Merger of 43 INC MLAs with PPA in Sept 2016
By A O News Service
NAHARLAGUN | Sept 22 | Itanagar permanent bench of Gauhati High Court, judge justice Achintya Malla Bujor Barua today disposed of the WP(C) 613 (AP) of 216 case – petitioner Padi Richo (then Congress president) vs state assembly Speaker, secretary, Election Commission of India and 43 MLAs including Pema Khandu (present Chief Minister) as respondents.
The judge in his verdict said: “…while interpreting the case in conformity with the law laid down by Supreme Court in paragraph-42 of the Kashinath G. Jalmi (Supra), where in it had been clearly provided that the powers of the Speaker which he otherwise has while functioning as a Speaker in the House is not available when the Speaker discharges the powers under the Tenth Schedule. Although it had been held in Sri Rajendra Singh Rana (Supra) in paragraph-25 that a proceeding under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution is one to decide whether a member has become disqualified on the ground of the defection and the Tenth Schedule cannot be read or construed independent of Article-102 and 191 of the Constitution of India, but such observation does not give the power to the Speaker to exercise any of its powers under the Business Rules while exercising its jurisdiction under the Tenth Schedule or the powers under the Tenth Schedule, while exercising jurisdiction under the Business Rules.
“In the instant case, the order being assailed is the order dated 16.09.2016 of the Speaker wherein the information provided by the members in Form-III was asked to be published in the Bulletin Part-II by showing them as PPA MLAs and further to decide the claim of merger on being taken up as a defence in the event of their being a petition for disqualification.
“In the view of the Court, the publication referred in the order dated 16.09.2016 is not a publication of any paper, document, report in connection with the business of the House or laid on the Table of the House or presented to the House or a Committee thereof, in order to bring it within the purview of the Rule-321(1) of the Business Rules and accordingly, the privilege against any proceeding in any Court, as provided under Article 194(2) of the Constitution, is unavailable.
“In view of the such conclusion, the contention raised by the learned Advocate General that the present writ petition against the order dated 16.09.2016 of the Speaker of the 6th Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly is not maintainable in view of the provisions of the Article 194 (2) of the Constitution, is found to be unacceptable.
“In the premises above, the contentions raised by the petitioner that the claim of merger by 43 INC MLAs as flows from different resolutions of 16.09.2016 does not satisfy the requirements of a merger, both factually as well as under the law, as well as the contention that the 43 MLAs having been elected on the INC tickets by taking a recourse to the policies of the INC, which were found acceptable by the electorate, the INC would suffer loss and injuries on their claim of merger with the PPA, would now be taken up by the petitioner and other similarly situated persons of the INC before the speaker, while deciding the petition for disqualification dated 14.10.2016, which had already been filed.”
“This court does not express any opinion on its merit either on the validity or the acceptability of such contentions and it would for the speaker to consider and decide the same. In terms of the above, the writ petition stands disposed of.”
While senior advocate K C Mittal assisted by R S Jandhyalam represented the petitioner, a group of advocates led by advocate general N Dutta represented the respondents, according to certified copy of the HC verdict available with this daily.
