Beyond the Horizon
By Pradeep Kumar
As the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) emerged victorious in three Hindi heartland states – Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh – in 2023 Assembly polls, several opposition leaders have raised questions over electronic voting machines. As some opposition leaders have raised questions on Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs), BJP leaders mocked them, saying they are looking for excuses to hide their own shortcomings
Though more than 20 nations use the EVM like, direct vote-recording machines are used in 27 states, while 15 states use machines with paper audit trail machines in the best democracy of the world the US, but some fact about the EVM cannot be overlooked.
On 09.03.22, the Election Commission of India (ECI) had acted over EVM complaints and removed three UP officials from poll duty, a nodal officer for EVMs in Varanasi, a returning officer (RO) in Sonbhadra district and an additional election officer in Bareilly district were pulled out from election duties, a day ahead of the counting of votes in UP and replaced on the directions of ECI, as reported by the media. Three officials were removed from election duty; a day after Samajwadi Party had alleged that EVMs were being shifted in an unauthorized manner.
The most startling was Quint report by Sushovan Sircar on 25.01.19: The Hack of 2010.
In August 2010, Hyderabad-based engineer Hari K Prasad, who is currently technology advisor to Andhra Pradesh Govt. and MD of Netindia Private Limited, had received an actual EVM from an anonymous source. Upon his arrest on charges of theft, the police had claimed that the machine was stolen from a customs house in Mumbai where it was stored.
Prasad had collaborated with Halderman, a computer science professor of University of Michigan and Gonggrijp, a Dutch technology activist who was instrumental in having EVMs banned in the Netherlands. The three also had published a paper on their case study in which they detailed the attacks they carried out on the EVM.
“We had got the EVM machine for just one day and carried out all our experiments in a short period of time. If we had more time we could’ve demonstrated more methods of hacking,” said Prasad.
The case study explained in detailtwo methods employed to manipulate the EVM. Following are some important points about their case study: 1) Their experiment was performed on a second generation EVM or M2 (current EVMs are M3), 2) Both the hacks were carried out by physically manipulating the machine, 3) The hack was carried out on an actual EVM and not upon a replica.
To demonstrate how the EVM can be manipulated to favour a particular candidate, a dishonest display board was installed that can replace the real display board in the control unit.
Normally, when votes are counted, the EVM display board shows the number of votes received by each candidate. The dishonest display adds a separate, hidden micro controller that intercepts the vote totals and substitutes fraudulent results.
“Once the dishonest display is installed in an EVM (possibly months or years before the election), the attacker must communicate which candidate is to be favored (or disfavored), and by what margin,” the paper explained.
The display board of an EVM that was replaced with a dishonest display board. Pic: indiaevm.org
There are many different ways that attackers could send such a signal— with various kinds of radios, using secret combinations of key presses, or even by using the number of candidates on the ballot, the report added.
The Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) after 2003 assembly elections has raised controversy resulting in debate about its pros and cons. It was first used in India’s Parur Assembly polls in Kerala in 1982 and in all state elections and by-elections of the country in since 2003.
After rulings of Delhi High Court, Supreme Court, and demands from various political parties, Election Commission of India decided to introduce EVMs with voter-verified paper audit trail (VVPAT) system. The voter-verified paper audit trail (VVPAT), which enables electronic voting machines to record each vote cast by generating the EVM slip, was introduced in 8 of 543 parliamentary constituencies as a pilot project in 2014 general election and in all 543 Lok sabha constituencies in 2019 general election.
