s Chief Justice-designate Altamus Kabir, also executive chairman of National Legal Services Authority, after inaugurating first legal aid centre of the state at Papu village-I community hall in state capital on 05.04.12 was returning to Delhi next day when I met him in the helipad and offered a copy of that day’s issue of Arunachal Front.
He had quipped: “Young man, why are you offering your paper? I’ve never read such honest report (on the inauguration of maiden state level legal aid centre in Papu-I village in Naharlagun on 05-04-12). Why are you offering me the same edition?”
Hinting at the rising number of pending cases in various courts across the country and citing the oldest pending case of Kolkata High Court, I said: “Sir, this is February 20, 2012 edition with a write-up about state’s bureaucrat-magistrates who have inked national records – My Lord, why not take a cue from Arunachal?” I informed politely. “Thank you, I shall read it,” he had replied before heading towards the helicopter.
You all know that the 560-km English Channel is the longest and busiest shipping area in the world. But “Government channel is the longest in the world, don’t you know?” Nothing moves on expected line anywhere in the country contrary to the tall claims of good governance and transparency.
Sadly, the Govts falter very often than not in taking major policy decisions for no convincing reasons, probably for coalition politics. Should that be the price we pay for democracy? Certainly yes, till we find another substitute through political evolution.
What has India achieved with its long years of near-uninterrupted democracy to reduce the gap between rich and poor and rising poverty? The human rights abuses from Kashmir to Manipur, when Indian forces were called in to quell separatist revolts? These are very pertinent questions. Have the people taken everything including the rampant corruption, human rights violation and police accesses for granted as fruits of democracy?
I have numerous examples of union ministers and chief ministers committing blunders for political consideration, like each voter of a particular assembly constituency paid Rs 1.6 lakh during 2019 assembly election and seizure of Rs 1.8 crore from the CM’s convoy in Pasighat around midnight on 03.04.19 hours before PM Narendra Modi was schedule to address a rally there reflecting “money power” to woo voters. These are examples of poor state of affairs of Indian politics. Money power to influence voters is common across India as observers of Election Commission of India seize crores of money during every election.
With general elections knocking at the doors, Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Khandu in all public meetings has been exhorting the masses to discourage ‘money culture’ in politics, being the root cause of corruption.
“Those who get elected by spending crores would be more interested in recovering the money spent instead of taking up development for which they cannot be blamed. But the power of money could be overcome when the people decided conscientiously not to accept money in favour of vote. That alone would facilitate development”, he says with conviction, clearly indicating deep-rooted money culture in the state.
The media, politics and democracy is a dynamic and complex landscape that plays a pivotal role in shaping socio-political fabric of India and my introspection is: if money culture is glittering, media is mein diya (increasing tendency of modern mass media in politics to blur and confuse boundaries between journalism, entertainment, public relations and advertising), Indian politicians have changed definition of democracy to “off the people, buy the people, far the people”, by evolving a new democracy, called ‘Dancecracy’, as the ruled dance as the rulers wish them to dance, which needs qualitative transformation to serve the masses. September 15 is the International Day of Democracy which is meant both to celebrate democracy and as a reminder to promote and protect democracy by the citizens. The need of the hour is for the citizens to rise conscientiously and walk together till the goal is reached.
I as a journalist except writing may not contribute much to the goal, thus conclude by wishing my loving Mother India Charaiveti… Charaiveti, means ‘Go on’…‘Go on’.
