By Pradeep Kumar
ITANAGAR | Apr 09 | ‘Every Action has an equal and opposite reaction!’, has been proved by Sir Issac Newton’s third law of physics. If demonitisation was an action how could its users escape from its reactions?
When empty ATMs of different banks in Capital Complex have been causing sufferings for account holders for them to make longer queue in front of cash-filled ATMs, a senior SBI officer on Saturday gave a vague reply to justify India’s largest CPSU bank’s efforts to normalise the situation.
He is right about regulating cash flow, but does SBI prints currency notes? If no, who are at fault – those who are responsible for printing or the transporters? Firstly, of total 180 bank branches in Arunachal Pradesh, including 57 SBI branches, ATMs in state’s twin capital cities of Itanagar and Naharlagun daily require Rs 13 crore. Why because paytm, bhim (online banking), freecharge etc, all initiatives under GoI’s Digidham, are almost distant dream not only in this hilly state but in almost all 12 Himalayan states as internet hardly works. It is but natural for the account holders to rush to ATMs and make ha-hola in finding them empty.
A consignment of about Rs 100+ crore currency notes was received recently. The amount is too meager for state’s 180 branches when cashless transaction is yet to be adopted by the masses. None could deny crisis of small currency notes (Rs 5,10, 20, 50 and 100) including Rs 500 and Rs 2000 notes since demonitisation. Will the poor people afford to transact with high value currency notes?
Where lies the fault then? Either the RBI is incapable of printing the currency notes or the transporters are unable to carry them to desired destinations. That is why the visible reactions!
The gospel truth is Prime Minister Narendra Modi was not given right briefing about demonitisation and its cascading impacts before he announced the withdrawal of Rs 500 and Rs 1000 notes on November 8-9, 2016. Had there been proper briefing, PM Modi would not have announced in public domain that Rs 500 and Rs 1000 notes will not remain legal tenders by the time the clock strikes 12 in mid night. For, one rupee note and all coins, printed/minted by the GoI, are only tender notes while Rs 2 to Rs 2,000 notes are promissory notes as printed on their bodies.
Why enough small currency notes were not printed ahead and made available all over India before demonitisation? It is common knowledge that currency notes will take longer time to reach any part of NE region from GoI mints at Kolkata, Hyderabad, Noida and Mumbai.
When there is no cash, internet non-functional, the remonitisation process will naturally take longer time. Mass sufferings is a natural process during this gestation period for which all stakeholders should be mentally ready and the bankers, mint operators and transporters need to play very proactive roles to complete the remonitisation process.
The demonitisation aims at checking misuse of high value Indian currency notes by anti-nationals from across the border to weaken the economy by pumping in fake notes besides to speed up economic liberalisation process.
It was former PM P VNarasimha Rao, who had spearheaded economic liberalisation policies in early 19990s involving reformist economist Dr Manmohan Singh as finanaceminister, whose benefits albeit late but are enjoyed by every citizen today. Thus, Rao was often referred to as Chanakya for his ability to steer tough economic and political legislations through Parliament despite heading a minority Govt.
In fact, the SBI by 1990 end was in a serious economic crisis. The GoI was close to default with the RBI refusing new credit and foreign exchange reserves. Thus, India had to pledge 20 tonnes of gold to Union Bank of Switzerland and 47 tonnes to Bank of England as part of a bailout deal with the IMF. Thus, most of the economic reforms since 1985 were forced upon India as a part of the IMF bailout.
PM Modi’s initiative is laudable to help India march with global economy and gain the status of developed (‘high-income country’- status from present developing (‘lower-middle income’) tag of the World Bank, but the Indian Govt channel, the longest in the world, has to be shortened for the plan to act effective.
But, “Monetization is a hollow move’, wrote India Central Programme as India lost 86% of its monetary base. At least Rs 12,000 crore would be spent in printing new notes and nobody knows how much in the logistics of exchanging the currency”, International Growth Centre (IGC) country director Pronab Sen said and on 08.12.16 and had questioned: Will such huge expenditure not cause inflation? If yes, the masses should be ready to face it soon. The cost of replacement of old ATMs by new ones once added would undoubtedly result in severe inflation and the burden would not be on the black money hoarders whose number could by minuscule but on the common masses.
The cost of withdrawing high-denomination currency notes to wipe out black money from the country will be about Rs 1.28 lakh crore during the 50-day window till December 30, the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) ET Bureau reported on. However, private economy watcher CMIE estimating overall conservative cost of demonitisation on 25.11.16 said that the GoI and the RBI are estimated to bear a cost of Rs 16,800 crore, largely on account of printing new currency notes and transporting them to banks, ATMs and post offices.
It takes about a week for trucks to carry goods from mainland to this land-locked state for no goods train service.Currency notes arrival by road will be delayed as finance managers will not press helicopter. Thus, sufferings, of Arunachalee account holders, hit hard by demonitisation, natural byproducts of plans with mismatched actions, will continue till remonitisation is complete.
